Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Ingersol Rand compressor -Emerson Motor -long

Posts

Ingersol Rand compressor -Emerson Motor -long

#1

Ingersol Rand compressor -Emerson Motor -long

Randy Johnson

>The Saturday after Thanksgiving I bought an Ingersol Rand air compressor at a local Tractor Supply. I looked at compressors at Lowe�s, Menard�s, and Orschelen. Tractor Supply was the only place that had compressors even close to what I wanted. They had two brands, IR, and Campbell Hausfield.

Now, no offense to the loyal CH fans out there, but I have, on occasion, heard less than glowing things about CH compressors. The local scrap yard used to literally have a pile of small CH units which, I think, were manufactured in nearby Harrison, OH. Seeing IR and CH units side by side the IR just �looked� better. The casting on the cylinder heads of the CH units looked rough while the castings on the IR looked cleaner. IR had the only two stage offering so I went with it.

On the decal which has nowadays replaces the old brass service plates the amperage rating was followed by an asterisk. At the bottom of the decal, the asterisk was followed by �see information on motor� - or something to that effect. The information on the motor said FLA was 21.5.

The next two weeks were spent plumbing in the airlines. After that job was done, the compressor was slid into the location I wanted, marks were made on the floor to drill the holes needed, and the compressor was fastened to the floor using the damnably expensive IR installation kit. Next step was to fill the compressor pump with the oil that came with the compressor. The final step was the electrical connection.

Going with the 21.5 FLA on the motor I ran #10 from the panel to a fused disconnect near the compressor in which I installed two time delay 30 amp fuses. Turn on the breaker, close the disconnect, and close the pressure switch. The motor ran for about a second - two seconds at the most - and blew one of the fuses. Attempts number two and three gave identical results. Two red wire nuts took the disconnect out of the equation and this time the compressor ran until it reached full tank pressure. I opened the valve on the tank to fill the lines and then cracked the valves at the low points to lower the pressure and allow the compressor to kick on again. This time the motor stalled. The best way I can describe it is to say that it acted like it was grossly underpowered or the pump was seized. I shut off the power and rotated everything by hand. Nothing seemed amiss so I tried putting power to the system again. It ran for maybe five seconds and blew a capacitor. This was on a Sunday and I had to wait until the next day to get a replacement capacitor.

With the new capacitor installed I repeated, almost exactly the same sequence of events from the day before with the same conclusion - a blown capacitor.

At this point I decided it was time to call Ingersol Rand. I wasn�t able to make the call until Tuesday (12/22/09) morning. At first I talked to the service manager who switched me to one of the service techs. In the course of the conversation he consulted a table and informed me I should have run #6 for a 5HP motor. I think I replied something to the effect of �. Well let�s just say that I told him that, in my opinion, #6 was more than a little overkill. He finally switched me back to the service manager who said someone would come the next day. I have now heard that promise twice and have yet to have anyone show up.

Yesterday I Googled the model number for the motor and discovered something interesting. It, and another Emerson model used on IR compressors sold by Northern Tool and Tractor Supply have achieved a degree of infamy. In the best case they simply don�t work. In the worst case they catch fire. Discussions on the problem are on at least three different message boards. The problem seems to be common and widespread enough that I�m sure the guys at the service center I talked to knew what the problem was before I�d spoken two sentences. The failure of a serviceman to appear as scheduled makes me wonder if they hope I�ll just go away.

I was going to wait and post this after the problem was resolved one way or the other, but, if by posting it now, I can save one person from buying an Ingersol Rand compressor with an Emerson motor made in Mexico I�ll have done my good deed for the day.

In closing I want to say this. I have no idea how many motors I�ve wired in my life but there have been quite a few. I�ve wired grain dryers, feed augers, commercial exhaust fans, and industrial machinery. Until this air compressor came along I�ve never had a motor do anything other than I expected. I�ve even had almost supernatural luck guessing which wire went where on first time three-phase hook-ups. When the motor was running its only time on the second capacitor I tonged the wires at the breaker and got a reading of 15 amps on a side. After I first encountered the problem I got out the owner�s manual and read the electrical section. The manual says to use #8 wire. I can see no reason for that unless the compressor is a couple hundred feet from the power source. I realize that startup amps can greatly exceed running amps. That�s why they make time delay fuses - so you can use the right size instead of one that is too big. I�m hoping the #8 requirement doesn�t turn out to be a way out of IR having to replace a piece of junk motor.

