Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Random Orbit Sander Advice ? ? ?

Posts

Random Orbit Sander Advice ? ? ?

#1

Random Orbit Sander Advice ? ? ?

Barry Turner

>I am in the market for a new 5" random orbit sander. Sanders that have floated to the top in my search are as follows: Porter-Cable Low-Profile Model 390, DeWalt D26453K and Bosch ROS20VSK. Does anyone have any experience with either of these sanders? Pro's? Con's? Does variable speed control have any real advantage?

My gut feeling is to go with the Bosch. It is the cheapest of the three and has the smallest motor, a 2.5 amp. It feels more balanced in my hands and is the lightest. The most expensive sander, the Porter-Cable has the largest motor at 3.5 amps. It is also large and heavy and is not easy to grip in my somewhat average-sized hands. The DeWalt, 3.0 amps, hits in the middle in all categories. Advice please!

Re: Random Orbit Sander Advice ? ? ?

#2

Ellis Walentine

Re: Random Orbit Sander Advice ? ? ?

Ellis Walentine

>I have one of the previous model Porter Cable sanders and much prefer it over the Bosch and the DeWalt. I have not tried the new low-profile version.

Ellis

Re: Random Orbit Sander Advice ? ? ?

#3

Re: Random Orbit Sander Advice ? ? ?

Barry Turner

>Thanks. A tool normally has to feel very good in my hands or be rated very highly by people that I trust to make it into my shop. When I read the literature, I should be ecstatic about the new PC, but I'm not. I like the feel of the Bosch, but something tells me it may be a bit of a light-weight.

Re: Random Orbit Sander Advice ? ? ?

#4

Another vote for the PC

doug f, san clemente, ca

>I've got a Porter Cable 333VS that I bought about 15 years ago that's still running strong. I wouldn't trade it for a new one.

Doug

Re: Random Orbit Sander Advice ? ? ?

#5

I favor the PC,

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>But I like the 6", which has about 30% more area on the abrasive disk.

5 = 19.6" vs. 6 = 28.27"

Also, I would look at the size of the circle of orbit from each model. The larger circle will cut faster, and need more power of course. This may not mater if this is your hobby, but if time is money, you can't afford to waste time sanding with a tool that feels good but doesn't perform well.

Re: Random Orbit Sander Advice ? ? ?

#6

Dale Lenz

Re: ? Keith

Dale Lenz

>You said the larger the orbit...faster cutting, makes since. How about the larger the orbit increase sanding swirls(?) just wondering. Personally, I've got my eye on a Festool. On my second DeWalt, about 60-75 bucks when I last purchased one, can't tell you which model, works good for me but I've never owned another RO to compare it to. RO sure are faster than vibrating sanders. Each type sander has it's place in my shop, except for a screaming belt sander.

TIA

Re: Random Orbit Sander Advice ? ? ?

#7

Re: ? Keith

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>Dale, I think any will leave swirls if you don't progress through the grits properly. I have not used the Festool, but have only seen good reviews of them.

Re: Random Orbit Sander Advice ? ? ?

#8

JL

I've had a PC 390 for a while

JL

>It is a good solid ROS. I like the soft starts and quick stops. It is a nice sander. I've had mine for over a year. I would get one again.

Re: Random Orbit Sander Advice ? ? ?

#9

Re: I've had a PC 390 for a while

Barry Turner

>Thanks. Does the large diameter of the sander bother you? Do you use the variable speed control? How about motor noise? I know any sander is going to be somewhat loud, but someone told me that the DeWalt was especially wheezy and high-pitched. Have you used DeWalt and Bosch sanders?

Re: Random Orbit Sander Advice ? ? ?

#10

air driven, if you can

Bill Tindall

>An air driven ROS is the "best" option if you can justify the large air compressor to run it. These sanders are very light, spin very fast and last for ever. The down side is that they require vast quantities of 90 psi air.

Re: Random Orbit Sander Advice ? ? ?

#11

Re: ? Keith/festool

Matt Overton

>I have 2 Festool 5" sanders. They are superb, and very expensive. You get what you pay for. I like the 5" palm sander better than the PC and the Bosch, but may not be worth the difference in price. The Rotex 5" however is the best sander at agressive wood removal you can buy in my opinion. This comes from sanding nearly 1000 bf of Ipe deck boards all 6 sides!! The Rotex is worth every penny!

Re: Random Orbit Sander Advice ? ? ?

#12

Rick L

Re: 5 hp compressor motor...

Rick L

>versus electric ROS. Not very efficient in the long run. I agree air sanders are nice but electric ROS have come a long way and you can plug an electric sander in just about anywhere for convenience. Practality goes a long way...

