Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

moisture meters

Posts

moisture meters

#1

moisture meters

Bill Tucker

>Does anyone have experience using a Sonin moisture meter (made in China)? Is there a better one out there that is relatively inexpensive?

thanks,

bill tucker

Re: moisture meters

#2

Why are people buying moisture meters?

Bill Tindall

>We sold hardwood lumber for many years and none of our customers owned a moisture meter. In that day they were expensive so the cost/benefit was a bit higher than today, presuming the current crop of cheap meters reliably measures true moisture content. We didn't own one for many years until someone gave me one, which rarely got used.

It seems to me that owning a moisture meter is a modern phenomena and I am wondering why there is suddenly a need for these meters in hobby shops?

They are not without some peril. No counting the possibility that some sorts of meters are inherently unreliable even the expensive meter common at dry kilns had to be used with care to get a reliable measurement. When the measurement really counted the oven method was used, and can be used in the hobby shop just as well.

Re: moisture meters

#3

Re: Why are people buying moisture meters?

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>I think the proliferation of moisture meters, mine included has been caused by the larger number of places processing lumber that really don't know how (or don't care) to properly season their product. I had one bad experience with "seasoned lumber" and had to redo a lot of work on a project because nothing fit after parts of it reached equilibrium. I went out and bought a moisture meter. However, it rarely gets used because I buy most of my stock from the same place and they kiln dry all their wood and do a very very good job of it. I can count the number of reaction pieces I've had from this source in 20 years on one hand.

Now if I go to use another source, you can bet my meter will be in my pocket or will get used as soon as the lumber reaches my shop.

Lumber, even hardwood, from the big box stores varies widely from shipment to shipment with regard to moisture content.

Re: moisture meters

#4

Re: Why are people buying moisture meters?

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

>Some of us air-dry our own and it's nice to get confirmation that the "year-per-inch" rule really works.

Re: moisture meters

#5

Sleazy Operators

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>1. who "short" their kiln programs to save money

2. who swear on the stack that the stuff's been air-dried for [4,5,25] years.

Have taken my Electrophysics [CT-100] on every wood-buying trip (except Simmy Agin, of course) in the last 10 years. I rejected about 20% of the stock available. Paid for itself many times over in avoided hassles.

I also use it for previously rough-turned bowls to be comfortable that all parts of the piece have reached EMC before finish turning.

Re: moisture meters

#6

Re: Why are people buying moisture meters?

jesse cloud

>I usually use some lumber from stock in the shop and buy some new lumber as well. Here in the NM desert, the humidity is very low (14% today and people are complaining about how sticky it is). If the lumber I buy at the yard hasn't been in the area for a while, I find it takes a few weeks to come to the same moisture level as my stock. I like to work with all wood at about the same moisture level, so I compare the pieces on the meter. Even if the meter isn't greatly accurate, the same reading on all pieces is good enough for me.

Re: moisture meters

#7

Because we can? We are Americans?

Barry Irby

>Because we are gadget freaks?

I use one in my work as a Home Inspector. Comparatively. Yep, that spot that looks wet IS wet, or NO its not.

Very seldom use it in my shop even though I have or have had three or four.

I really do think part of it is the American fascination with gadgets. Rather than use a scales or even the kiss test it's so much better to get a read out. I bet the ones that have the digital Read out are even more attractive than the ones with the lights or the needle.

They are a quick and dirty test. Want to know if the bowl blank is dry? Weigh it, wait a few weeks and weigh it again. Or meter it and hope you get a good reading.

Perhaps I don't buy much lumber.

Re: moisture meters

#8

Used to think I needed one

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown PA

>Never did by one, though. I air dry a bunch of my own lumber. I now fear that having a moisture meter might be an excuse to short cuts part of a good construction process. Mill your lumber to rough thickness, stack/sticker and let it acclimate and move around for a few days/weeks. Then go to final thickness thickness. And yeah, I've had parts still move even after this, probably more of a drying defect than a moisture problem (or bad stock selection on my part like using a wide flatsawn board - of course it's going to cup a little).

