Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Need More "Open Time" for a Tricky Glue-Up

Posts

Need More "Open Time" for a Tricky Glue-Up

#1

Mark Meier (Ann Arbor, MI)

Need More "Open Time" for a Tricky Glue-Up

Mark Meier (Ann Arbor, MI)

>I'm building some sculpture stands.... Here's a link to the original post.

I have all the parts made - now I need to glue them up. I'm using biscuit joinery and everything fits well. However it takes my friend and I about 20 minutes to get everything glued, positioned, and clamped (we've done 3 practice runs and that's as fast as we think we'll realistically get). We've thought about gluing one of the 3 sides alone and then attaching the other two sides but even that's a bit tricky since it's hard to clamp and the angles need to be tight and right on for everything to work.

Sooo... what I'd really like is a glue with more open time. Titebond III allows 10 minutes. Titebond Extend allows 15.

Anybody know of a product that can give me 20 or 30 minutes before things set up?

Thanks in advance!

Mark


img

Re: Need More "Open Time" for a Tricky Glue-Up

#2

Re: Need More "Open Time" for a Tricky Glue-Up

chuck_w

>Have you thought of using liquid hide glue?

Re: Need More "Open Time" for a Tricky Glue-Up

#3

Re: Need More "Open Time" for a Tricky Glue-Up

Dave Paine

>I think if you look at the options for epoxy you should find one with sufficient open time. Expoxy can be accelerated or retarded based on additives.

Re: Need More "Open Time" for a Tricky Glue-Up

#4

Mask off the joints...and *LINK*

Grant in Iowa

>Try Dap Weldwood plastic resin glue. I use this when doing laminate bending because of the generous open time. I have taken as long as 30 minutes to get a glue up in the vacuum bag.

Note the requirement for 70 degrees plus for cure... you can use this to your advantage too by not raising the room temp until the clamps are on, then taking it up to 80 or so.

Every time I use it, I wonder why more people don't use it. it comes as a fine powder that looks like cinnamon and sugar... you mix it with room temp water, following the instructions and apply it with a brush.

You might have to order some online, as I have trouble finding it locally.

Regards,

Grant in Iowa


Weldwood

Re: Need More "Open Time" for a Tricky Glue-Up

#5

Epoxy would be my choice.

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>Epoxy does need heat to kick, so you don't really need to buy a slow cure if your shop is cool, which is not uncommon this time of year. I have done glue-ups where I took several hours gluing in cool weather, then thrown a tarp over it with a space heather inside to warm it up for the cure.

I do however warm it up while mixing, then work in a cool shop, then warm it up after everything is ready.

Re: Need More "Open Time" for a Tricky Glue-Up

#6

JL

Hide or liquid hide glue...

JL

>You figure I had to fit 20+ spindles through the hoop and the arm posts. I then had to hammer all the wedges home. The bottoms were set with Titebond I. I used hide glue for the tops. It took a bit of time.


img

Re: Need More "Open Time" for a Tricky Glue-Up

#7

I had a problem like this one......

Bill Tindall

>I used urethane adhesive (gorilla glue).

Re: Need More "Open Time" for a Tricky Glue-Up

#8

Re: Need More "Open Time" for a Tricky Glue-Up

McKay

>I made six of the three legged tables that you have a picture of and the only part that I had difficulty with was the top that had to be splined. Yellow glue added too much moisture and so I used hide glue to keep the splines from swelling. The mortise and tenon joints on all of the legs went together nicely with titebond on all six joints. Just be organized at glue up time and it should go well.

Re: Need More "Open Time" for a Tricky Glue-Up

#9

It's not the Glue, It's the Application

Rick Christopherson

>I see this question get asked over and over, yet the solution is not buying a different glue--granted, glue manufacturers would love for you to buy into that (pun intended).

I cringe every time I see Norm Abram spread glue with a brush, and then in the next breath comment about how quickly he needs to work before it sets up. The one act causes the other.

The rate that a liquid dries is dependent on the ratio between the total volume versus the surface area. The thinner you spread the glue out, the faster it is going to dry. This should be pretty self-evident if you think about it: Pour 1 cup of water into a small puddle on the floor, and then take another cup of water and spread it out across the floor in a thin film. Which of the two is going to dry the fastest? Obviously the one that was spread out.

The same is true with your glue application. When you spread your glue out in an attempt to avoid squeeze-out, you cause the glue to dry faster. Instead, lay the glue out in thicker beads, and let the compression of the workpieces spread the glue at the time of assembly.

It isn't necessary to flood the area with glue to accomplish this. You can still limit the volume of glue by applying smaller areas of bead, but just keep the individual beads thick.

Furthermore, the only reason to apply glue to both surfaces is when you spread it out too thin to begin with. If you don't spread it thin, you also don't need to apply to both surfaces. The glue will spread to both surfaces as long as you have used enough to do so.

Re: Need More "Open Time" for a Tricky Glue-Up

#10

Re: Need More "Open Time" for a Tricky Glue-Up

Glenn Madsen---in SF Bay Area------WebKitFormBound

>That's my first idea, too.

