Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Tape measures - have you ever noticed

Posts

Tape measures - have you ever noticed

#1

Tape measures - have you ever noticed

Nathan

>Have you ever noticed that when you take two tape measures, often one will give a different reading than another? The problem, I think, is with the metal hook at the "beginning" of the measure.

Any ideas on how to modify or tweak the hooks so all the tape measures in the shop read the same?

Re: Tape measures - have you ever noticed

#2

Re: Tape measures - have you ever noticed

Ed Beck

>Don't know about that, but one of the first things my woodworking instructor taught me was that when you retract the tape don't do it too fast, and put your finger in front of the tape to prevent it from whacking into the tape measurer's body.

Re: Tape measures - have you ever noticed

#3

Re: Tape measures - have you ever noticed

Sgian Dubh

>One of the first lessons I teach beginners is to use the same tape measure from the beginning of a job to the end. That way all the measurements are consistent, even if they read differently to another tape measure. The solution therefore is to carry your one and only selected tape measure about with you and use it for all the measuring tasks, and put all the other tape measures out of the way. This works well and the only exceptions to using that one tape then are when you need even greater accuracy which is where steel rules and the like come in to play. Slainte.

Re: Tape measures - have you ever noticed

#4

Re: Tape measures - have you ever noticed

Philip Duffy

>Gee, I was taught that the slack was intentional so that when you push the tape against an edge, or pull it from a fixed edge, the readings are accurate to the width of the metal at the tip. Am I wrong all these decades? Don't think so, but to be sure, lets ask Harry! Phil

Re: Tape measures - have you ever noticed

#5

Re: Tape measures

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Whenever I get a new tape, I check it against a 1 foot steel rule. I then note the "error" on the tape's case. All measurements with that tape are therefore adjusted for the difference and everything fits. Nominal error that I've found in construction tapes is 1/64" although I've had a few off by a 32nd.

Lets remember that these things ain't micrometers. Their intended use is working "construction". Talk in 64ths to a framing crew and they'll ask you what drugs you're using and where they can get some. |;-}}}

Re: Tape measures - have you ever noticed

#6

JL

Re: Tape measures - have you ever noticed

JL

>Is your metal end "hooked"? Sometimes they are so that they will grip the end of a board more effectively. But as Mark said - they aren't that accurate. If they measure to within 1/16", I'm happy. If I want more accurate measurements, I'll use my Starrett.

Re: Tape measures - have you ever noticed

#7

Barry, not Harry...

Barry Irby

>I like Phil on this. I thought the ends floated or telescoped enough to compensate for the thickness of the hook.

Recently I was helping my cousin put siding on her storage shed and it began to look like I couldn't cut it right. Sometimes it was too loose/ the joints were too wide to caulk comfortably and sometimes we were having to spring the pieces in/way too tight. After getting over the "I must have had too much to drink" sensation we compared tapes. The were off substantially and got worse as the pieces got longer. Mine was a name brand one and hers was a cheap Chinese knockoff. There was at least a 1/4" difference at 12'. So, if she measured and I cut the pieces were short and if I measured and she cut, they were long. I think the idea is to compared the tapes on the job and be sure they match or use the same tape to measure and cut.

I have never understood why the markings are upside down. Since only 7% of us are left handed you would think the tapes would be set up for a right handed person. Hold the tape in your left hand and mark with your right. The numbers are upside down.

Re: Tape measures - have you ever noticed

#8

Re: Tape measures - have you ever noticed

pecker

>Set a wooden box on a flat surface, with the edge of the box just overhanging the edge of the surface. Then measure the height using the the tape measure both ways...as an inside and an outside measurement.

You can bend the tang with pliers until you get the same reading both ways.

It will at least be accurate to itself then, if not to all your other measurement tools.

Re: Tape measures - have you ever noticed

#9

Re: Barry, not Harry...

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>I believe the slip on the hook end is intentional for inside versus outside measurement accuracy. I also use one tape for the entire project. I've also found that buying several identical tapes at the same time gives a much better tape to tape accuracy.

Also have you ever noticed in your shop that tape measures are as hard to find as pencils once you get into a project.....

Lee

Re: Tape measures - have you ever noticed

#10

You're right, but...

Gary Camp, Bend, Oregon

>I don't think that it really what is being discussed. Even when you take into account the sliding end many tape measures don't measure the same. Here are a couple of reasons why, you dropped the tape and bent the hook and / or the sliding hook has worn differently (someone, not you of course), has let the tape retract to fast and hook has slammed in to the case a few to many times. As stated earlier, slow the blade with your finger and use the same tape measure from start to finish (impossible in my shop). On framing crews where one person is measuring and another is cutting the call is "burn an inch". Keep in mind,the furniture maker works to a 64th a cabinet maker to a 32nd, the framer to an 1/8th and the buildere to the nearest boat.

glc

Re: Tape measures - have you ever noticed

#11

Re: Barry, not Harry...

Barry Irby

>Years ago I worked with a friend in his shop. We could never find a pencil. A lady we were working for gave a box of old pencils. There must have been a thousand. We took them and flung them across the shop. There were pencils everywhere. Problem solved. That was forty years ago. I think he still finds a pencil now and then.

My son and I often comment about tools hiding in plain sight. Recently he painted some of the bright orange. Gave some thought to painting others pink and blue and yellow. I suspect it would only aggravate the clutter vision. My tape occasionally stays lost for days.

