Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Cutting off Router Bit?

Posts

Cutting off Router Bit?

#1

Cutting off Router Bit?

Barry Irby

>I bought some spiral router bits form Harbor Freight. (Don't get side tracked onto HF, I know they sell cheap crap, that's why I bought them, 3 for less than half the price of one "good" one.)

The problem is they are too long. They Are 1/4" in diameter and about 3" long. They have about 1" of shank and 2" of cutter. The router I use has only about 1 to 1 1/2" of hollow shaft. If I try to take anything but a very light cut the bits vibrate and chatter or whip. Because you can only take a light cut, you end up working all the time with the first 1/4" of the bit. Even if I could chuck it deeper I am concerned it would score the collet. So, how does one cut off a router bit? Anybody done it? Seems these would be much better if they were 1/2" or and 1" shorter.

Re: Cutting off Router Bit?

#2

You Don't

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>You Buy Cheap . . . Deal with it, Barry.

You do NOT attempt to shorten such things until and unless you've signed up for the "Darwin Awards, 2010 Smackdown Edition"

They Vibrate? (what a surprise!)

They Chatter? (nah, really?)

They skip? (Imagine that . . .)

[pssst, Barry . . . put them in the garbage, don't tell your wife, go get yourself descent tooling, and . . .)

STOP ASKING STUPID QUESTIONS THAT AMOUNT TO SEEKING HELP FROM YOUR FRIENDS TO HELP YOU COMMIT SUICIDE!!

Re: Cutting off Router Bit?

#3

Re: You Don't

Howard Norman

>Barry's question was not a stupid question, there are no stupid questions. I would agree however that I would not want to try to shorten a router bit.

Your remark at the end of your post is completely out of line Mark.

howard

Re: Cutting off Router Bit?

#4

Re: Cutting off Router Bit?

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Barry,

Try grinding it off with your bench grinder. You should be able to get it done quickly and evenly.

George

Re: Cutting off Router Bit?

#5

I wouldn't.....

Brian in Sandusky, OH

>Some bits are solid carbide, and some have the carbide brazed onto steel.

If a piece of the carbide comes flying off due to vibrations of being cut, you could be in trouble.

Re: Cutting off Router Bit?

#6

Ellis Walentine

Mark's comments aside... :)

Ellis Walentine

>... if it were me and there were no other game in town, I wouldn't hesitate to grind off the bit. BUT, this is just my opinion and I'm not recommending it. If you do decide to take the plunge (pardon the pun), j ust use the corner of your grinding wheel to make an ever-deeper V-groove at the desired length until you've cut through the bit, then flatten off the end. It won't be able to plunge directly into the wood because the cutting geometry on the tip will be gone, but it shouldn't be dangerous in any way. If you were modifying a bigger bit where the imbalance would be magnified by the diameter of the bit, I'd be a lot more concerned about offering this advice.

Ellis

PS I'm open to suggestions about this bit of advice.

Re: Cutting off Router Bit?

#7

Bad day, missed med's

John b. SW chicago burbs

>The preferred way to cut carbide would be with a diamond wheel. Aluminum oxide wheels would just over heat the carbide. Work safely it can be done. John b.

Re: Cutting off Router Bit?

#8

Relax, Howard

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Barry knows me well enough to know that my all CAPS verse is a joke, even if you don't.

Re: Cutting off Router Bit?

#9

More importantly,

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Using a grinder or cut-off wheel on a brazed carbide bit is almost guaranteed to generate sufficient heat to weaken and/or crack the bronze brazing holding the carbide to the steel. When the bit is then used, the bit can easily fly apart sending razor sharp chunks of carbide flying at significant velocities. Cutting (dressing) of carbide cutters is done with diamond abrasives in properly cooled and lubricated machines with a fair amount of precision.

The risk of serious personal injury so far outweighs any possible benefit to Barry's question that, all joking aside, I stand by my original post.

JUST DON'T DO IT.

Re: Cutting off Router Bit?

#10

THANKS, I THINK.....

