Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

How to tell "bad" finish?

Posts

How to tell "bad" finish?

#1

How to tell "bad" finish?

John E in SC

>Recently tried to use some Bullseye shellac out of a can that was at least 9 months old. It looked fine in the can, and even seemed to brush on OK for the most part, but dried into a huge mess. It was very uneven, and brush strokes were very obvious. I was using this as a seal coat, so it wasn't a problem except causing lots of sanding, but I've not had that problem with shellac before. Is that what happens when shellac goes bad? Any way to tell this prior to applying it? (I know I should buy flakes and mix my own prior to use, but as I said, this was just for a sealer, and I had it already on hand.) My shop was fairly cool as well, probably in the 50's if that matters.

Re: How to tell "bad" finish?

#2

Re: How to tell "bad" finish?

Fred Davis

>John,

Zinsser's is good for at least three years in the can , (their claim) .

If it has gone over the hill , the Shellac would remain tacky and not dry.

I think the low temp had a lot to do with the rough finish, also you may need to put a little alcohol in the Shellac if it seems thick.

Water based paint which is more user friendly requires at least four hours of 55 degrees or higher to dry adequately.

Buying flakes and making your own , results in time lost , wasted material and no better if as good as results as premixed.

Next time for sealing with Shellac,, use Zinsser's SealCoat, a thinner mix and dries faster.

Since it is already dewaxed that makes it a better choice for under other finishes.

FredD

Re: How to tell "bad" finish?

#3

Re: How to tell "bad" finish?

Dan Donaldson

>Put a drop on a piece of glass or other hard surface and wait for it to dry. If it is good, when you scrape it off, it will be hard and flake, if it stays gooey, it is no good.

Re: How to tell "bad" finish?

#4

Re: How to tell "bad" finish?

Howard Acheson

>As already said, the test for shellac is to apply it to a test board. If it dry to the point when sanded that it produces a fine dust, they it is still good. If the drying time is over an hour or if it remains sticky, it is past its prime and should be discarded.

Temperature has little to do with shellac drying. It's an evaporative finish and as long as it can evaporate freely, temperature will not be a factor. I've applied shellac at temperature well below freezing. NC lacquer will also dry at below freezing temperatures.

Shellac is a temperamental finish to brush because of its fast evaporation and drying. It should be flowed on with a good brush. Minimize back and forth "brushing". If you were using Zinsser Bullseye standard varnish, it will brush much better thinned 50/50 with denatured alcohol.

Re: How to tell "bad" finish?

#5

Clint Searl

Re: How to tell "bad" finish?

Clint Searl

>If the can has a word spelled s-h-e-l-l-a-c or B-L-O on it, you'll suffer everlasting grief. A "seal" coat does nothing on wood that doesn't ooze sap that a thinned coat of the top finish won't do. If the wood oozes sap, convert it to kindling

Wash off the mess with denatured alcohol and go straight to the final finish.

Clint

Re: How to tell "bad" finish?

#6

Re: How to tell "bad" finish?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>John,

Using 9-month old waxy shellac as a sealer is taking a real chance. Even fresh, it's not a great "sealer" because the wax content tends to create adhesion problems with the top coats; especially waterborne finishes.

Since shellac is an evaporative finish, it dries quickly. If applying with a brush (I prefer padding it on, myself), use fine nylon, and do not back-brush, but rather flow it on the surface and allow it to level itself. Continuing to work the thickening film will just create a mess.

As for your present situation, try to level the film by using w/d 400 grit with mineral spirits as a lubricant. The alternative is to give it an alcohol bath to redissolve and rinse the offending film off, allow to dry, and start over.

Also suggest you use SealCoat rather than Bull's Eye as a sealer for the reasons already stated.

Re: How to tell "bad" finish?

#7

Re: Agree one on point

DaleLenz

>You are getting brush mark due to the shellac being too thick, thin the 3# cut, what's in you can, down to 50/50, 1.5# cut or add 2 parts thinner, Alcohol, to the 3# shellac for 1#. By thinning the shellac will allow the finish to level quicker before setting up. When working with shellac, you never go back over with a brush, ever, until the next coat is applied over the dried shellac. Going back over un-dried shellac is a sure way to get brush marks.

Actually, leveling should be better in a cold environment due to the shellac not evaporating as quick. But on the other hand, runs and sags will be greater in a cooler environment. Have you ever tried padding shellac? In a warm shop I can often get 5 coats, of 1# cut, in an hour, and then I'm done for several hours to a day.

Re: How to tell "bad" finish?

#8

Sure would like to have an edit button, : ' >

DaleLenz

>

Re: How to tell "bad" finish?

#9

somebodies got to say it

Thomas S Stockton------WebKitFormBoundaryAt+6o7QFm

>Keep it away from cigs and booze and it probably won't go bad. If it does go bad it can star in it's own b movie "reform school shellac"

Actually the advice you've gotten is real good

Re: How to tell "bad" finish?

#10

Re: How to tell "bad" finish?

John Pappas

>Clint, I am curious...what is the "everlasting grief" suffered by using shellac. You are right that a seal coat is not always necessary, but I see no grief if a coat of shellac is properly applied. Also, for certain applications shellac makes an excellent topcoat.

Re: How to tell "bad" finish?

#11

Clint Searl

Re: How to tell "bad" finish?

Clint Searl

>Specifying that the barrier properties of shellac are rarely, if ever, needed in furniture making, as a finish finish, shellac is shelf life unstable, a challenge to apply successfully, builds slowly, can age to a flaky dry alligator surface, offers little protection from household spills, and usually adds an extra step to the finishing schedule. The same goes for its elite cousin, french polish. Whatever positive qualities it has (?) can be had better with modern natural and chemical finishes. It smells nice, though.

As for BLO, it's the lowest branch of the drying oil tree, and is best used to generate spontaneous combustion.

Clint

Re: How to tell "bad" finish?

#12

but....

John Pappas

>my question remains unanswered, "what everlasting grief"?

Re: How to tell "bad" finish?

#13

Clint Searl

Re: but....

Clint Searl

>I guess one man's grief is another man's pleasure.

Happy New Year.

Clint

Re: How to tell "bad" finish?

#14

Have To Disagree

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>If using the new sophisticated waterborne finishes, a light sealing coat of 100% dewaxed shellac can SAVE much grief because it prevents the water from raising the wood grain. I've had supposedly "self-sealing" waterborne finishes make a mess of a piece. Shellac's use as a sealer MUST, however, be done with very fresh product (the advantage of mixing small batches from dry) and used sparingly.

I also find it superior for toning a piece when mixed with Transtint dyes to match existing items in a room and/or blending different parts of the same piece with slightly different shading (notably cherry), but, again, I view it is a finesse part of a finish routine rather than an end in itself.

[DO agree, however, about BLO. Never use the stuff.]