Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Accelerating varnish curing

Posts

Accelerating varnish curing

#1

Accelerating varnish curing

Brandon in Cincinnati

>Hello everyone. I sit on the bench a lot around here, but now I have a question that I was hoping to get some advice on. In order to speed up the cure time of a piece I am brush-on varnishing in the 50 degree basement of my house, I was considering constructing a small tent using plastic sheeting around the piece and heating the tent with a small electric space heater to speed the curing process after applying the final coat. I have the piece hanging from the joists while I am applying the varnish. Heating the entire basement is not an option, as the house is 125 years old with a very drafty stone foundation wall.

Should I be concerned about explosion/fire hazard with the combination of the electric space heater and the fumes?

My plan is to leave the bottom of the tent hanging just shy of the floor a few inches for ventilation while not allowing all of the heat to escape. I am also running a homemade exhaust fan in the basement using a cheap box fan and some 4� pipe through a window. So far I have put two coats on, 24 hours apart and they seem to be drying ok. The fumes in the house above have been minimal, so the exhaust seems to be doing a decent job.

Would appreciate anyone�s thoughts/advice. Thank you kindly.

Re: Accelerating varnish curing

#2

Re: Accelerating varnish curing

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Brandon,

First you need to understand that varnish, like all drying oil finishes, is a "reactive" where the oil molecules take in oxygen in a process called polymerization. This is very different from solvent finishes like lacquer and shellac where the finish film is formed by the evaporation of the solvent leaving the resin behind.

Polymerization is a chemical reaction and it's speed will be somewhat effected by temperature and the amount of oxygen available to the film surface. It will, however, take a relatively long time to complete, and "messing" with it may harm the results.

An oil finish goes through the curing process by first giving up the diluent (mineral spirits or naptha, etc.) so that the coating feels dry, and then begins to absorb oxygen from the air. As it cures, the film actually shrinks and gets thinner in the process that can take weeks or months to complete.

Your tent proposal with some added heat will help the MS or naptha flash off, but you shouldn't be trying to bake the film to cure it as you may weaken the film. Better, I think, if, once dry, you move the piece upstairs to the warmer sections of the house where air circulation will provide more oxygen to complete the cure "naturally."

Re: Accelerating varnish curing

#3

Re: Accelerating varnish curing

Brandon in Cincinnati

>Thanks for your thoughts Mark. It is my understanding that the reaction of the oxygen with the oil is sped up with increased temperature. So my goal was to try not to restrict oxygen, while at the same time bumping the temperature up some, but not so much that I am "baking" it. (I don't think I could get it that warm anyway) I was mainly concerned about whether the heating element of the electric space heater could potentially ignite the fumes.

Re: Accelerating varnish curing

#4

information relevant to your needs

Bill Tindall

>1. First, to understand what is needed to get the film cured. Varnishing is a two step process. After the varnish is applied the solvent evaporates, which is faster than the next step, the reaction of varnish with oxygen to harden the film. The curing step is highly temperature dependent as well as dependent on the product formulation. A varnish that could be dry to the touch in 4 hours at 85 degrees might take days at 50 degrees.

2. You are wasting your money exhausting air from the basement. The diddly amount of solvent you are evaporating is not a hazard. Suppose you were varnishing a floor or all the house trim as is done refgularly in the trades. Learn to enjoy the sweet smell of success that the project is near done.

3.Given what we know from #1 how to best get the varnish cured in the cold, something I do regularly, BTW? Apply varnish and let the project sit for a while while most of the solvent flashes off. An hour would be plenty of time. Then move the project to some place warm or make where it is at warm. I move projects either into the living area (laundry room is handy) or into a vehicle that gets solar heat. I used to have a van and it was like a greenhouse on a sunny day.

4. There is great risk in heating in a tent or something similar. Not from fire, if you have flashed most of the solvent off, but from boiling out the residual solvent and getting blisters ( I will not go into painful details of how I keep rediscovering this problem).

Re: Accelerating varnish curing

#5

the issue to fear is.....

Bill Tindall

>not lack of oxygen as there is no way the cure can/will deplete oxygen, or fire, once the initial amount of solvent is flashed off. What will cause you to pound the bench and rend your hair is if you get the surface hot and the residual solvent boils out and makes blisters. The only fix will be to strip and start over.

I can tell you all manner of ways that this predicament can occur-direct sun on a dark wood, hair drier, in front of fireplace, heat lamp and any other way you can imagine that radiant heat can heat a project's surface.

Re: Accelerating varnish curing

#6

Re: the issue to fear is.....

