Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Garage Heat

Posts

Garage Heat

#1

Garage Heat

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>My lathe has been relegated to the unheated garage where it's colder than a witch's . . . refrigerator.

If I'm going to be doing any turning, I'm gonna have get some heat out there, and am considering a 35,000 BTU "torpedo" for the 25x30x8 foot space. Runs 11 hours on a 20lb propane tank so I figure I'll get 2-3 days work out of a tank.

Tips, brands, etc. are welcome.

No, no permanent, through-the-wall, installations will be done here. This is strictly a "temp" situation.

[Stop it, George!]

mm

Re: Garage Heat

#2

I got the orange one from

Dustmaker Mike

>the orange Borg about 5 years ago. It is noise smells like propane but does a great job of heating my garage. I have one little problem with it right now that it will not stay running unless the start bypass switch is held in. I just taped it over and it works fine. I am looking at installing a permanent NG heater some time this spring.

Re: Garage Heat

#3

All Pro 35000 BTU

Dustmaker Mike

>

Re: Garage Heat

#4

Clint Searl

Re: Garage Heat

Clint Searl

>A radiant unit on top of a 20# tank backed up by a little oscillating fan served me well for 13 years in my double garage shop. Quiet and effective.

Clint

Re: Garage Heat

#5

Moisture issues - RUST

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

>Any unvented gas or kerosene heater puts a LOT of moisture in the air, which will condense on any cold tool surface. I'v got some pretty rusty tools from a number of years using a kerosene torpedo. I switched to a natural gas unit heater and all moisture problems went away.

If this is just for occasional use, you're probably ok with the conbustion or radiant type. But I would not consider this a long term arrangement unless you like rust.

Re: Garage Heat

#6

Re: Garage Heat

Barry Irby

>I have two or three heaters for my shop. My shop is about half the size of yours, its in a basement and is insulated. I have a 40,000 Btu torpedo, and a radiant glow heater that will mount on top of a propane tank, and a Little Buddy brand heater. I also have an electric "barn" heater. What I find is that the the torpedo is way too big and I never use it. The glow heater gets a little use, but it is too big also and i can only run it a few minutes and have to turn it off. I have never bothered to hook up the Little Buddy, but I bought it because it was about 15000 Btus or smaller and I figured I could run it for longer periods of time. What I do now Is turn on the barn heater about an hour in advance and then go to work in the shop. If I was In a hurry, I would run the glow heater for maybe half and hour and then let the barn heater take over.

I find I like the electric heat much better. No odor, no fuel to haul in, less risk of fire, less noise, no CO, etc and it does not generate moisture. Gas heaters put out a significant amount of moisture vapor and yow may find rust developing on your tools. The electric heater has a crude thermostat on it and if I leave it on, it cuts itself off and does not over heat the shop. I got a phone call once and came back to the shop after a lengthy conversation and it was so hot I thought I was going to have to open the door and there was condensation on everything.

If I were you I would look for some sort of heater that had two speeds so I could get a blast of heat and then turn it down to a low firing rate and with a thermostat to shut it off when it reaches the right temp. I would get the smallest on I thought could do the job. Or get a smallish gas heater and an electric one. You could also put a curtain around your work area to confine the heat to where you are working.

Re: Garage Heat

#7

Alternative

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Looked at several of those, but unsure as to the capacity. How many "burners" did yous have? I've got a small 115 muffin fan that would be easy to incorporate and the tank-top deal would save a bit of space. Brand?

Re: Garage Heat

#8

Re: RUST

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Since the only unpainted cast iron is the top of the lathe's ways, a bit of rust just helps the banjo grip better.

I do have a pair of 20 amp circuits available so the electric option is still doable.

Re: Garage Heat

#9

Re: Garage Heat

xeddog

>I have tried one of those torpedo heaters in my garage. It makes a heck of a lot of noise, stinks to high heaven, and does produce moisture. It creates so much noise and odor that I just don't use it. Also, you are not supposed to use these in enclosed spaces so you have to have a lot of cold air coming in anyway.

It sounds like you want heat in just one area, so you might consider something like these: http://www.sunrayz.us/ceramic.html. I don't have any but that is what I am going to be looking into.

xeddog

Re: Garage Heat

#10

Re: Garage Heat

mdclor

>Mark,

I used to use a Mr Heater with 3 burners on top of a propane tank. I would light 1, 2 or all 3 depending on the ambient temperature. It worked well, but as others have mentioned it did put a lot of moisture into the air.