Re: Random Orbit Sander Advice ? ? ?

#13

Re: 5 hp compressor motor...

Barry Turner

>Soooooooo.........in effect you would have a 5 HP random orbit sander? Not a very efficient use of power, in spite of the pluses of air-powered tools.

Re: Random Orbit Sander Advice ? ? ?

#14

Re: Random Orbit Sander Advice ? ? ?

Bill Hammond, Oregon Coast

>My sander, a Ridgid fits my hand and my small vac hose fits securely on to it. It's own dust bag is not to bad either. It's also a VS and I find that the soft start is nice. I use the VS on slow for course grit disks, I tend to do less gouging that way. Slow speed is nice even with fine grits when sanding the edge of boards, again more control.

Bill

Re: Random Orbit Sander Advice ? ? ?

#15

Re: Makita here

Ed Freestone------WebKitFormBoundaryiliP7S+oBWEY3G

>I have a Makita ROS - works great and Makita's motors seem quieter than others.

Re: Random Orbit Sander Advice ? ? ?

#16

JL

Re: I've had a PC 390 for a while

JL

>I've got large hands, so it doesn't bother me. I do use the variable speed.

I have used the Dewalt variable speed ROS also. The PC 390 is better, IMO. It does cost more though.

Re: Random Orbit Sander Advice ? ? ?

#17

Air Tools

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Are great in industrial settings that run large compressors (100 - 1000+ CFM) with work stations and a variety of air-driven operations like body shops and foundries. Beyond a small die grinder, nailers, and spray finishing I think they're a waste of money to buy and especially to run when compared to electric tools.

There is, of course, a certain macho wow factor to having a 16+ CFM compressor roaring away in your garage whilst the electric meter approaches light speed, and, what-the-heck, electronics will compensate for my hearing ruined by those tools' high whines, right?

Re: Random Orbit Sander Advice ? ? ?

#18

Re: Air Tools

Barry Turner

>I agree. If air were freely available with no fuss like electricity, air power would win hands down. But, if I have to run a 6HP compressor with a 60 gallon tank to power an air-powered random orbit sander and go deaf in the process, then I think I'm not thinking very well.

Re: Random Orbit Sander Advice ? ? ?

#19

Oh please...make some sense

Bill Tindall

>The 5 HP compressor doesn't run continuously. If you are going to own a compressor anyway the increment from buying one for routine shop use to one that will run an air sander is not but a few hundred dollars.

The difference in performance-air vs electric- is huge. There is a reason that every cabinet shop uses air driven sanders. My palm sized unit weighs almost nothing and spins 12000 rpm. Material removal rates are so fast that I retired a belt sander which cost me more than the increment of small air compressor to 5 HP, suitable to run the sander.

As frugal as I am I consider my move to air driven sanding one of my best equipment decisions. Most shops doing much work come to the same conclusion.

Re: Random Orbit Sander Advice ? ? ?

#20

Re: Random Orbit Sander Advice ? ? ?

Michael J Bitetti

>I have the PC 333 and love it. A while back I picked-up a newer 5" PC (model number escapes me) after DeWalt had aquired PC. As someone previously posted here, the case it comes in is horrible, the first sign of the presence of DeWalt "engineering". The sander is great! Very much on par with the original in most ways. One very important difference: it uses 8 hole disks vs 5 on the older sander. Since my inventory was well stocked with 5 hole disks it was agravating to say the least that if I wanted to keep the dust collection (and good air circulation which equals cooling) I had to get 8 hole disks. I've gotten an 8 hole replacement pad but since I buy in bulk, it will be a long time before I change it.

Mike

Re: Random Orbit Sander Advice ? ? ?

#21

Re: Random Orbit Sander Advice ? ? ?

J. Roberts

>Let me tell you about PC. They make good stuff but sometimes they make...not good stuff! Has anyone out there bought the 335,6 inch ROS? Yeah, I know, they dont make them any more. I found out the hard way. I bought one at at woodworking show a few years ago . I didnt use it much, mostly sat in the cabinet. When I did start to use it one day I found the pad had turned to mush. No problem said I. Ill just go to the PC repair shop and order a new one. Also the neoprene belt had rotted . This was about one year after I had bought it. Found out parts were no longer available and PC said sorry but couldnt help. So, just to let you know another side.

After I had calmed down I did get the 5 inch PC and have had good luck with it.

Re: Random Orbit Sander Advice ? ? ?

#22

Re: Random Orbit Sander Advice ? ? ?

Barry Turner

>Sounds like some of my experiences with Delta and Rockwell tools. Mixed!