Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Dovetails Conundrum

Posts

Dovetails Conundrum

#1

Dovetails Conundrum

charlie belden

>My second woodworking projects was a wall hanging tool cabinet, with basically shallow box doors for storing more tools in (the first project was a router table cabinet - with half blind dovetails drawers for the JoinTech Cabinet Maker System).

This wall cabinet holds a ton of tools, figuratively speaking, with chisels in one door and squares, a bevel gauge, small hammers, an old wood mallet, coping saw with blades box, a Gents saw - well you get the idea. The things been hanging on the wall - loaded - for over eight years.

A couple of days ago I go out to the shop to get something and something didn't look right but I wasn't sure what. I'd left this cabinet's doors open, intending to put a chisel and and small coping saw back - and hadn't closed them,

One of the doors was hanging at an odd angle. The dovetail joints on the piano hinged side of the door had opened up. I'm pretty sure I glued ALL the dovetail joints in both doors.

I made a seven drawer unit for under the drill press years ago and never got around to glueing the drawers' dovetails. The drawers have worked fine - for years.

So I'm looking at dovetail joints - and this cabinet door joint failure - and it occured to me that the Rules for Dovetails - pins in the front and back, or top and bottom, and tails in the sides - have at least one exception - which I seemed to have managed to find (see attached illustration).

Have YOU found any other Exceptions To The Rules?


img

Re: Dovetails Conundrum

#2

Re: Dovetails Conundrum

Fred Davis

>Charlie ,

a couple of things to remember when designing weight bearing projects is....Gravity is on full time and the worst strain is a steady one.

I would lay the doors down on the bench on their backs, pull and glue the joints back into place and drill a 1/8th inch hole through the pins and tails and tap in a 1/8th inch Brass rod.

That should do it.

FredD

Re: Dovetails Conundrum

#3

Re: Dovetails Conundrum *LINK*

charlie belden

>Fred:

I like your suggestion to use brass rods rather than wood dowels. And adding them as "decorative elements" - yet another OOPS can become a

"design feature"!

Thankfully I went with a modular approach to the tool holders so they can be removed - with their tools in place - to lighten the carcase and doors for hanging (see attached link). Am NOT looking foreward to removing 30 little brass screws in the door's piano hinges - then replacing them once the "enhancement" is complete. Think a trip to ACE hardware for some spare screws would be a prudent thing to do.

And while I'm at it, maybe I'll do the brass rod reinforcement/design feature on the other cabinet as well (I made two figuring, rightly, that I'd need the other one eventually). And maybe - just maybe - I'll fix the right door lower than the left door by 1/8" or so - as well.

Sometimes crisis presents opportunities. It's all about how you look at things I guess.

Again, thanks for the great suggestion/solution.

This "crisis" does raise the question of Just Pins On One, Just Tails On The Other. There are situations when a Mix (Pins on one end, Tails on the other) has advantages over the standard dovetails arrangement. This is one such case.

Can YOU think of other special cases where the "standard dovetails arrangement" may not be the best solution?


modular tool holders

Re: Dovetails Conundrum

#4

Re: Dovetails Conundrum

Barry Irby

>Those little brass screws are an ideal place to use your drill with a clutch. Set it at the lowest setting that will drive the screws (1 or 2 on mine)and drive them. That way you won't break them. I go a little light on them and then give the chuck a little twist by hand if they don't quite make it home.

I would tap the dovetails back into position and put the brass rod in and then soak them with thin CA. It will wick into the joints. May not be able to glue glue to glue, but it will fill any remaining space and add some friction at worst. I would use a brad point bit to drill the hole for the rod. Brad point bits wander less for me.

Re: Dovetails Conundrum

#5

Re: Dovetails Conundrum

Fred Davis

>Without spending a lot of time speculating about possible Dovetail joint failure Charlie , it is my opinion that Dovetails solve more problems then they create.

That being said , think though your use of them in a unconventional way and you will realize whether your making a booby trap or not.

FreDd

Re: Dovetails Conundrum

#6

Ellis Walentine

Re: Dovetails Conundrum

Ellis Walentine

>Hi Charlie,

Your thinking about this issue seems logical enough. Joinery should always be designed to resist the forces anticipated on the finished assembly. And you're right about dovetails: they don't have much resistance to pullout parallel to the pins. But, there are other elements that you can use to your advantage as you design these things, notably reinforcements such as panels, gussets, glue blocks, etc., that take some of the pressure off the corner joints themselves.

You didn't mention what kind of panels these doors have. Plywood panels glued firmly into grooves in the frame would have improved the integrity and rack resistance of these doors greatly. If you used solid wood floating panels, you might have helped keep the frame intact by somehow triangulating the frame with a sturdy sub-assembly that has some other useful function like holding your tools.

This discussion underscores one of the first principles of furniture design, which is to anticipate all the force vectors that may come into play over the life of the piece.

Ellis

Re: Dovetails Conundrum

#7

Re: Dovetails Conundrum

charlie belden

>Alas, the door panels are resawn poplar with a subtle quiet flame/cathedral grain pattern and float in grooves. So they can't be structural.

To maximize the space in the doors for tool storage, glue blocks in the corners would've complicated the modular, removeable tool holders inserts.

Pinning the dovetails would, in hindsight, have been a prudent thing to do, given the application.

But this OOPS example does bring up joint selection - for the specific application. I went with dovetails for this cabinet's doors, thinking just turning a box/drawer on end. Had I looked at the forces the doors would experience, pinning would have been obvious. Dovetail splines acrossed the joint would've been another choice. Blind wedged mortise and tenon might work, or blind wedged loose tenons - maybe using dominos.

Got any other ideas for a joint to use in this case?

Re: Dovetails Conundrum

#8

Re: Dovetails Conundrum

Fred Davis

>Well , now that you asked....

Since it is a utility cabinet rather then fine furniture , at this stage, a couple of 2"x 2" L Brackets inside each corner wouldn't hurt a thing and would give you a stiffer corner, less susceptible to racking forces.

FredD

Re: Dovetails Conundrum

#9

Re: Dovetails Conundrum

charlie belden

>L brackets OUTSIDE could work. But inside - no space unless I mortised them in - the tool holder inserts wouldn't fit then.