Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

For Those Of Us Who Use The Golden Ratio *LINK*

Posts

Re: For Those Of Us Who Use The Golden Ratio *LINK*

#2

Clint Searl

Balderdash

Clint Searl

>The Golden Mean became popular because it's easy and foolproof to lay out with only a straight edge and compass, and it's repeatable in any size.

Of the rectangles below, which is the most pleasing?

Clint

Re: For Those Of Us Who Use The Golden Ratio *LINK*

#3

Clint Searl

Re: Balderdash 

Clint Searl

>


img

Re: For Those Of Us Who Use The Golden Ratio *LINK*

#4

C

Stephen Roth

>

Re: For Those Of Us Who Use The Golden Ratio *LINK*

#5

B or C

Bill Tindall

>I find things made with "golden" rectangle too narrow most times.

Re: For Those Of Us Who Use The Golden Ratio *LINK*

#6

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Interesting.

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>I read the article, then looked at your selection of rectangles. I really couldn't pick out one I liked the best, though A, B, and C were all candidates. But I'm on my laptop, so I rotated it 90�, and B suddenly jumped out at me as being the most pleasing to the eye.

I suspect it is at least in part due to the fact that our eyes are side by side, so the image they transmit to the brain is wider than high--and I would suspect that if there were an accurate way to measure it, the readily interpreted part of the image (the more central area, excluding the periphery) would be close to the Golden Ratio.

Jason

Re: For Those Of Us Who Use The Golden Ratio *LINK*

#7

None of the above....

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>

Re: For Those Of Us Who Use The Golden Ratio *LINK*

#8

Re: None of the above....

Philip Duffy

>Wat to go, Lee! I am with you on this one. Phil

Re: For Those Of Us Who Use The Golden Ratio *LINK*

#9

Clint Searl

"C" is the Golden Mean

Clint Searl

>

Re: For Those Of Us Who Use The Golden Ratio *LINK*

#10

I kinda like A

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>

Re: For Those Of Us Who Use The Golden Ratio *LINK*

#11

Integer ratios are popular too

wilbur

>There's a DVD by George Walker called "Unlocking the Secrets of Traditional Design" where he shows how a lot of 18th century furniture used ratios based on classical architecture to design furniture pieces. This would result in a lot of proportions NOT based on the golden mean, even though both were used by the Greeks. There's a lot of 2:3, 3:5, 5:6, etc. going on -- more so than the golden mean. As easy as it is to layout the golden mean with a compass, it's even easier to layout a 3:5 proportion.

I had a chance to talk to George Walker at the last Woodworking in America conference, and asked him if he knew of any other country, region, or time period that predominantly used non-integer ratios in their styles. He said not to his knowledge. I do know that in Asian furniture styles, integer ratios are used extensively, but different proportions were more popular. 1:2 and 2:3 are used more commonly in Asian furniture than in western furniture styles.

Re: For Those Of Us Who Use The Golden Ratio *LINK*

#12

I think you may be right

charlie belden

>An earlier thread on this Golden Ratio thing got me looking into our binocular, stereoscopic vision thing.

Found the following numbers and played with them

From Straight Ahead, our field of vision "towards our nose" is about 60 degrees horizontally.

From Straight Ahead, our field of vision "towards our ear" is about 100 degrees.

So horizontally, each eye has a field of view of about 160 degrees and we can see about 200 degrees.

Horizontally, looking foreward, the overlap of the field of vision of each eye is about 120 degrees. This overlap of fields of vision is where we have our stereoscoplic vision. The remaining portion of our 200 degree range is monoscopic.

Each eye's Vertical Field of Vision is about 60 degrees up from horizontal and 75 degrees down from horizontal - for a total vertical field of vision of 135 degrees - all of it I assume is stereoscopic vision.

Playing with these numbers - and a primitive CAD program I did the attached illustrations - did some measuring - and calculated some ratios. Rough results had horizontal fields of vision in the 1.62 to 1.66 ratios, while vertical came out with a ratio of about 1.81.

There's an arbitrary distance between eyes for this stuff - but it gives some idea of how our field of stereoscopic vision may have some relationship to the Golden Ratio.

I find the referenced article to be just a wee bit euro-centric. I suspect that chinese and japanese aesthetics are a bit more complex and refined - and probably not adhering to any "western" rules of proportions. Personally, I find oriental paintings, sculpture, block prints - and furniture - very pleasing to the eye.

Re: For Those Of Us Who Use The Golden Ratio *LINK*

#13

Clint Searl

Re: I think you may be right

Clint Searl

>An amusing hypothesis, but if the ratio is hard wired because of our field of stereoscopic vision, then it should be found throughout all cultures. I think the simple explanation is most plausible; it's easy to construct without a ruler and is infinitely scalable.

Clint

Re: For Those Of Us Who Use The Golden Ratio *LINK*

#14

George Walker and the Golden Rectangle

Bill Tindall

>I just finished George's useful DVD on furniture design last night and not once did he mention designing anything using this ratio. I design most of the stuff I make and rarely does this ratio lead to some useful size for that which I am designing. I could be convinced with data, but I am skeptical that this ratio is used much in cabinetry.

Your analysis of vision was most interesting though.

Re: For Those Of Us Who Use The Golden Ratio *LINK*

#15

Clint Searl

From Wikipedia

Clint Searl

>Some scholars deny that the Greeks had any aesthetic association with golden ratio. For example, Midhat J. Gazal� says, "It was not until Euclid, however, that the golden ratio's mathematical properties were studied. In the Elements (308 BC) the Greek mathematician merely regarded that number as an interesting irrational number, in connection with the middle and extreme ratios. Its occurrence in regular pentagons and decagons was duly observed, as well as in the dodecahedron (a regular polyhedron whose twelve faces are regular pentagons). It is indeed exemplary that the great Euclid, contrary to generations of mystics who followed, would soberly treat that number for what it is, without attaching to it other than its factual properties."[20] And Keith Devlin says, "Certainly, the oft repeated assertion that the Parthenon in Athens is based on the golden ratio is not supported by actual measurements. In fact, the entire story about the Greeks and golden ratio seems to be without foundation. The one thing we know for sure is that Euclid, in his famous textbook Elements, written around 300 BC, showed how to calculate its value."[21] Near-contemporary sources like Vitruvius exclusively discuss proportions that can be expressed in whole numbers, i.e. commensurate as opposed to irrational proportions.

Re: For Those Of Us Who Use The Golden Ratio *LINK*

#16

OOPS - forgot illustration 

charlie belden

>


img