Re: Ingersol Rand compressor -Emerson Motor -long

#2

Re: Ingersol Rand compressor -Emerson Motor -long

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Randy,

I have an IR SS3L3 that I bought on special from Northern Freight. It was always fairly loud, but about a year after I got it, it got VERY L-O-U-D. Called IR and in less than 4 days they had a tech in my garage with a brand new pump. Guy even switched out my pressure switch to raise the range from 80/120 to 110/150 at no charge.

Could not have asked for better service. Call them; they're very sensitive about good customer relations.

mm

Re: Ingersol Rand compressor -Emerson Motor -long

#3

Re: Ingersol Rand compressor -Emerson Motor -long

Ken Garlock, Collin County Texas

>Happy New Year Randy. I am sorry and surprised to hear about your problems with an IR compressor.

I have the 5 HP 60 gal. IR compressor, and I think I bought it back in 2004. It has run flawlessly since the first time I flipped the switch.

When I bought my unit from Northern Tool, they were just a paper shuffler for IR, and the actual compressor was shipped from a plant in Tennessee as I recall. I have a Marathon motor on my compressor and about 50 ft. of #10 between the compressor and the breaker panel.

#6 wire is overkill, the fellow at IR either didn't know what he was talking about or just trying to cover the corporate rear end. Yes, my instructions call for a #8 40 amp circuit, that might be good for a unit that is cycling on and off every couple minutes.

I think you got a bum motor, and I would require IR to install another brand motor, or haul the hole thing off for a refund.

Don't let the IR people pee on your shoes and tell you it is raining,

Ken

Re: Ingersol Rand compressor -Emerson Motor -long

#4

Re: Ingersol Rand compressor -Emerson Motor -long *LINK*

GalenV in Iowa

>Randy

I imagine the one person who suggested #6 wire just read a table like the attached. From the FLA you listed for 5 Hp I figured you are talking 230 single phase power. You did not say how far your conductor run was from the panel to your fused disconnect nor if there was anything else running at the same time from the panel you tied into.

If the manual suggested #8 I assume it figures you are not making a long run so no need for #6. To me for a 5 Hp motor the #10 is light for carrying the starting current at rated voltage.

To run once for you makes me think maybe it was the only load from the panel and the voltage was close to 230 but next time some other panel load made the voltage drop and amperage go above your limits.

Not there so hard to know all the facts. Motor must have been wired right to run once. Also not totally uncommon to hook up wrong if motor not labeled well.

Good luck and hope you get things resolved.

Galen


Motor wire size

Re: Ingersol Rand compressor -Emerson Motor -long

#5

Re: Ingersol Rand compressor -Emerson Motor -long

DONinSTL

>I have a 2-stage, 3HP compressor that puts out just under 12 CFM of air. It has a 3 HP Century motor rated at 18 AMPS, 230 volts, continuous run.

I have a cable run of 35-40 feet from the main panel to a fuse box, then a 5-10 foot run to the motor.

I installed it to my father-in-laws specs. He was an electrician his whole life, was an IBEW, Local 1 member and had worked as a St. Louis County electrical inspector.

He had me run #6 copper and install 30 amp. fuses.

I can only say that I have never had a problem.

Good luck solving your problem.

Re: Ingersol Rand compressor -Emerson Motor -long

#6

Wait a minute - I messed up

DONinSTL

>Randy,

I'm so sorry about my previous response - I screwed up. (My excuse is that my cable installation took place over 30 years ago.) I forgot that at that time, I also ran a spot welder on that cable. It bypassed the 30 amp. fuse box and used the 50 amp. breaker in the main panel.

This just proves that you cannot necessarily trust the "help" you get on the Internet.

I'll try to do better next time.

Re: Ingersol Rand compressor -Emerson Motor -long

#7

Re: Ingersol Rand compressor -Emerson Motor -long

Randy Johnson

>Voltage around here tends to run on the high side. I have never had any trouble when running any machine with the cyclone running anyway.