Barry Irby

>Oddly these bits might be the best thing I ever bought at HF. The problem is they have an abundance of cutting edge. I bought them to ruin. I was repairing hardwood flooring and had to make about fifty cuts in it to replace numerous pieces. Ruined about three expensive bits hitting nails in less than an hour. (Finally found the nails with rare earth magnets) These bits survived the process. Unlike most of HF's stuff, these appear beautifully made except they are poorly proportioned. Usually I gripe about bits being too short. My thinking was that if I shortened them they would be far less dangerous. I suspect the vibration and chatter is going to kill one and cause a chunk of it to go flying. These are solid HSS (I think)and do not have welded on cutters. Normally, I don't buy cheap, but I was tired of trashing expensive ones in seconds.

Re: Cutting off Router Bit?

#11

Yes-s-s-s

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Have bought "waste" tooling for particular jobs the same way. I use the "sacrificial" cutters to make the rough cuts, then came back with the quality bits to clean up the edges and make my final joints.

Re: Cutting off Router Bit?

#12

Two lessons here.....

Barry Irby

>One, probably not smart to cut off a router bit.

Two, When cutting hardwood floor, use rare earth magnets to find the nails before you cut. Tried a metal detector, actually two. Not accurate enough. They just went nuts. There were nails everywhere, in and under the flooring. Just take a little round magnet and roll it slowly down the edges of the boards and boing!, they snap to attention right over the nails. Mark them with pencil or chalk and avoid them. Did the whole job with one bit after that. Could have used a better bit.

Re: Cutting off Router Bit?

#13

Re: Missed Med's

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>New Years is only a couple of days away . . . |:-}}}

Re: Cutting off Router Bit?

#14

award contention

Bill Tindall

>If Ellis gives an award for best advice in 2009 this answer is a top contender!

Re: Cutting off Router Bit?

#15

Re: Relax, Howard

Howard Norman

>No matter how well you know Barry I still believe that your post was out of bounds on a public forum. I would accept that for friends it would be appropriate in email but not a public forum. Just my opinion, lets drop the subject.

Re: Cutting off Router Bit?

#16

PS

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>HSS cutters can be ground to your own particular specs. I've made my own self-piloting cutters out of HSS stock for years.

I assumed (wrongly?) from your original post, that the bits in question had carbide knives brazed on.

I have personal knowledge of one young man who tried to modify/sharpen a carbide-construct router bit. He'll take the facial scar to his grave, but the safety glasses I made him wear saved his right eye.

Re: Cutting off Router Bit?

#17

Re: Mark's comments aside... :)

Justin Szeliga

>I have an old bit I ground the bearing screw off of, I think. It's been so long, I'm not sure what I ground off, but it was a cheap old Woodworkers Warehouse bit, I needed something that was less than what I had, & the grinder took it off nicely.

Re: Cutting off Router Bit?

#18

cut it with a drimel and cutoff wheel

Wayne Carson

>

Re: Cutting off Router Bit?

#19

Dale Lenz

Re: Cutting off Router Bit?

Dale Lenz

>Barry, I'd take them back to HF and spend some decent coin on a good bit. The way I look at it, One good router bit is better than A dozen+ trashed bits. What's that Ol' saying: Can't make a silk purse out of a sow's ear or some such BS as that, : ' >.

Re: Cutting off Router Bit?

#20

Re: cut it with a drimel and cutoff wheel

Howard Norman

>One of the problems with cutting off a router bit is that it is almost guaranteed to be out of balance after cutting. I don't like the idea of rotating an out of balance item at 10-20k rpm's.

Re: Cutting off Router Bit?

#21

are you sure they're router bits?

Larry Williams

>They sound like end mills to me.

Re: Cutting off Router Bit?

#22

I would cut it off too, Ellis

A Wright

>it really isn't much different than a 1/2" HSS drill bit, and I have sharpened plenty of those with a bench grinder with no ill side effects

The main thing to watch for is to go slow so that you don't overheat the bit and cause it to lose its temper