Re: Tape measures - have you ever noticed

#12

Sometime when a tape get dropped,

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>and lands on the hook, it will bend the hook, throwing it off. I hang the corner over the edge of my TS wing, and peen it back to square when this happens.

Of course everybody knows that the little hook should slide by the thickness of the hook metal.

Re: Tape measures - have you ever noticed

#13

Re: Tape measures - have you ever noticed *LINK*

John McGaw

>An old article here but still very much to the point. Bottom line: tape measures are not good for measuring. But if you must use one, then use only one in a given project if you want to have any hope of things fitting together in the end.


Test of the Tapes

Re: Tape measures - have you ever noticed

#14

Framing

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>The drug addicts who built my house aside, the framers I know all work to a "s'teenth" [1/16].

One friend, known locally to be fairly meticulous, about fell over in my shop when I pulled out the mic to check my Performax's side-to-side uniformity.

Re: Tape measures - have you ever noticed

#15

Re: Tape measures - have you ever noticed

Thad

>This is why my fil, who was taught by his fil who was a shop teacher for decades, refuses to use a tape.

He always uses a folding rule.

Re: Tape measures - have you ever noticed

#16

Re: Framing

Gary Camp, Bend, Oregon

>As did the framers I worked with, but the "joke" doesn't "work" so good that way. (it probably doesn't work any way)

glc

Re: Tape measures - have you ever noticed

#17

Yes, Gary, that was my question.

Nathan

>Sorry I should have been more specific, but Gary understood my question exactly.

I was laying out mortises on a long board. I had been trying to use just one tape measure throughout this project but... the one I had been using temporarily "disappeared" and another one was lying close at hand, all silver and shiny, so instead of hunting for the right one, I grabbed it. Now, earlier on, I had made a mark on the board at 270 mm (sorry... I know, but here in Europe we do use metric). Out of habit (or compulsiveness), I doublechecked it and was shocked to get a reading from the silver tape measure that was 2 mm off. I was measuring in the same way as before, hooking onto the end of the board and pulling the tape measure to the mark.

I've seen plastic Chinese rulers where the rule itself was noticeably off - as if they had shrunk it to 90% before printing it on the ruler. I guess the same thing could easily happen in a tape measure factory somewhere in China.

Re: Tape measures - have you ever noticed

#18

The Smallness of China

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>I would not trust any Asian import item until I had laid it out against my reference rule, an 18" Starrett steel rule that I use for only two things: a) checking other rules (and tapes), and b) checking the tune on my table saw fence, miter slots, and indicator hairline.

I've yet to find a Chinese tool that "measures up." Always short.

Re: Tape measures - have you ever noticed

#19

Re: Tape measures - have you ever noticed

Fred Davis

>"Bottom line: tape measures are not good for measuring. But if you must use one, then use only one in a given project if you want to have any hope of things fitting together in the end."

I have always considered a Measuring tape useful for estimates.

That is close enough for most outside Carpentry.

Inside a Cabinet shop , layout tools and a sharp knife take it's place.

Just my opinion , but it works for me and many I know.

FredD

Re: Tape measures - have you ever noticed

#20

One problem to look out for, Richard

Andrew F in Australia

>Hi Richard,

I used to run a large scale steel processing line in a previous life. We had to set a set of side shears to trim steel to width, at about $700/tonne.

Using the same new (high quality brand) tape measure, our operators set the shears to read accurately according to the tape.

The clip on the end jammed intermittently, meaning that sometimes, it would jam on the inside measurement, and sometimes on the outside.

The difference in these two values was about 2mm or so, but it rendered 1500 tonnes of steel worthless for intended purpose. It took us a few months of having the stock sitting around before we could get rid of it. The boss wasn't happy. I gave him the tape measure that was provided and asked him to measure his desk pad - sure enough, he got a different value each time.

After that, we worked to a 2m rule with a fixed stop block as the only measuring tool.

I carried this through to cabinetry - I take about four measurements of each using a tape if it's critical to make sure that this hasn't happened, and use a steel rule for measurements less than 1500mm

Cheers,

Andrew

Re: Tape measures - have you ever noticed

#21

where do inaccuracies come from?

Tom Dunlap

>my guess is that there is a mr. rodgers or 'how is that made' episode about tape measures.

my guess is that the markings are applied using some sort of inkjet printing. if so, the smallest speed change would make a difference as the tape whizzes past the jet.

does anyone know for sure?

tom

Re: Tape measures - have you ever noticed

#22

How it's made you tube

Gary Camp, Bend, Oregon

>http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F2SMGNh3tPI

Re: Tape measures - have you ever noticed

#23

ahhh,,the answer to...

Tom Dunlap

>...innaccuracies is at about 6:08

"depending on the country"

Re: Tape measures - have you ever noticed

#24

It's in the manufacturing

Phil Joines Krum,Tx

>Tapes are printed using a loop with the markings proud of the surface. As it's run against the tape it can and does stretch to some extent.

When I did telephone equipment installation the measurements for things like bay lineups had to be within 1/16" even if the lineup was 100' long. We bought tapes in batches of 50 from the same lot and they still had to pass calibration every 3 months. A lot of them got tossed.

Re: Tape measures - have you ever noticed

#25

Temperature too?

Gary Camp, Bend, Oregon

>When I took surveying classes, oh so many years ago, in a time before electronic distance measuring and self leveling insturments. We had to know where and how to check steel tapes against standards and compensate for temperature. I was wondering if tapes printed on days with significantly different temperatures show differences?

glc