There's also some stuff called Roo Glue, which has a really long open time. Works for melamine, too. I got mine at the plywood dealer I work with in the Bay Area.

Re: Need More "Open Time" for a Tricky Glue-Up

#11

Lee Valley to the rescue (as usual)

Neal in San Jose

>I like their 2002 GF glue. Besides being gap filling (that's the GF part of the name), it has an advertised open time of 15 to 20 minutes. With my shop pretty cool this time of year, I have done some complicated glue ups with no problems. I haven't timed it, but I think 20 minutes is reasonable if your shop is on the cool side.

Re: Need More "Open Time" for a Tricky Glue-Up

#12

plastic resin glue or epoxy

Chris Friesen

>The Lee Valley 2002 GF glue gets you reasonable assembly times, but I don't like pushing the envelope. Also, it's a PVA glue which means that it's not easily repairable down the road.

Various epoxies will give anywhere from 20 minutes to 2 hrs of open assembly time. I have some "cold cure" stuff that will cure at just above freezing, which can be useful in a cold shop. (Takes a long time to cure at those temperatures though.) Epoxy is also structurally gap-filling, which is nice if your mortices are not absolutely perfectly machined.

As someone else mentioned, plastic resin also gives good open times, but it has a minimum temperature to cure that is higher than epoxy or regular wood glue.

Re: Need More "Open Time" for a Tricky Glue-Up

#13

Mark Meier (Ann Arbor, MI)

Re: plastic resin glue or epoxy

Mark Meier (Ann Arbor, MI)

>Chris,

Thanks for the suggestion. Do you have a specific brand or type in mind for an epoxy?

Also, what is the nature of clean-up for epoxies? I'm sure some will squeeze out and I need something I can easily clean off that won't affect the finish.

Thanks,

Mark

Re: Need More "Open Time" for a Tricky Glue-Up

#14

Mark Meier (Ann Arbor, MI)

Re: Need More "Open Time" for a Tricky Glue-Up

Mark Meier (Ann Arbor, MI)

>Thanks very much for the comments everyone. It's clear I have several good options.

Mark

Re: Need More "Open Time" for a Tricky Glue-Up

#15

Re: Need More "Open Time" for a Tricky Glue-Up

Barry Irby

>I would suggest West System or System 3 epoxy. Take any advice I give you with a grain of salt because I don't have a ton of experience with epoxy. I had very mixed results with the stuff I bought at the borgs. Had excellent results with the System 3 stuff I bought at WoodCraft, but, again it was a one time thing. I assembled four 15" wide boards into a box with nine dovetails on each corner. Don't know what the time was, but it was fairly slow 20 to 30 minutes. I tinted the epoxy to match the walnut and was pretty happy with that.

You can clean up with alcohol or paint thinner. I usually tape off the area with blue painters tape and then wait till the squeeze out is thick and sort of rubbery to clean up. I try to be sparing with the liquid because I don't want it to soak into the joint and damage the epoxy. Wear Gloves. None of this stuff is good for you. Not horrible, but epoxy can be a sensitizer and the alcohol may have some pretty bad stuff as a denaturant.

Incidentally, I used a brush to slather on the epoxy. Just using a brush does not mean you have to be stingy with the glue. The glue acted like a lubricant. Joints that required a little persuasion before slipped right together. Epoxy might pay off for that because unlike PVA it does not contain water which might make the wood swell.

Re: Need More "Open Time" for a Tricky Glue-Up

#16

Re: Need More "Open Time" for a Tricky Glue-Up

Scott Crumpton

>Everyone's focused on the glue and not the process...

Why not glue it up in stages? Assemble the entire unit dry. Use strap clamps between adjacent legs, not around the entire assembly. Now open up one side and glue the joints on one side of one leg only. Clamp and allow to set. Open up the next side and glue the next leg. Re-clamp and allow to set. Do it to the third side. Now you have 3 legs glued on one side each. Half your gluing is completed. Break it apart and glue up the remaining 3 sets of joints.

Re: Need More "Open Time" for a Tricky Glue-Up

#17

Re: plastic resin glue or epoxy *LINK*

Chris Friesen

>There are lots of good epoxies: Industrial Formulators, West System, System Three, etc. As for cleanup, there's a good writup at the link below. Generally you want to be wearing an organic vapour respirator.


http://www.glen-l.com/supplies/pxman-cleanup.html

Re: Need More "Open Time" for a Tricky Glue-Up

#18

Re: My thought as well

David Hay @ Denver

>

Re: Need More "Open Time" for a Tricky Glue-Up

#19

Re: Need More "Open Time" for a Tricky Glue-Up

NickB

>My 2 go-to long open time adhesives are epoxy (with slow catalyst) and liquid hide glue. I would suggest the liquid hide glue because of the fact that you are using biscuits, which need a little moisture to swell up and lock the joint.

Hope this helps,

Nick