I have to agree the prevalance of moisture meters now is a gadget thing along with the need for a number and measurement to everything. I fear that it takes the "feel" out of woodworking, being able to look at a board and feel it's weight and know if it's good or not. Plane a too wet board and feel the shavings, you'll see what I mean. It's also good to know the amount and type of movement to expect in your boards and account for it in the design (even though I've seen lots of pieces flaunt the rules with no issues).

I still think the meters have their place, such as working with construction grade lumber (often very wet) or to see if you are getting a good deal on that cheap stack of lumber at auction.

Re: moisture meters

#9

Ellis Walentine

Where I find them useful

Ellis Walentine

>I must say that I used to use my moisture meter rather often, mostly for measuring the moisture in floating panels, to make sure that 1) the panels didn't shrink out of the grooves in the course of a year and 2) that they didn't expand and blow the door or frame apart.

Depending on the panel width and species, the importance of the MC varies. I was most often concerned if/when I was bringing material in from the unheated woodshed and knew that it was probably in the 10% to 12% range. I wanted to be able to predict how much it would shrink in a heated environment, so I took a reading and looked up the shrinkage coefficients in order to assure myself that there wouldn't be a problem one way or the other.

Ellis

Re: moisture meters

#10

Bill, I think I have read Dr Wengert state,

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>That he gives free advice to woodworkers over on Woodweb, but that he earns a pretty good living as a professional witness, in lawsuits, mostly relative to drying issues.

I hope to never meet him in the courtroom.

Re: moisture meters

#11

Are modern meters more reliable than in days past?

Bill Tindall

>My experience with moisture meters is dated. I owned a Lignometer, considered in its time the best meter, and the meter I saw in use at any kiln I was at. It employed 4 scales that were set according to the species being tested. Does your meter have, or need, 4 scales and temperature correction? Furthermore, the reading had to be temperature corrected and it was important how and where the electrodes were inserted into the lumber. Even with these precautions the meter was not considered accurate to 1% at the low end of moisture content and for KD lumber the oven dry method was used because it was vastly more precise and accurate. In the hands of an inexperience person readings of KD lumber could be even more inaccurate, or useless.

That said, if accuracy and reliability have not improved then your meter may tell the difference between 7% MC lumber and 12% but not reliably be able to determine if lumber is 7% or 9%. In the first case an experienced woodworker will be able to differentiate 7 and 12% MC lumber by feel and smell.

Re: moisture meters

#12

Re: Why are people buying moisture meters?

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Evening Bill and Lee,

I have found to my chagrin that moisture content and wood movement vary between sources. I spent a lot of time last winter wrestling with warping lumber purchased for my #2 daughter's dining room table. In the end, it cost me about a hundred bucks and literally weeks of time before scrapping one glue-up and acquiring additional material from another vendor. I value mine, and use it.

George

Re: moisture meters

#13

Weight

Tony - Memphis

>I have a scale froma furniture factory in Goldsboro, NC (my hometown). My Grandpa and Great Uncle both worked there all their lives (40 years for Grandpa - I have his retirement watch too). Somehow, when they shut down, my Uncle got soem equipment (guess they sold stuff or just got rid of it). He gave me the scale they used to weigh their stock to check for moisture content. I have it in my shop with a piece of mahogany on it. If you balance it ad leave it alone, you can see that it does change over time. Pretty neat. He got one of their lathes too and I wish I could have gotten that. It was very simple, but very industrial. He converted it from belt drive to motor driven and used it for many years. The furniture company was Kemps, btw. They were both very proud of their work and their company. There is a young Mr. Kemp that is getting back inthe furniture biz (or was before the recession, not sure now).

Tony

Re: moisture meters

#14

"Somehow, when they shut down..."

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>My uncle worked for the Southern Pacific railroad. He had a lot of tools marked "S.P.", which he would explain stood for "Sacramento Plumbing" (Sacramento, CA being about three hours from his place). I think they'd been headed for the dumpster before wandering over to his truck - certainly that's likely true of the Yankee breast drill I have from him.