FWIW,

Merle

Re: Garage Heat

#11

question

Dan Donaldson

>do you really need to heat the entire space, or are you mainly concerned with the area around the lathe. I have one of those quartz tube heaters in my garage (I do not use the garage for woodworking) and it does a nice job of heating the space below it. It covers an area that would do a lathe. It heats by radiation, so it heats the objects below it and not the air. It might work for you if there are not many breezes in the garage.

Re: Garage Heat

#12

Re: Garage Heat

Joseph Mulherin, Sr.

>Mark, check into the heaters the Amish are selling now. The advertising seems to cover exactly what you need.

Re: Garage Heat

#13

Space

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>On the ceiling is the problem here, Dan. When I float the lathe out to the operating position, I've got the hoist and lighting tracks above. While the garage ceiling is code-compliant, I'd still be a bit leery of a fixed heat source up there about 2-1/2 feet over my head even if I could fit it in.

I will, however, look into the quartz option with (perhaps) a couple of 1500+ watt reflector jobs. Have a friend who uses a kero-torpedo, but he has to open the garage door from time-to-time. Kinda defeats the purpose.

Re: Garage Heat

#14

Thanks All

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>I knew that a properly running propane heater puts out H2O + CO2, but I really didn't anticipate "that much" moisture. On the other hand, I don't want to be turning in a fog, either.

Seems like a couple of quartz deals with a small fan for convection may be the better answer.

mm

Re: Garage Heat

#15

unless that's the only iron or steel

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>in the garage, I assure something's going to rust. I did the very same thing with a propane heater and every tool in my shop that wasn't painted got rust. EVERY one. Table saw, plane blades, chisels, wrenches, screws.

Re: Garage Heat

#16

Clint Searl

Re: Alternative

Clint Searl

>Two burner. It's been tucked away since I built my HVAC'ed shop. Don't know if it will fit the new tanks, but it's yours for the taking if you pass close to Haycock Mtn.

Clint

Re: Garage Heat

#17

Re: iron or steel

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Cars are either painted, chromed, or plastic, snow blower's rusty already, chainsaws are oiled, everything else is the the nice dry basements, and the law mower wore out 12 years ago.

But do think the electric is the way to go. With 2 20 amp circuits, I can run 2 1500 watt heaters to warm things up and then just one to maintain the temp, at $25 a piece, this is sounding more like a plan.

This board's experience has (again) saved me from a mistake.

mm

Re: Garage Heat

#18

Not Fer 'Crost the Crick

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Might do for a road trip.

Re: Garage Heat

#19

Re: Garage Heat

ben d.

>I use a Dayton 220 volt electric 20000 btu and this week when it has been 5 to 15 degrees it keeps my 20 x 30 warm at about 1/2 turn on the temp dial. Has a fan and thermostat much better than the propane tank heaters and no smell, fan not that noisy either. I think you can get them that runs on 110 volt that is 17000 btu output.

Bought mine off e-bay for $150.00.

ben

Re: Garage Heat

#20

Re: Garage Heat

Randy Johnson

>How much do you use it and what kind of electric bills do you get?

I installed a smaller unit (I think 4000 W) where it would blow down on me when I was using the lathe. My thought was that on really cold days I wouldn't have to turn the main propane heater past fifty and heat the entire shop when I was turning. After the first month's electric bill came, I decided that propane was cheaper.

Re: Garage Heat

#21

Re: Garage Heat

Lewis Dodd-aka-- RIPSAWED

>Uhhhh, started to say move South, but it is 14 degrees outside right now (close to San Antonio, Texas)!

You don't make no mistakes on that thar lathe?

I got two potbelly wood burning stoves and I seem to never run out of wood for them!!! I put in several "chimneys" and move them to the location needed, I just block off the "not in use" chimneys when I move the stove.

No codes to worry about down here!

Lewis (;>))

Re: Garage Heat

#22

Up Year and Down Yonder

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>"Garage" up here is part of the house with living space above. Y'all put walls on the carport and call it done. |;-}}}}

No chimneys or pot bellies in this space, code or no code.

Mistakes? on the lathe? Naw, just making round kindling.