Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

poisoning yourself

Posts

poisoning yourself

#1

poisoning yourself

John Cotten

>I was reading Alan Young's post below regarding the gentleman who poisoned himself after heating brake fluid cleaner.

While my cabinet shop my not be the cleanest or best organized out there, the commode in my shop is always cleaned two or three times a week. I can't stand a nasty commode. Back in March of this year it was still cold enough to keep the oil electric heater on in the bathroom (keeps the pipes from freezing). I accidently spilled some toilet bowl cleaner on the heater, the gas as immediate and toxic. Severe headache, coughing, threwup a few minutes later, eyes burned, and sinuses burned for the next three or four hours. Exposure time, 10 to 20 seconds before I realized what was happening. Interesting though, there was no warning of any of the this on the label. I called the company that manufactured the product, and was told by their customer service department that there was no requirement to put that precaution on the label. I explained that while I had the vent fan on in this 4' x 6' space, and the door open that my poisoning was instant, and could have possibly been fatal. They appologized for my discomfort, but offered not other concern. The product still does not have anything on the label regarding spilling it on a heater, radiator, or other hot item. I won't mention the manufacturer here except to say it is one that is on nearly every discount and grocery shelf.

Re: poisoning yourself

#2

explanation of what happened

Bill Tindall

>The cheap stuff is just a solution of fairly strong hydrochloric acid. Same stuff, although more dilute, that is used to clean masonry, and masons use it by the gallon. When heated the hydrochloric acid boils off.

Among the excessive warnings are "causes skin burns, irreversible eye damage, wear gloves, etc. They could have added "vapors extremely irritating" but didn't. Personally I think these warnings are over the top for this material. However, given these warnings why would anyone be surprised to find that boiling this stuff would produce vapors that would at least be irritating, and likely harmful if concentrated?

The vapors are so irritating that it is difficult to to expose oneself to harmful amounts unless for some reason it was difficult to recoil form them. The nose irritation would be expected but I have never seen anyone with a nose full of this stuff throw up before. That may have been from stress.

Re: poisoning yourself

#3

Re: poisoning yourself

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>I don't have a bathroom in my shop. But I have been in a couple of other workshop bathrooms. Not kept as clean as yours. Trust me...they were nearly as toxic! Thankfully my prostate is in working order....more than 20 seconds of exposure could have been equally as fatal! ;-)

Tom

Re: poisoning yourself

#4

Re: explanation of what happened

Joseph Mulherin, Sr.

>When that hydrochloric solution is heated it turns into fosgene gas...the same thing as mustard gas the German's used in the 1st WW.

And if it is mixed with chlorine is is very damaging to the lungs.

I did mix them when I cleaned my pool and refilled the pool filtering system with the chemicals....spilled the stuff together into the container and got a very deep whiff of the gas...was in the hospital for a few days.

Re: poisoning yourself

#5

Your response is not correct

Bill Tindall

>Heating a solution of hydrochloric acid will simply boil off a mixture of water and hydrochloric acid. The vapors will be extremely irritating. The only thing in this solution is hydrogen, chloride and water.

Phosgene is a compound containing chlorine, oxygen and CARBON. There is no possible way to make something that contains these elements from a solution of simply hydrogen, chloride and water.

Re: poisoning yourself

#6

Re: Your response is not correct

Joseph Mulherin, Sr.

>I stand corrected. thanks

Re: poisoning yourself

#7

I've never understood.

davhamm

>Why post something about an event you clearly feel is VERY Dangerous. Yet not tell the people what product it is they should stay away from.

I see this often and never understood the thinking.

Re: poisoning yourself

#8

Not A Complaint About The Product

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>But (seems to me anyway) rather a heads up! about caution in the accidental misuse of ordinary products. Anyone who's used "plain ol' muriatic" on concrete and gotten downwind of the yellow reaction plume knows to stay up-wind of the stuff.

Most "ordinary" household chemicals are quite safe until misused. For example, chlorine bleach as well as most all ammoniated cleaners which will all be labeled clearly warning about chlorine gas generation. It did, however, take a couple of janitor deaths to make those warnings happen.

All the warning and "instructions for use" labels in the world won't help if people don't read them. I wonder, how many people routinely store chlorinated products like bleach or scouring powder within inches of the sudsy ammonia bottle? Would they do so if they knew that a leak could fill their home with chlorine gas and kill their kids?

I'm pretty careful with cleaning products, but would not expect a few drops of mild H2SO4 to create such a dramatic reaction.

Of course I smoked for 45 years notwithstanding that wienie Surgeon General . . .