Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

OT - Replacing shower mixing valve

Posts

OT - Replacing shower mixing valve

#1

OT - Replacing shower mixing valve

Joe Pack

>After 28 years, our Delta tub/shower mixing valve started to leak...simple to fix by taking it apart and replacing some O-rings and seals. Just twist off the retaining ring, pull the plastic cover, pop out the ball, R&R seals, springs and O-rings, replace the cover and screw the retaining ring back on. Everything went perfectly until I got to step one. I feared, and was correct that 28 years worth of calcium and crud probably would make it difficult to unscrew the retaining ring. I was wrong. Heck, just use a 14" pipe wrench and push down and the whole thing just twisted right off.

So now I'm replacing the entire mixing valve. Of course, the original was sweated on and there are no unions anywhere...just copper and solder. I have no choice but to cut it apart (with no real room to use a copper tubing cutter, so out will come the Dremel and/or hacksaw...ugh). I really don't want to sweat the whole thing together again, so I'm looking at alternatives. Most logical is to use 5/8" compression fittings, but that requires some "play" in the pipes that I really don't have unless I do more deconstruction. Which leads me to this brilliant idea to run by the experts here... Considering that the openings in the valve are only 1/4" anyhow, what would be wrong with using a stainless steel reingorced flexible supply line like those used with kitchen/lavatory/toilet supply lines? I can get the 1/2" pipe connections on both ends of the line, one screwing onto the valve assembly and the other onto a 1/2"pipe-5/8"compression fitting. No torch, no soldering, very little hassle, and easily accessible if there is trouble down the road. Is there any reason this would not work? Any downside you can see?

Re: OT - Replacing shower mixing valve

#2

Re: OT - Replacing shower mixing valve

Barry Irby

>I really see nothing wrong with your Idea.

I am turning into an old fuddy duddy and am surprised I am not telling you you have to sweat the whole thing "like you are supposed to".

Recently I tried to make a sweat repair to avoid the expense of using more expensive fittings. After two tries at soldering ancient corroded copper pipe that had been leaking a LONG time, I gave up and use the slip on fittings. They worked just as they should have.

So, what I am saying is check out the "Shark-Bite" or "Gator-Bite" fittings. One comes form Lowes and the other from Home Depot. They are even easier than compression fittings. They literally just slip on. Available in most of the standard configurations including the adapter from pipe to threaded. The only disadvantage I can see is they are about ten times as expensive as sweat fittings, but Hey, its a lot cheaper than burning your house down and you don't even need room to turn a wrench.

I would be skeptical of the plastic flexible tubes, but all my toilets are hooked up on them and have never had a problem. With the "bite" type fittings, you might be able to use the supply lines to your existing unit and put them back together on your new unit with couplings, but no body is that lucky. Nothing will line up.

Re: OT - Replacing shower mixing valve

#3

VERY humble opinion . . .

steve mackay

>I HATE compression fittings. Don't like worrying if I got it seated "just right". Then, untill I replace them, I worry if I can't see it leaking (behind a wall). I've even opened the wall on both sides in order to cut and sweat fit. Then I know in my heart its as good as it gets. And yes, I know, if installed properly they are wonderful. Sorry, just my opinion, but I always doubt them.

Re: OT - Replacing shower mixing valve

#4

Re: VERY humble opinion . . .

Fred Davis

>What Steve is saying is basically true , sweated fittings are top of the line supply connections.

That being said ,if you still resist using a Plumber and you have a good Plumbing section and knowledgeable clerk in it at the Hardware , inquire about using alternatives, one being what Barry suggested.

For compression fittings make sure you have checked for the slightest burr on the sleeve, that is all it takes for a leak to develope, generally after you close up the wall and forget about it.

FredD

Re: OT - Replacing shower mixing valve

#5

Sweat them

Dustmaker Mike

>I just did a shower faucet last month same reason as you. I used a close quarter pipe cutter to cut out the valve all three legs. I then assembled every thing and sweated the connections in the garage ( in a vise). I used copper coupler to join the pipe in the walls to the new faucet. Total three sweat joints in the wall. I cut the wall about 18 x 14 to make sure I had room to work and installed two quarter turn shut off valves in the wall also. I am making a door to cover the hole instead of redoing the sheet rock. It is your home why short cut it?

Don't forget it is a half inch pipe up to the shower head.

