Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Resawing for drawer bottoms

Posts

Resawing for drawer bottoms

#1

Resawing for drawer bottoms

Doug Reynolds in Seattle

>It seems impossible to find thin quartersawn wood for use in drawer bottoms here in the Seattle area. I can find white oak in 4/4 locally and mail order other species. I have read, however, that it is not a good idea to take 4/4 or, 8/4 and resaw it into 1/2" or 1/4" thick stock because resawing releases all sorts of internal stresses in the wood and it will seldom remain flat. The authors claim I should take my 4/4 stock and resaw equal amounts from both sides until reaching the desired thickness. That sure wastes a lot of wood when going for 1/4" stock. What has been your experience?

Does anyone know of a source for thinner quartersawn stock?

Happy holidays.

Re: Resawing for drawer bottoms

#2

The grooves in the drawer sides will hold it flat

Andrew F in Australia

>Hi Doug,

The grooves in the drawer sides will hold it flat. 6mm drawer bottoms will not exert much twisting force on the drawer itself, so I'd just do what you are doing already.

Seems strange - Oak's cut quartersawn for the ray fleck, so I thought that you'd get it easily, albeit at a premium to live sawn timber.

Here, buying quartersawn isn't a problem, as our main timber for hardwood furniture (Tasmanian Oak, one of three similar species; woolybutt, messmate or alpine ash) develops horrible shrinkage cracks radially, so it's quarter sawn out of necessity.

Cheers,

Andrew

Re: Resawing for drawer bottoms

#3

On the same subject, different application

Tom Rex in TX

>I am making a game table for my son & family.

The table will be 27" square.

I'm going to put a checkerboard on the top, mounted on a piece of 3/4" MDF.

I was planning on resawing 4/4 red oak & walnut down to 3/16 or 1/4.

The squares will be about 2 1/2".

Will I have trouble with the squares laying flat?

Any suggestions on making this table would be greatly appreciated.

Thanks in advance,

T Rex

Re: Resawing for drawer bottoms

#4

Re: Resawing for drawer bottoms

Barry Irby

>Doug, Oak is very common but is somewhat difficult to dry properly. There is a whole industry wrapped around drying oak for furniture and flooring. Having said that, in spite of their best efforts, some of it is poorly dried. What I would do is saw 3/4 stock right down the middle and then bring those pieces into the house or heated shop for a few days or a week or two and see what they do. Then flatten the pieces on a jointer and then plane the other side parallel. Even if the pieces part out 5/16" thick you will probably get a 1/4" piece out of quarter sawn stock. If the wood was well dried, you should find they say nearly flat.

Re: Resawing for drawer bottoms

#5

Re: On the same subject, different application

Barry Irby

>Tom, many years ago I tried to make some chess boards out of Maple and walnut. Glued up 3/4" thick strips about 2" wide. Ripped them into strips the other way and flipped every other one to create the pattern. Thought all that end grain would be weak, so I resawed the pieces into strips that were about a quarter inch thick and glued one set to a piece of 1/2" birch plywood, on one side only. The wood was not as dry as it should have been and when it dried it pulled the boards into a cupped shape. The chess boards were a valley and the edges were raised about 3/8 to 1/2". Ruined. I threw them away. IF I did anything similar today I would balance the construction and do the same thing to both sides of the substrate and use dryer wood.

Re: Resawing for drawer bottoms

#6

Re: Resawing for drawer bottoms

Virgil Johnson

>I don't know what size your drawer bottoms are but I'm of the school of "cut one and see what happens". I can't see a 4/4 board of reasonable size twisting that bad.

Re: Resawing for drawer bottoms

#7

Re: Resawing for drawer bottoms *LINK*

Fred Davis

>Doug,

for solid wood drawer bottoms I never resaw , only remove equal amounts from both sides with the Jointer and Planer until I have stock 3/8Th's" thick.

From the photos you can see the smaller drawer is about the dimensions of the one you describe.

I ran it parallel to the sides mostly for convenience.

The larger drawer out of the same piece of furniture is much larger in width and I ran it parallel to the front .

The bottoms are captured in a groove all way around.

The wood is Birch, a very stable wood and used for the all of the drawer sub- assembly.

For larger drawers like in a Chest of Drawers or Kitchen cabinets for that matter, I prefer a nice looking plain sliced Ash plywood panel unless the piece is meant to look traditional in every respect.

Then I glue up stock and plane it down and do as the pictures show.

The bottoms initially floated free until the Lacquer finish was applied and it looks like they are locked tight with that Lacquer with no movement.

