Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Tung Oil and Walnut

Posts

Tung Oil and Walnut

#1

Tung Oil and Walnut

Dustmaker Mike

>My wife's father made her a candle holder for Christmas and did not have a chance to finish it. While I was there we applied a few coats of Tung oil. The wood is from a Walnut tree from their yard when she was a kid. Needless to say it is very dry and is soaking up the oil almost as fast as I can put it on. My question is how much do I put on it? Do I go until it stops soaking in, will it stop soaking in and build to a nice shine? I have been using a rag and wiping it on can I use a small sponge and soak it to get more of it into the wood?

Re: Tung Oil and Walnut

#2

Re: Tung Oil and Walnut

Barry Turner

>First of all, Tung Oil can dry very slowly. I think you need to stop slathering on the Tung Oil and allow these coats to cure for a week or two. Then, you can apply additional coats, allowing them to cure for a few days between coats.

I don't think your finish is going to build significantly until you do this. What you are doing is keeping the oil wet and it continues to soak in. If you let the coats already applied cure, they will act as a sealer or barrier and prevent further penetration. That's my opinion of what is going on. DAMHIKT. (Don't ask me how I know this!)

I'll bet if you go back and read the instructions, they will say to apply Tung Oil in thin coats, and allow to cure btween coats.

Someone with more experience may have a different opinion.

Re: Tung Oil and Walnut

#3

Re: Tung Oil and Walnut

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>What Barry said, plus, you MAY want to switch to walnut oil, and go slowly. The walnut oil will smell better, but still cure slowly.

Impatient people will switch to Waterlox when your current oil dries completely. Three coats of that should complete the finish pretty well.

Re: Tung Oil and Walnut

#4

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Tung Oil and Walnut

Jesper, Denmark

>What Barry said, plus you may add a little Japan dryer to speed the process.

Re: Tung Oil and Walnut

#5

this description matches my experience

Bill Tindall

>It may take a month to get a good build, but there is not much effort involved.

Re: Tung Oil and Walnut

#6

Thanks I have waited a day

Dustmaker Mike

>or two between coats and have been applying a thin layer each time. I just thought it would build and shine up after 6 coats. The first three where done in TX and the next three done a little over a week later up here in OH. I guess I will apply one more coat today and wait until I get back in ten days to see what it looks like. I used tung oil before on Cherry and I don't remember this happening.

Thanks Again

Re: Tung Oil and Walnut

#7

Re: Thanks I have waited a day

Barry Turner

>Just one more thought........are you leaving the finished item in a cold shop after applying the Tung Oil. If you are, this will prolong the curing process. Move the item inside to normal room temperatures.

Re: Tung Oil and Walnut

#8

Re: Thanks I have waited a day

Barry Turner

>A day between coats is probably not nearly long enough. Sit the item on a sheet of white copy paper for 30 minutes or so. If it leaves an oily residue on the paper, it's not dry enough for another coat of oil.

Re: Tung Oil and Walnut

#9

Re: Tung Oil and Walnut

Barry Turner

>Just remember, Walnut Oil dries very slowly, too. I have had really good luck with Minwax Polyurethane. Brush it on and allow it to soak in for a few minutes. Then, wipe it off with a soft cloth and allow to dry overnight. Two or three coats applied this way results in a remarkably nice finish with very little effort. Watco Danish Oil can also be a good finish. Either of these will dry faster than Tung Oil or Walnut Oil.

Re: Tung Oil and Walnut

#10

Re: Tung Oil and Walnut

Howard Acheson

>What do you mean by "tung oil"? Are you using a true, pure tung oil or one of the faux "tung oil finishes" like Minwax Tung Oil Finish?

Pure oils are a particular poor finish. They have little or no water or water vapor resistance and have no resistance to abrasion. They also have little durability and will require at least annual re-treating.

The Tung Oil Finish products contain a varnish that make it a significantly more protective and durable finish. But, it's best to make your own by mixing equal parts of your favorite varnish or poly varnish, boiled linseed oil and mineral spirits.

Re: Tung Oil and Walnut

#11

Formby's Tung oil finish

Dustmaker Mike

>

Re: Tung Oil and Walnut

#12

Re: Tung Oil and Walnut

Bill White

>Formby's is a good finish, but it just takes a while to get everything cured. Since I have a real issue with poly anything, I try to use the old-timers finishes whenever I can. Don't get in a hurry.

Opinion here:

It takes YEARS for the tree to grow. Hours, days, or weeks to build the project, yet we want to splatter a finish onto said project so we can be though in 30 minutes.

I use plasticurethane on floors.

Now I feel better.

Bill

Re: Tung Oil and Walnut

#13

Re: Formby's is NOT tung oil.

Howard Acheson

>Formby's Tung Oil Finish is a thinned wiping varnish and contains no real tung oil at all. Look carefully at the label and it will say that it is a varnish.

That said, you are actually quite a bit better off using Formby's. Being a varnish, it will provide a much more durable and protective finish than a real tung oil. Follow the directions on the container and it will give good results. There are some other varnishes that will give you a nicer finish on Walnut but the Formby's will be perfectly adequate.