Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Drawer bottom grain orientation

Posts

Drawer bottom grain orientation

#1

Drawer bottom grain orientation

Doug Reynolds in Seattle

>When using solid wood for drawer bottoms, in this case 1/4" thick poplar for very small drawers about five inches wide and ten inches deep, does it make a big difference which way the grain runs? My understanding is that I should use quartersawn wood with the grain running from side to side so the natural expansion will be from front to back. But, my wood is not quartersawn.

Re: Drawer bottom grain orientation

#2

Re: Drawer bottom grain orientation

Andrew F in Australia

>Hi Doug,

Convention says yes, grain running parallel to the drawer front.

Allow for about 3mm or so shrinkage/expansion (1/8")

I thought: "would I go the other way," but the rear of the drawer bottom is not supported in traditional work, so you could be bowing out the drawer bottom until it snaps.

Cheers,

Andrew

Re: Drawer bottom grain orientation

#3

Puzzling English drawers

Bill Tindall

>I was in an antique store that specialized in English antiques. Several of the pieces built in the 1800's had drawers with the grain running with the depth of the drawer, and these were large drawers. Every one had gaping cracks. I had never seen drawers built this way before. These were otherwise nice mahogany pieces with finely dovetailed oak drawer sides. Other English case goods in this store had fine English drawers built with the grain running conventionally.

Re: Drawer bottom grain orientation

#4

Re: Drawer bottom grain orientation

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod MA

>Quartersawn wood would be nice for drawer bottoms but I don't think it is essential or even commonly used there.

I suppose you could run the grain front to back in such a narrow drawer if you make the back with a groove to capture the bottom (same as the sides and front) and leave a little slop in the 5" dimension, perhaps 1/16" to 1/8". The bottom would have to be in place when the drawer was assembled, obviously. Quartersawn would be nicer here as it would move less so you would need less slop.

All that said, for a solid wood bottom I'd make them the usual way. If I were making a drawer with a groove in the back I'd use plywood or mdf for the bottom.

Bill mentions the old English drawers with the bottom grain running the 'wrong' way. I've seen some of these as well. They may have worked in the days before central heating in a climate where the humidity is relatively constant (high in the case of England) but don't do well when moved into different conditions, hence the cracks.

Re: Drawer bottom grain orientation

#5

Ellis Walentine

What your eye expects to see

Ellis Walentine

>Even if we don't think about it, our eyes are used to certain relationships when we view furniture -- and a lot of other things, for that matter -- whether from our own studies or more generally from a lifetime of passive observation. Drawer bottom grain direction is one of these relationships. When the grain runs front to back, it may, explicitly or vaguely, seem different, if not wrong, to our eyes. As a designer, I know I can design the drawer so the grain runs front-to-back without any engineering shortfalls, but I can't overcome the tendency for the viewer's eye to prefer a side-to-side orientation, whether they can even articulate what is going on. You have to decide whether that matters to you in a particular instance.

Ellis

Re: Drawer bottom grain orientation

#6

Re: What your eye expects to see

Fred Davis

>Everybody sees drawers every day .

How many of them do you think check out the grain orientation?

Do they care about the type of joint used.

Or whether the drawer has a finish or not and does it matter.

Does the pull correlate to the style and period?

Does it have a style and period?

Now that you bring up seeing something that clashes with your past experience, when I see raised panel doors having the rail extend over the stile , that catches my attention , yet a very good woodworker like Chico does it that way and it appears to be a hallmark of his .

Not a rant Ellis , just a thought.

FredD

Re: Drawer bottom grain orientation

#7

Ellis Walentine

It's subconscious

Ellis Walentine

>I agree that we don't check out drawers to see the grain orientation; that awareness creeps into our subconscious without us even noticing. Then, when we see something that differs from the vague notion in our head, we notice it, or at least we sense that something is different. That sense of uneasiness adds tension to our apprehension of that piece.

I may be talking about way-too-subtle stuff here, but I firmly believe there is a subconscious dimension to this. We find comfort in the proportions of Greek architecture, not because we've studied it, but because it has influenced so much of architecture and design since then. When we play with these ratios and proportions, we can easily be aware of the difference without knowing what it is or why.

Ellis

Re: Drawer bottom grain orientation

#8

Re: It's subconscious

Fred Davis

>" When we play with these ratios and proportions, we can easily be aware of the difference without knowing what it is or why"

Indubitably Ellis,

on that note of scale and proportions , I believe the Egyptians beat the Greeks to it by a few thousand years.

I like your line about apprehension and tension adding to ones appreciation or lack of it when viewing a piece.

That becomes my feelings when I see a "conceptual chair " gathering eww's and ahh's and I am thinking, is it safe to sit on without collapsing?

FredD