Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

OT propane camp stove indoors

Posts

OT propane camp stove indoors

#1

OT propane camp stove indoors

Jerry Gibbs

>Our propane camp stove warns against indoor use because of CO poisoning. What is the difference between a camp stove and a regular household stove that uses natural or propane gas? The household gas stoves I have used seemed to have no special venting. Jerry Gibbs

Re: OT propane camp stove indoors

#2

Clint Searl

Re: OT propane camp stove indoors

Clint Searl

>I used to use a propane radiant heater in my garage shop. It had a CO alarm. Neither it nor I ever went off.

Clint

Re: OT propane camp stove indoors

#3

Re: OT propane camp stove indoors

Craig in Silverdale

>I have a 200 sq ft cabin with a Coleman two burner stove. Been using it for the past five years, and as far as I know, I haven't died. Don't think I'd try to heat the cabin with it.

Re: OT propane camp stove indoors

#4

Re: OT propane camp stove indoors

Justin Szeliga

>As long as it burns blue it should be burning hot enough to produce only CO2 & H2O. If it burns yellow it's going to be burning incompletely & the the danger is raised.

Re: OT propane camp stove indoors

#5

Jesper, Denmark

Re: OT propane camp stove indoors

Jesper, Denmark

>There should be no difference. When used for cooking, the CO produced is so small that it has no effect.

Re: OT propane camp stove indoors

#6

Warning lable . . .

steve mackay

>As in most cases the warning lable is there because someone did it and died. I've used gas stoves and lights in small tents even and still here. You gotta figure that it was some total idiot, locked himself in a closet and fired the thing up, fell aslepp and it burned 'till empty. If you notice, now a days, charcole BBQ grills have the same warning. And, yes Virginia, we have several deaths a year here in El Paso from idiots doing it. Same line every time . . ."Well he was poor and cold. " Well, now hes dead.

Re: OT propane camp stove indoors

#7

Re: Warning lable . . .

Barry Turner

>Soemtimes these warning labels appear to be stupid, but please don't underestimate the stupidity of some people. I worked for a health department for 37+ years and saw a variety of adverse situations. I accompanied a health nurse on a home visit one afternoon. Once inside, we discovered the means of heat was a wood stove that had no stove pipe of chimney connection of any sort. They were burning coal in the stove and the small children were about as black. Had we stayed very long, so would we. The house had enough broken out windows so that CO was not much of a concern. The head of the household just couldn't seem to grasp what our concern was. We finally got them into better housing.

Re: OT propane camp stove indoors

#8

Re: OT propane camp stove indoors

Barry Irby

>Jerry, I have not looked it up lately, but I believe that kitchen stoves don't have to be vented unless they are over 25,000 btus per hour. Smaller/regular ranges are not over the limit, whatever it is. The larger ranges with six burners and double ovens may not qualify for the exemption and have to be vented and the vent has to be built as if it were a flue.

The theory on all this is that generally ranges don't produce much CO and the house will be leaky enough for it to escape harmlessly if they do.

And the information about blue flames is correct. If the flames are hot and blue there is likely to be very little CO. On problem with ranges or camp stoves could be "impinging" where the flames touch the pot and the pot cools the flame and causes it to produce CO/incomplete combustion. (Also a problem with improperly assembled gas logs, where the flames "lick" the logs.)

So, small gas heaters are relatively safe indoors. As an aside, 18% of what they put out is steam or moisture vapor. I have seen several houses where people used a number of small heaters indoors during very cold weather and there was condensation drooling off everything. In one case the wall paper literally fell off the walls and everything in the closets was black with mold.

Re: OT propane camp stove indoors

#9

Re: Warning lable . . .

Randy Johnson

>The company I work for is primarily a natural gas supplier but we sell and install hot water heaters. I know of two cases where, when someone went to look at what would be involved in installing a heater, they found the existing heater venting into the house. In one case the heater was in the bathroom. Like you say, the homeowner didn�t see anything wrong with it.

Re: OT propane camp stove indoors

#10

What is the problem with that

Dustmaker Mike

>they didn't want to waste the heat. It makes you say Hum some times when you see stuff like that.

Re: OT propane camp stove indoors

#11

Re: Warning lable . . .

Barry Turner

>Yeah, but I'm not talking about a gas heater. There was coal soot and smoke going into the living room! Of course the woman wasn't the sharpest knife in the drawer...........

Re: OT propane camp stove indoors

#12

Re: Warning lable . . .

Randy Johnson

>Granted, coal would be many times worse, but CO is CO.

I've had more than one leak call while on standby where the problem was a vent that had been knocked loose from the flue. The people who called those in noticed something. How you could take a bath while the water heater was belching exhaust a few feet away is beyond me.