Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

drawer sizing advice

Posts

drawer sizing advice

#1

drawer sizing advice

Bill Tindall

>I need to make a chest of drawers about 4 ' high. The drawer pattern will be 3 drawers side by side at the top followed by 2 side by side and then 1,1,1- 5 ranks of drawers high, for a total of 8 drawers. The question is how to size the drawer heights to be pleasing and not wind up the a ridiculously deep drawer at the bottom like many mathematical progressions lead to.

If you have such a unit in hand or picture in a book, or a flair for design, please advise.

Re: drawer sizing advice

#2

Re: drawer sizing advice

Barry Irby

>Before I knew any better I thought you were supposed to add the width of the stretcher to each successive drawer.

I have a Chest I made several years ago that is 45" tall. The top drawer is 4" deep, the stretchers are 1" wide. So, the Drawers are 4,5,6,7,and 8". There is a cove molding under the top and a base. Seems pleasant to me and the drawers are useful depths, or they would be if I put much of anything in the chest. The body of the chest is 34 1/2" wide and 18" deep. There is a hidden compartment under the top.

Obviously, you can play with this a bit. You could make the stretchers slightly wider or you could cheat the numbers a bit.

Is 8" ridiculously deep?

Re: drawer sizing advice

#3

Re: drawer sizing advice

John Pappas

>Bill, this is how I did a chest of drawers.

Lets say you have 30 vertical inches for the drawer space.

Play with some ratios. For example this 30 inches is to be used in a ratio of 6:7:8:9:10. That is a total of 40 parts.

Top drawer: 6/40 x 30 = 4.5"

Next row 7/40 x 30 = 5.25"

Next 8/40 x 30 = 6."

Next 9/40 x 30 = 6.75"

Bottom 10/40x 30 = 7.5"

Total 30.

Different rations yield different heights. Try a couple others.

John

Re: drawer sizing advice

#5

interesting approach

Bill Tindall

>I'll draw up an example for the task at hand.

Re: drawer sizing advice

#6

Re: drawer sizing advice

Andrew F in Australia

>Hi Bill,

I've quickly sketched up something for you, assuming that the carcase has a plinth/kickrail of about 4" (sounded about right.)

The Arithmetical progression is one way out.

Visually, I like the logarithmic progression, but the bottom drawer at 12" high is a bit deep for my liking too.

Here's one way around this.

I'm assuming that the cabinet contains five drawer rails at 3/4" each and 4" plinth = 7.75" of available height used, making the available drawer space 40" (round down a bit - won't matter too much.)

Let's say the top drawers are 6.5" not 6" high

The second drawer is 6.5 plus 1 extra unit of height.

The third drawer is 6.5" plus 2 extra units of height

The fourth drawer is 6.5" plus 4 extra units of height.

The bottom drawer is 6.5" plus 8 extra units of height.

All up, the space needed for the drawers is 32.5" plus 15 units of height.

15 units of height = 7.5"

1 unit of height, therefore, = 0.5"

This makes the drawer heights as follows:

6.5 inches

7.0 inches

7.5 inches

8.5 inches

11 inches (still a smidgeon too deep.)

Repeat the maths, and eventually you'll get something to your liking.

Cheers,

Andrew


img

Re: drawer sizing advice

#7

Another image without the text 

Andrew F in Australia

>


img

Re: drawer sizing advice

#8

Image showing 6.5" as the base unit 

Andrew F in Australia

>


img

Re: drawer sizing advice

#9

what I have learned so far

Bill Tindall

>1. There isn't any magic formula that "everyone" uses for determining drawer heights. It may be that there isn't a formula that any two people use! I have yet to encounter two progressions that are the same in my research so far. This discovery is a surprise.

2. The looks of the cabinet don't seem to be critically dependent on making this decision. This tentative hypothesis comes as a surprise to me. When I asked the question I presumed the progression of sizes seen in "quality work" would be constrained to but a few possibilities.

3. From what I have gleaned, in a 5 drawer high cabinet the first two ranks are(can be) the same height which reduces the problem to 4 heights to proportion.

4. The "book" formulas involving some mathematical progressions lead to ridiculously large bottom drawers in a 4 rank cabinet. An 8" drawer is acceptable but considered big in my mind. I don't know how anything bigger would be practically used.

5. I had never encountered the " depth of one above plus drawer divider thickness" approach for establishing the progression but it is certainly simple to use and leads to a practical progression of sizes. I will draw this progression up and see how it looks.

Thanks to all who offered assistance...........

Re: drawer sizing advice

#10

Re: progressive drawer sizing article *LINK*

Henry (Raleigh, NC)

>Here's what I consider a wonderful article by Richard Jones in WoodCentral's Articles section. I have not read it in quite some time so I forget the progression details, but the picture shows progressive drawer sizes without massive bottom drawers.

Henry W


WC article - Richard Jones: Chest of Drawers

Re: drawer sizing advice

#11

You could look at this *LINK*

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown PA

>George Walker has been putting out some information on traditional 18th C. design using Classical Orders. He has some DVDs available through Lie Nielsen (link attached). I haven't seen them, but I plan to. It might be of help to you.

George also has a pretty nice blog here:

http://georgewalkerdesign.wordpress.com/

I also recall and article in a recent Pop Wood discussing drawer graduation which I think was also by George:

http://www.popularwoodworking.com/articleabstract?aid=15205

Maybe this will help out.


http://www.lie-nielsen.com/catalog.php?grp=1320