Re: OT - Replacing shower mixing valve

#6

I wouldn't

Neal in San Jose

>I worked as a general contractor doing remodeling for 13 years back in a previous life, and I've seen several of these stainless steel reinforced lines fail. Usually just a slow drip, which isn't a problem where it is visible and accessable like behind a toilet or in a vanity. I've seen a couple of them fail catastrophicaly (sp?), again out where they were accessable. Cost a new vinyl floor in one case, a wood kitchen/dinging room floor in another, and some sheet rock in the bathroom under the failed flex line in another case. Again, all of these were accessable, and a shut-off valve was adjacent so that once they were found, the water source was easily turned off.

I don't want to think of what would happen if that line failed inside a wall. A slow drip would make a perfect habitat for termites, and if it failed by bursting, well, at the minimum you'd have to turn off water to the house and leave it off until you were able to chop a hole in the wall and cap off the leak. If you happened to be away for the weekend lets just say it wouldn't be pretty. At the worst your homeowner's insurance may not cover damage caused by a non-code installation.

Listen to the other folks and do it right. I don't have any experience with the slip-on Shark Bite type fittings, but it sounds like that may be your answer.

Re: OT - Replacing shower mixing valve

#7

Re: VERY humble opinion . . .

Joseph Mulherin, Sr.

>I am a retired pipefitter/plumber of 35yrs experience before retiring. DO NOT install any flexible fittings inside a wall like those used for the washer machines....and in most cases it is against the building regulations and safety. If you want to see what happens when DIYers do their own work, watch the Mike Holmes series in the Do It Right Productions shows on Discovery TV. One small leak after a period of time will produce a mold inside the walls and under the floor tiles which will cost more than what it is possible to fathom in some cases. Stop being a DIYer and hire a Plumber and do it right!!!

Re: OT - Replacing shower mixing valve

#8

Re: OT - Replacing shower mixing valve

Howard Norman

>As long as you have an access panel I don't see any real problems with what you suggest. However, if it was me I would do it with solder fittings myself. As others have mentioned what happens if you get a slow leak develop that you don't catch quickly? Could be a major problem.

Re: OT - Replacing shower mixing valve

#9

Re: OT - Replacing shower mixing valve

Howard Norman

>BTW, as long as you are where you are in the process I wouldn't even consider hiring a plumber unless you don't have the time to complete the job.

Re: OT - Replacing shower mixing valve

#10

Re: OT - Replacing shower mixing valve

John Veerkamp, Western Mo

>Shark-Bite fittings are the answer for the final connections. Assemble and soldier as much as you can on the bench and then use the Shark Bite to finish up. They do meet code.

Re: OT - Replacing shower mixing valve

#11

Re: OT - Replacing shower mixing valve

Gary Evans--Tallassee TN

>Hi Joe,

I don't know if you are familiar with repair couplings. They don't have a stop in the middle so that you can slide one all the way up on the end of one pipe, line up your two pipes and slide the coupling over to join the two pipes. Unless you have a really odd installation, I don't know why you couldn't use these to accomplish your task.

Gary

Re: OT - Replacing shower mixing valve

#12

BINGO!

Joe Pack

>Never heard of repair couplings till now, but that may be just what I need! They would eliminate my adjustment/length problem. I'll look for them at HD/Lowe's tomorrow.

As for the suggestion to "do it right" I know all of you are right. I built the house and did the plumbing, so the "no union" thing was my stupidity. Even though I built in access panels when I built the house, I was trying to avoid that, just cause I've gotten lazy in my old age. But between the new snap fittings and the repair coupling, my job may have just gotten easier..

Thanks for all the tips and for the cautions. Guess I will take my Daddy's advice and do it right the first time. If I get another 28 years out of the shower, I'll fix it again then.

Re: OT - Replacing shower mixing valve

#13

Re: VERY humble opinion . . .

Fred Davis

>I believe I mentioned a Plumber as the first option in passing Joe , but you know how woodworkers are..........

Same thing applies to doing you own Furnace installation , Branch Circuit panel and Brain Surgery

FredD

Re: OT - Replacing shower mixing valve

#14

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: VERY humble opinion . . .

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>Plumbing is NOT brain surgery. Not even close.

It's just not that hard. Tricky at times, yes, but I don't believe reasonably handy people should have to call a pro for every little thing that goes wrong in their home, plumbing and electric included.

There are two rules to plumbing:

1. If it leaks, it's not right.

2. "Stuff" flows downhill.

Jason

Re: OT - Replacing shower mixing valve

#15

Re: BINGO! Stuff you already know...

