Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

OT - Wood stove Air FLow

Posts

OT - Wood stove Air FLow

#1

OT - Wood stove Air FLow

Paul T (Upstate NY)

>Is it better to push air or pull air? I'm looking into putting a duct in my house to take hot air from the loft down to the entry way two stories below. When running the woodstove (located on the 2nd floor) the loft gets very hot but the entry way gets cold so I'm looking to get some of that hot air down below. Assumming I can run a duct and get a fan for it, would it be better to have the fan in the loft end of the duct and push the air or in the entry way and pull the air down?

TIA,

Paul

Re: OT - Wood stove Air FLow

#2

Clint Searl

Re: OT - Wood stove Air FLow

Clint Searl

>I think putting it at the top of the run will maximize the volume of hot air that gets into the ducting.

Clint

Re: OT - Wood stove Air FLow

#3

Dale Lenz

Re: OT - Wood stove Air FLow

Dale Lenz

>In your case not sure if it would matter, as long as you had the fan inside the duct work. Have less air turbulence if you pull air, it's more efficient to pull air in most cases. Automotive cooling fans pull air through the radiator. In air drying sheds you pull air though the lumber.

Good luck with you project.

Re: OT - Wood stove Air FLow

#4

Re: OT - Wood stove Air FLow

Marvin Horn

>Should make no difference- be sure to oversize the duct entrance and provide a smooth transition to your duct to minimize entrance losses.

Re: OT - Wood stove Air FLow

#5

Re: OT - Wood stove Air FLow

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I think the location is less important for efficiency than for noise - at which location will the sound of the fan be less instrusive?

Size your duct properly (this includes calculations of lost efficiency due to elbows), seal it well (NOT duct tape*), and, if it's running outside the heated part of the house (like inside an outer wall), insulate it thoroughly. A lot of ducts have pitifully thin insulation**.

*When I did sheet metal, we were using duct tape - but it dries out over time. I understand the modern standard is caulk and/or metal tape. If you use any adjustable elbows, seal each joint of the elbow too. And, of course, make sure you use three screws on round duct and at least four on rectangular duct, for a good tight mechanical fit and strength. The metal tape seals well but it's not very strong.

**Your house, if properly insulated even to older standards, will have at least R-19 in the ceiling and R-13 in the walls. To run some of your air outside that envelope and then insulate the duct - metal duct transmits heat very well - with 1" of something seems kinda silly.

Re: OT - Wood stove Air FLow

#6

Another option

Grant in Iowa

>If the loft area has a return air duct heading back to a forced air furnace, then you might already have what you need. Just set your thermostat fan control to "on" and not to "auto" during the times when you use the woodburner. This should help circulate the heat throughout the house. You can add to this effect by changing out return air duct grates in other areas for grates with dampers in them. In this way, you can control where the furnace draws its air year round for more even temperature control.

If you don't have return air ducts in the loft area, you might consider extending that system instead of creating a separate duct and fan.

If the loft area is in conjunction with a large great room where the woodburner is located, you might consider installing a large ceiling fan to pull the warm air downward.

Knowing more about the layout of where the heat is created, where it goes, and where it is needed would be helpful.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa<---heats about 50% with wood.

Re: OT - Wood stove Air FLow

#7

Re: OT - Wood stove Air FLow

ehgauss

>My instinct says that a fan is a volumetric flow device. Therefore, operating at the same speed, a greater mass of denser cold air will be moved than of less dense warm air. To me that says that for the greatest effectiveness, locating the fan at the colder location is preferable. Another factor, that probably isn't much of a factor for the temperature range you're dealing with, is that a fan motor operated in cold air will run cooler, and therefore have a longer life.

Re: OT - Wood stove Air FLow

#8

Re: OT - Wood stove Air FLow

Gary Evans--Tallassee TN

>I think you may be happier with the fan at the top of your duct or in the middle somewhere, depending on the noise issue. If you put it at the bottom, you will need to direct the flow so that it doesn't blow directly on someone in that room. Unless the air is 98 degrees or warmer, it will feel cold blowing directly on the skin.

We use a duct to pull warm air from the peak of our roof down into our bathroom. Next time, I will put the fan somewhere besides the outlet of the duct.

Gary

Re: OT - Wood stove Air FLow

#9

Jesper, Denmark

Re: OT Makes absolutely no difference......

Jesper, Denmark

>Put the fan where it the easiest to operate and where any noise is least objectionable - even in the middle of the duct.

Re: OT - Wood stove Air FLow

#10

Clint Searl

Re: OT - Wood stove Air FLow

Clint Searl

>It's either at the top or at the bottom or in the middle or not at all or it doesn't matter. Sounds like the blind leading the blind. LOL

Like Big Mouth Billy Bass says, "Don't worry, be happy."

Clint