The piece is four years old and looks like I just made it.

I have seldom let the back end of the bottom run though and secure it with slotted nails, though this is a traditional way to make drawers .

I have presently in the shop some European furniture made in the 1800's with hand cut dovetails and traditional drawer assembly and it looks like the drawers were made by a apprentice, sides cracked , dovetails split and anything not showing done rough.

Hope this helps you decide which way to go about a straight forward task without worrying about whether your violating any cardinal rule real or imagined about making drawers.

FredD


http://picasaweb.google.com/lh/photo/8_gnor1v9mfZUdAJF7UVlg?feat=directlink

Re: Resawing for drawer bottoms

#9

Re: Resawing for drawer bottoms

Fred Davis

>Here is the middle 1800's furniture I spoke of , done by "Old World Craftsmen"

One of a Bedroom suite I am cleaning up , has cracked Marble top that the owners have ordered replacements for in granite.

If you look closely you can see the workmanship leaves a lot to be desired.

FredD

Re: Resawing for drawer bottoms

#11

several points of disagreement.....

Bill Tindall

>1. Properly dried lumber does not have stress so there is no issue resawing it so long as 1. it is stress free and 2. the moisture content is equal throughout

2. it doesn't matter because the bottom is held flat by the drawer sides.

3, there is no need to use quartered lumber in a drawer bottom, and less so to use oak. The back of a drawer bottom is never captured, hence, the bottom can expand or contract at will.

Bottom line- resaw some inexpensive wood like pine or poplar for the bottoms. Alternatively, don't resaw. Edge the bottom like a raised panel and install with the raised portion down. Disadvantage is that the drawer will be heavier, but this is no problem on a small drawer.

When it is available, I typically make bottoms out of the wood not attractive enough to use where it is exposed, for example cherry or walnut sapwood, or discolored wood.

Re: Resawing for drawer bottoms

#12

Re: Resawing for drawer bottoms

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod MA

>As you resaw, you will find internal stresses in some planks that cause the resawn pieces to move. At least that is my experience. The workaround is to resaw more than you need and feed the stove with the bent bits. You can improve your odds by using only straight grain planks with little or no runout.

The other problem you will run into is a difference in moisture content between the outside and inside of a plank. The outside might be drier because the heating season has started and relative humidity in the air is low. Meanwhile, the inside has more moisture content, acquired during the more humid summer months, now lessening but still more than the outside.

If you resaw a plank with this moisture content difference you will have pieces that are wet on one face and dry on the other. Instant pretzel :) Your advice to take equal amounts off both faces addresses this problem. The workaround is a climate-controlled workplace and wood storage area.

I resaw for veneer. I sometimes resaw narrow boards that can be forced into flatness if they move, such as molding. If I need drawer bottoms (or sides) I start with 3/4 or 4/4 remove equal amounts from both faces until I get the desired thickness. This is done over a period of days. The stock is jointed, thicknessed, stickered overnight, and repeat.

Re: Resawing for drawer bottoms

#13

Re: Resawing for drawer bottoms

Jim Hoeller------WebKitFormBoundarycQB+IfmNjFaVxeA

>If the wood was properly stress relieved at the end of the drying process, there will no appreciable internal stresses to create problems. I have been re-sawing 4/4 stock (flat sawn and quarter sawn) for book matched panels for quite a few projects and have not encountered any significant problems with warping or twisting.

If you can locate a small sawmill with a kiln that sells retail, ask the owner about the subject and act accordingly. If you buy from a hardwood dealer, ask the owner the same questions.

Re: Resawing for drawer bottoms

#14

Re: Resawing for drawer bottoms

Ken Kimura

>Doug, you live in the middle of a wealth of wood sources. Check Craig's list to word of mouth. I like to drive around and drop in on all the mill operators. From large operators to the wood mizer guys. You even have blow down from all the wind storms at this time of year. I like to use northwest species for my secondary woods, plain figured big leaf maple, alder, fir, pine, spruce etc. for drawer sides, bottoms and backs. Spruce is nice because of it's weight to strength. It doesn't seem to matter if the grain is quarter sawn or flat sawn. Both orientations will work. It depends on the look you want.

A lot of the wood I find is fresh cut. I find I can air dry up to 8/4 for a year and get to 12%-15% moisture in my unheated garage. Resawing from that point often produces stuff I can take to the planer right away and sometimes I'll let it sit another couple of weeks after cutting.

I would think twice about using stuff like quarter sawn white oak for drawer bottoms. Unless it's a special drawer, stick to the traditional secondary woods.