Barry Irby

>Lowes has the repair couplings. They may be a little scarce, but they usually have them. You can recognise them by looking through them. They will be a straight tube with no dimple or ridge inside to keep the pipe from sliding through. Be careful, its easy to slip them too far one way or the other and not center them on the joint. When I use them I put a scratch or Sharpie mark on BOTH pieces of pipe so that I can tell how far they are into the fittings.

Copper repair couplings are nearly identical in size to regular couplings. There are others available called Dressler couplings that are longer and somewhat like compression fittings but they might be three inches long.

I suspect you could use the Shark-Bite fittings as repair couplings. They make a (cheap) tool that allows you to unlock the fittings and remove them. If you were careful you could slide them onto one pipe and then release it and slide it back onto the other pipe.

As an aside, there has been much discussion of doing it right and soldering the joints to be sure you don't have a leak inside the wall. Obviously, I agree that none of us ever wants a leak inside a wall, but sweating the joints is not a guarantee you won't have a leak. Doing it WELL is about as close to a guarantee as you can get, but unless you are at least somewhat skilled at sweating joints, your guarantee is only as good as your skill level. I have found plenty of soldered joists leaking on Home Inspections. My favorite one was found because the baseboard was discolored. With permission, we cut the wall open. There was an elbow on copper pipe that had obviously been soldered over and over (an attempt at the impossible). It was leaking very slowly. Under it was a tin can with a piece of sponge in the bottom. We reasoned that they could not stop the leak and set the can under it. They relied on evaporation to eliminate the water. We figure the sponge was to eliminate the sound of the dripping. Unfortunately, the can rusted out and the water leaked out and stained the baseboard. Both the buyer and seller were flabbergasted. My comment was that if they had had sense enough to use an aluminum can it would have been a permanent repair.

So, make an excellent repair. Use excellent materials and apply your best skills. It would be a good idea to open that panel and check it once or twice a year, but nobody does.

PS, When I was building for a living, I had this sort of grizzled old plumber working for me. He may have worked for the Romans back in the day, too. He may have been the guy that invented indoor plumbing. I asked him why he did not put unions on things like water heaters. He gave me his best "you poor babe in the woods" smile and said, "Because its the unions that leak". His theory was that any fitting is far more likely to leak than the pipe itself so it was not smart to install any that were not essential. He also felt that the shut off valves were something of a joke. They sit there for something like 28 years and when you finally need them they likely won't work or will leak.

Re: OT - Replacing shower mixing valve

#16

Not a plumber, but...

Joe Pack

>It's not that I can't do the copper myself; I have plumbed 4 houses and a duplex, and I have stayed at Holiday inn Express a couple of times. It's just that I'm gettin old and lazy. Sweating copper is not hard as long as things are clean and smooth...the things that too many folks lose sight of.

Re: OT - Replacing shower mixing valve

#17

Re: OT - Replacing shower mixing valve

del schisler

>use shark bite fitting's they won't leak check this link out they are at home depot Maybe low's also or other home centers They have them for showers and all water heater's also It made a beliver out of me the best for those tight places and No flame to burn up something

http://www.sharkbite.com/

Re: OT - Replacing shower mixing valve

#18

You forgat a very important rule

Gary Camp, Bend, Oregon

>Don't chew your fingernails

glc

Re: OT - Replacing shower mixing valve

#19

Mike Holmes . . .

steve mackay

>Since you bring him up (I'm a BIG fan !) these fittings are KINDA like electric junctions in walls with no access. And you KNOW how he fells about THAT !

Re: OT - Replacing shower mixing valve

#20

Re: VERY humble opinion . . .

Fred Davis

>"Plumbing is NOT brain surgery. Not even close."

I never said it was and I believe you know what I meant.

The posters problem with a leaky Mixer valve is not a easy fix for anybody that has never done it like a Plumber for instance and because it is in a difficult place to reach and work in and requires sweating of fittings for a proper repair , I would not , nor would any Plumber recommend doing it yourself.

That being said Jason , I have no doubt done far more plumbing then you will ever and I acquired the experience along the way to recognize that some jobs are best left to those who do it every day.

That is the difference between a General Contractor and a Tradesman.

There is a couple of Electricians and Plumbers on this forum and their advice on matters they deal with in their respective trades is well worth listening to , especially if your a homeowner looking for help.