The run from the panel to the compressor is under twenty feet. Fitting #8 into the pressure switch would be tricky and I think fitting #6 into it would be impossible. After the pressure switch there would have to be a real load problem because the wire from the motor to the pressure switch is only #12. But that's plenty for 15 amps on a side.

If you Google IR 23220064 or IR 54421193 you will be able to read a number of threads on at least three forums about troubles with these particular motors.

Since it was too cold to do much else today I took a little roadtrip to Richmond,IN where I bought my compressor. Part of the trip was to look at what was available in motors in case I have to replace the one I have on my own. While at Tractor Supply I noted that none of the three 5HP IR compressors on the floor have one of the two motors that have caused all the trouble.

Re: Ingersol Rand compressor -Emerson Motor -long

#8

Re: Ingersol Rand compressor -Emerson Motor -long

GalenV in Iowa

>Randy

Tractor Supply has a 30 day satisfaction policy so guess I would pack the thing up and return it. Not satisfied if it don't run!

E. Return and Refund Policy for In-Store Purchases (back to top)

Our ultimate goal is for you to be completely satisfied with your purchase from Tractor Supply. If you purchase an item from a Tractor Supply Company Store and you are not completely satisfied, you may return it within thirty (30) days to any Tractor Supply Store for a refund or exchange within our current return policy guidelines. If you choose to return or exchange your product at one of our retail stores, please bring your receipt or invoice with you to ensure a quick and hassle-free return. To find your nearest Tractor Supply store, click here. Your refund will be processed when the item being returned has been received. Refunds will be made by crediting the original method of payment (i.e. credit card, in-store account, etc.), or in the form of a check from our Store Support Center. For additional assistance, visit your local Tractor Supply store or you may call our Customer Service Center at the telephone number identified in Section F and one of our customer service representatives will be glad to recommend alternative return options that may be available.

Re: Ingersol Rand compressor -Emerson Motor -long

#9

Re: Ingersol Rand compressor -Emerson Motor -long

Randy Johnson

>I don't really think it is Tractor Supply's fault or problem. Anyway, as much as it weighs there would have to be a lot more wrong with it than the motor before a return would even be considered. My feeling at this time is that if Ingersol Rand would just send me a new motor - one with a better reputation than the two I've mentioned, I would be a happy camper. They have kind of hemmed and hawed about it up to this point even though, from what I've read, they already know that the motor was junk to start with.

There are two Tractor Supply stores I do business with and I have never had any regrets shopping at either of them. As a matter of fact, if the one in Richmond had had a motor that worked today the compressor might be fixed now. They did have one (Marathon) the right size HP and frame but the shaft was 5/8 instead of 7/8.

Re: Ingersol Rand compressor -Emerson Motor -long

#10

I have the same compressor

A Wright

>I bought it from Tractor Supply last fall, and wired with a 30A breaker and #10 wire. It has run flawlessly for 3 months, so hopefully I got a good unit. I am sure this is a stupid question (and don't take any insult by it), but did you put oil in the pump? mine was shipped dry.

Good Luck (and i am keeping my fingers crossed)

Re: Ingersol Rand compressor -Emerson Motor -long

#11

Re: Ingersol Rand compressor -Emerson Motor -long

GalenV in Iowa

>Randy

I know it is not Tractor Supplies fault but since they carry the IR brand they have more leverage than one consumer to try and get something done for you. Never hurts to ask for their help. Maybe they can get approval to swap out the motor and return the defective to IR.

If they don't seem interested I would sure think twice about buying from them too.

We packaged Quincy compressors in a lot of our projects and even though the warranty terms were made to be the manufactures warranty we took a defective unit back and handled the warrenty problems for our customer. Did not have to but good business in the end.

Sure take the wind out of your sails when a new purchase ends up with problems.

Galen

Re: Ingersol Rand compressor -Emerson Motor -long

#12

Re: I have the same compressor

Randy Johnson

>Yeah, I mentioned that in the first post. I purposely put of wiring to the very last so I would be less likely to throw the switch before everything was ready. Besides, that was the part I could do pretty much on autopilot.