Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Opinions on how to approach this repair

Posts

Opinions on how to approach this repair

#1

JL

Opinions on how to approach this repair

JL

>I could turn another side stretcher. This would mean disassembling the entire chair. I'm not sure I want to go that way. The chair has been in use for a while with the broken stretcher.

I can (with a moderate amount of force) spread the legs apart so I have 1/4" or more distance between the two parts of the stretcher. I thought about putting a pin (nail, machine screw thread or whatever) and gluing the pieces together with epoxy and the pine. If I can't get a straight line with drilling, I could easily cut a slot in the bottom of the two pieces and pin it that way.

Thoughts and suggestions please.

TIA


img

Re: Opinions on how to approach this repair

#2

Based on the PIC

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>1. I'd remove the short piece and center-drill a 5/16 hole.

2. I'd reinsert the drilled piece with a locator pin tapped in and make a point impression in the log piece as close to center as possible.

3. Remove the short piece and drill another 5/16 hole into the long piece.

4. Rejoin the pieces with epoxy and a 1/4" dowel. The 5/16 hole will give enough wiggle room and the resin will fill the gap. Then glue back into the leg

A little care and some luck and the repair won't show.

Re: Opinions on how to approach this repair

#3

Re: Based on the PIC

Joseph Mulherin, Sr.

>I agree with Mark. I have done almost the same repair in yrs past and the chair is still operational.

Re: Opinions on how to approach this repair

#4

Clint Searl

Splint and baling wire

Clint Searl

>

Re: Opinions on how to approach this repair

#5

JL

Sounds reasonable.

JL

>

Re: Opinions on how to approach this repair

#6

Re: Based on the PIC

john lucas

>JL I've done several repairs like that. I drill it as best I can and use a piece of All thread rod as my dowel. Epoxy will fill the gap so If I can't drill the holes perfectly straight I simply drill them oversize just enough to get the all thread in there and the 2 pieces lined up. This has proven to be a very durable repair.

Re: Opinions on how to approach this repair

#7

Re: Opinions on how to approach this repair

Philip Duffy

>You could remove the broken pieces, turn a new one and steam bend it so it would go into the old holes - -that you had cleaned out. Once it is in place it dries and is solid as new. Did it once and it is still a good chair. Good luck. Phil

Re: Opinions on how to approach this repair

#8

Another Opinion

David Yoho

>JL, reading the current responses suggests drilling, pinning with a steel rod, and epoxy has worked. You can't argue with results like that... well, except me. I see several problems in your situation.

One is the fact that you say you can basically only spread the joint/break by about 1/4". Not only does this not give enough distance to remove the short piece from the leg (I'd think the tenon goes in the leg more than 1/4") but it also doesn't make for enough space to do any accurate drilling while in place. The other issue (maybe) looks like there isn't much room on the longer piece to drill into before getting into the mortise cavity for the cross stretcher's tenon.

Short of Philip's suggestion, which sounds doable but tedious, my thoughts tend to center toward repairing what's there. I'm wondering if you wouldn't be better off with some variation of your slot idea.

If you can cut a fairly straight and regular slot on the bottom side, I think I'd try that. I'd start by gluing the break and clamping it first. This gets the spindle together and the profile lined up. Once dry, cut your slot about 3/16 or more wide, as deep as you care to chance, and as long as seems right to you. Cut a strip of wood to fit the width of the slot, shape the ends to sit into the slot if the slot was cut with a rotary tool, and make the piece wide enough to stick out beyond the highest point of the spindle's profile. Epoxy it in, let dry, and shape the excess to match up with the profile. Paint the repair and you're done.

David

Re: Opinions on how to approach this repair

#9

JL

Again, sounds reasonable.

JL

>I would not want to do Philip's suggestion. It would mean disassembling the chair. The center stretcher would have to be fitted and I would have to spread the legs apart.

I can cut a slot with a Dremel tool. That is relatively easy. I think I'll try it this way.

Re: Opinions on how to approach this repair

#10

Did the same

Al Goldstein

>I agree. This is the way I fixed some broken spindles on a stair rail in my first house. After removing the spindles I cut a 2 inch saw kerf along the central axes of each piece. Then made a roughly 4 inch long spline to fit in both kerfs. Put the spindle pieces back into the stair rail and then glued the spline in place using supports to align the two pieces straight. Then some files and sandpaper shaped the spline. After some paint the repair was invisible at distances greater than a few feet.

The long grain glue joint made this repair very strong. Good luck.

Re: Opinions on how to approach this repair

#11

What's wrong with duct tape?

Gary Evans--Tallassee TN

>

Re: Opinions on how to approach this repair

#12

or use a couple of brads while the glue dries.

Virgil Johnson

>drys

Re: Opinions on how to approach this repair

#13

Re: Opinions on how to approach this repair-MAGIC

Justin Szeliga

>"The chair has been in use for a while with the broken stretcher."

Just use the incantation, Ima getuit, Ima getuit......

Re: Opinions on how to approach this repair

#14

The easy way....

Marv

>I would go to that fat part to the right of the right angle cross piece and saw it at an extreme angle using a thin blade dovetail saw. Once the fat part is sawed through you can then wiggle the piece off the cross piece and you will then be able to drill straight into the broken short piece to the left and also drill a matching hole in the piece you have in your hand. Glue your dowel into both pieces and slip it back onto the cross piece and then glue and clamp where you sawed with the dovetail saw. Allow to dry and then sand the saw cut so it's even all around then paint it.

Marv