FredD

Re: OT - Replacing shower mixing valve

#21

Re: OT - Replacing shower mixing valve

Howard Norman

>After reading some more of the posting on this thread I recalled that I had to replace a shower valve a few years ago in this house. The original Delta unit developed a leak about a year or two after installation. The leak was in the part assembled by Delta. I called them and they sent out a new valve assembly. I cut a hole in the drywall behind the valve and replaced the valve assembly. I do have a short tubing cutter so cutting the Cu tubing was not an issue. The biggest issue was repairing the drywall. That is something that I can not do to my satisfaction so I do have that done by someone that does it all of the time.

I rarely use a plumber or an electrician. I have been burned so many times by both plumbers and electricians incompetence that I am better off doing it myself. I hired a plumber to do the original piping in this house because I thought it would be done faster and better than I would be able to do the job. What a mistake that was. Total incompetence is the only way that I can describe the work. I am still ten years later finding places where he did not correctly suspend pipes in the basement. And I was paying him on a time and material basis so there was not the excuse that he had underbid the job and was taking shortcuts because of that.

My experience certainly doesn't support the theory of hiring the "pros" to do most jobs. They screw up as bad as anyone else in my experience.

Re: OT - Replacing shower mixing valve

#22

Re: OT - Replacing shower mixing valve

Barry Irby

>Apparently from the posts I see here there is a vast difference in the competence of the so called Pros in different parts of the country. Perhaps its Union Vs. Non Union or Licensed vs Non Licensed.

As a Home Inspector in Virginia (non Union or Right to Work State, but Licensed) Some of the the worst work I see has been done by people representing themselves as Pros. Some of it very poor quality, but some so bad as to be frightening. Cobbled together plumbing. Electrical work that includes things like a No. 10 copper wire inserted into the main lugs of a 200 amp panel with the aluminum service cable and no breaker or fuse on the copper wire. So much wrong with that its hard to list it all, but it was clear the owners did not do it themselves. Seen it more than once.

At the very least homeowners should have some idea what good work looks like and should inspect the work of the pros before they pay them. This is a good argument pointing out the benefit of building permits and the inspections that go with them. And, you should be there when the inspector comes and make sure they actually give it a good look.

Re: OT - Replacing shower mixing valve

#23

Re: OT - Replacing shower mixing valve

Howard Norman

>Barry, your experience is like mine. I don't know what the difference is but there are certainly a lot of so called "pro" tradesmen out there doing shoddy work. All of my experiences with shoddy work has been with American citizens as far as I can tell. That is probable due to the illegals who are working in construction being hired by the big contractors where I don't have any exposure directly to their work ethics.

I am not against building permits and inspections. I just wish that the local inspectors were more knowledgeable. It has been suggested by a couple of local builders that I know that the local inspectors are trying to find things wrong so that there will be work for the inspectors since building in general has slowed down a lot.

Re: OT - Replacing shower mixing valve

#24

Way OT - licensed contractors - not just Virginia

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>"At the very least homeowners should have some idea what good work looks like and should inspect the work of the pros before they pay them."

I am still stinging from the work that a licensed plumbing contractor did on my parents' place over a decade ago. I kind of knew at the time, but didn't listen to that little voice (and didn't really have time - work was intense), that I should have been there. A supposedly pro plumber did galvanized-to-copper changes directly, no dieletric union or brass pipe between, and the solder drools on the copper joints ran two feet down from the joints.

California's licensing board complaint process favors the contractor, and my parents were unwilling to go with a small claims court action, so they wound up eating the extra cost for a competent plumber to repair the work.

Ironically, I've seen unlicensed contractors do work that's so far above that licensed turkey's work that he wouldn't last a day with him.

Still wish I'd trusted my instincts and driven down (2 hours each way, in good traffic; three or more in bad) to hover over the work.

Re: OT - Replacing shower mixing valve

#25

Re: OT - Replacing shower mixing valve

Bill Howatt

>I made my own by slightly filing the dimple in a regular coupling such that it would slide competely over the pipe. I think it would be easier to do on the dimple type rather than the "groove" type. Like Barry said, it is a good idea to mark where it is roughly centered on the pipes since you lose the automatic locating feature - the dimple.

I personally don't share the concern over a properly installed compression fitting leaking. They are used in various applications in almost any industry you can think of, in far more demanding conditions than household water supply.

I haven't seen any mention of the risk of porous copper pipe being installed - it does happen and it may not be immediately apparent. There are no guarantees in plumbing no matter what methods you use.

Bill