Brandon in Cincinnati

>The heater has a thermostat so I can control temperature. How hot would the surface have to get?

Re: Accelerating varnish curing

#7

Weakened Film

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Since you already understand the process, you can anticipate that too rapid a dry/cure will weaken the film, even if you don't "boil" it as described by Bill. Remember too that there are tail volatiles remaining after the MS has evaporated. They are there to assist the film in leveling out evenly. The film cures from the outside in, and will be more subject to heat damage down at the wood surface so even if if it doesn't bubble or blister, you may still get a weak bond and an uneven film.

Oil finishes are very forgiving, but are not for those in a hurry to get the piece out the door.

Good Luck

Re: Accelerating varnish curing

#8

Jesper, Denmark

Re: One additional factor....

Jesper, Denmark

>Humidity. If you cold room also has high relative humidity, it will also slow down the curing - and if really high, cause some clouding of the varnish.

RH in the 50-60% range is preferable. You can lower the RH by heating. About 10�F drops the RH about 20%.

Re: Accelerating varnish curing

#9

Re: Accelerating varnish curing *LINK*

Howard Acheson

>Over the years I have frequently used a small electric heater under an old army blanket to keep the temperature between 65 to 85 degrees. With oil based finishes, you do not have a fire hazard. But, to completely cure, it will take more than a few hours. Oil based finishes can take 3-4 weeks to develop full hardness and durability. I would keep the item under the "tent" for a full 24 - 48 hours and then take it into a warm room for a week or two.

Go to the link below for some interesting new info about finishing in cold weather. Read the whole thread and follow the link provided by Steve Mickley. Steve is a finisher I greatly respect.


Cold Weather Finishing

Re: Accelerating varnish curing

#10

Dale Lenz

Thank you, Howard

Dale Lenz

>Have ran ceiling fans to create air flow over drying varnish finishes, after flash off, for years and has worked, . The though for my doing the air flow was to increase evaporation, not to increase oxygen level around the project piece.

Re: Accelerating varnish curing

#11

There is much that is false in the link

Bill Tindall

>Most egregious is claim of oxygen deprivation in cold weather. It takes a minuscule amount of oxygen to cure a varnish coating. If what was said was true Minnesotians would be passing out from lack of oxygen for most of the winter. An oxygen molecule travels on the order of inches in a second just by diffusion. Convection is irrelevant to replacing oxygen at a curing surface. I would venture, not taking the time to calculate the situation, that the replacement rate of oxygen at a curing surface is orders of magnitude greater than the rate it diffuses into the film to react with the varnish components.

Second, the claims on viscosity are similarly wrong. The viscosity of polymer solutions such as varnish are extremely sensitive to dilution. I don't know the value for varnish molecules but, for example, diluting a solution of cellulose nitrate by a factor of two will reduce its viscosity by something like a factor of 50! The effect of temperature is vastly less. Leveling is all about viscosity, less leads to faster leveling (and runs). If the varnish seems to thick because it is cold either heating the varnish or thinning with a small amount of solvent will solve the problem. Thinning with something volatile will enhance the rate of evaporating the solvent, and that is good in cold weather. Thin with naptha. Ditto for any of the other finishes. Thin with a low boiling point solvent or hell may freeze over before the solvent leaves the curing film. But be wary about the possibility of blushing if the solvent leaves too fast.

A third factor was discussed by our own expert in these matters, Mr. Dresdner. The catalyst that accelerates the curing is deactivated at high humidity. Cold can mean damp, (except in MN where cold means no humidity) so cold and damp is a double whammy to cure rate. How much humidity affects the catalyst will depend on the catalyst used in the formulation. Some are probably less humidity sensitive so some products may cure better cold and damp than others.

Indeed, the chemistry that results in "cure" proceeds at any temperature at a rate dependent on catalyst activity and temperature. It is the same chemistry that makes fat rancid. Whole wheat flour gets an off taste quickly at room temperature because of the fat becoming rancid(oxidizing/reacting with oxygen) but I can store whole wheat flour for a year in the freezer and the fat stays fine because lower temperature has slowed the rate down orders of magnitude. The varnish has a catalyst that makes the "fat" oxidation go faster so it may not take a year to cure at 40 degrees.

The temperature factor affects many of the physical and chemical process involved in cure. However, I can't think of any reason the final film properties should depend on temperature of cure, unless the temperature is too hot. Most polymer cross linking reactions (and that is what is going on) are more complete if they go more slowly (think epoxy cure). But curing is a complicated process and someone having experimented with these issues may have contrary data. I would believe the data.