Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

OT Leaky toilet Question, need help

Posts

OT Leaky toilet Question, need help

#1

OT Leaky toilet Question, need help

Barry Irby

>I have a toilet that has an odd (to me) flush valve/flapper. It is sort of a teeter totter thing. Its white hard plastic with a round end with rubber gasket and the other end is a cylinder about the size of a 35mm film canister. The cylinder has a hole in it and when you flush the water in it hold the flapper open momentarily until the water in it runs out. Then the flapper tips down and it seats. This is not the typical soft rubber flapper.

The problem is that the toilet runs occasionally and refills. Water is wasting, going down the drain. Turns out the flapper part is expensive and hard to come by at least in this end of the country. The first one lasted about 20 years. Replaced it a few months ago and it is leaking again.

Now I am trying to figure out exactly what the problem is. The seat for this is smooth white plastic and it feels and looks in good shape. The rubber gasket seems to be in good shape. The seal between the mechanism and the tank is some sort of soft rubber. It has deteriorated to the point that it leaves a very black inky stain on your finger if you touch it.

My question is, could it be leaking between the mechanism and the tank and not at the flapper? How can I tell? Is there a simple way to seal the hole for the flapper, fill the tank with water and wait? I was thinking about using a plumber's plug that expands into the opening, but I don't know if one comes in the right size and it might crack the plastic. Is this a job for Duct tape? Any suggestions? Any help would be appreciated. Wonder if I can change the entire mechanism?

Re: OT Leaky toilet Question, need help

#2

Ellis Walentine

Re: OT Leaky toilet Question, need help

Ellis Walentine

>I'm no plumber but when I've had flappers start disintegrating, I've just replaced them. Any half-decent plumbing supply house will tell you what you need, for whatever toilet style you have.

Ellis

Re: OT Leaky toilet Question, need help

#3

Re: OT Leaky toilet Question, need help *LINK*

Phil in Connecticut

>Flush/flapper valve could be leaking where it seals to the tank. Try shutting water supply off,then flush and hold flapper open until water empties from tank: this will leave water level at the edge of the flapper seat. If this level is not maintained over time, you may have a leak between the flapper valve body and the tank. My experience: even though the flapper seat and/or flapper feels OK, it may still leak. Try this web site to research toilet parts:


Toilet Parts

Re: OT Leaky toilet Question, need help

#4

Yeah, but....

Barry Irby

>This is a weird one and I had to search all over for a replacement. Founds this supply house that is believe it or not in a abandoned McDonald's. They specialize in the weird and wonderful. Looks more like the Star Wars bar scene than a typical plumbing supply house. Prices to match. the Gasket for the flapper was over $20. The Flapper was not available, but would have been over $30. Actually I was pretty happy, even at that price, but now it's leaking again. I'm on a cost reduction water saving campaign around here. Wanted to be sure I was working on the right part.

Re: OT Leaky toilet Question, need help

#5

Re: OT Leaky toilet Question, need help

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Morning Barry,

I'd replace the whole flapper assembly. and, if the flapper assembly is independent of the filler valve/ball cock, etc, I'd replace the flapper with a more common variety. As the father of 10, toiletology became an unwelcome specialty.

George

Re: OT Leaky toilet Question, need help

#6

Re: OT Leaky toilet Question, need help

GalenV in Iowa

>Barry

When I work on a toilet I remove the tank cover and drop a few drops of food coloring above the flush mechanism. The food coloring is heavier than water. It will slowly drift down to the bottom and you can generally see where the dye is being drawn into. The last time I worked on one it was the seal for the ball seat to the bottom of the tank. When I went to replace the seal the brass draw bolt clamping it down broke as it has almost completely been eaten through. Got lucky and found the special bolt.

At least you should be able to find the leak. Parts like you say is another story.

Galen

Re: OT Leaky toilet Question, need help

#7

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Yeah, but....

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

>Well... If you're really on a water saving crusade her, maybe it's time to replace the toilet with a new, water-saving tw0-mode flush model.

Your current twenty-plus year old model is likely flushing a at least 3� gallons per, or maybe even 5 gallons per. A new two-mode onw will flush 1.0 gallons for liquid waste, and 1.6 gallons for solids. That'd be quite a savings overall.

Even a low end new model - maybe 75 bucks - would save over 50% of the water you're now using, and would likely end up being cheaper than replacement parts for your 'dinosaur.'

Jim D.

Re: OT Leaky toilet Question, need help

#8

Re: Yeah, but....

Barry Irby

>Hmm, have to think about that. This toilet is supposed to be a very expensive unit, which is part of why it has oddball parts. I like it comfortwise better than my other toilets. But You might be right, time to get a new two flush long bowl toilet, save water and eliminate the weird parts.

Re: OT Leaky toilet Question, need help

#9

Re: Yeah, but....

Joseph Mulherin, Sr.

>That is exactly what Jim just said....replace the old toilet entirely and get one of the new water saving units. Go to HD and buy an elongated bowl, tank, seat, wax seal w/bolts for $88.00 + sales tax.

Stop penny pinching and do the right thing!!!

Re: OT Leaky toilet Question, need help

#10

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Yeah, but....

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

>And if you want to upgrade 'comfort' as well, spend a few more bucks and get one of the 'chair height' models.

We replaced both of our old models with "comfort height" Kohlers (a bit pricier at about $250.00 each) and have been very satisfied with both their comfort and their reliability.

Jim D.

Re: OT Leaky toilet Question, need help

#11

Just Buy a toilet rebuild Kit

Dave (PacNW)

>The rebuild kit has ALL the parts to completely rebuild the offending toilet for about $14.00 at the BORG. If you are using an in the tank bowl cleaner, STOP! They are chlorine based and will dissolve or other wise attack rubber seals and O-rings

Dave(PacNW)

Re: OT Leaky toilet Question, need help

#12

How tall are you?

Barry Irby

>I'm on the short side and find the taller toilets to be uncomfortable. I feel like a little kid sitting there with my feet dangling. It's not really THAT bad but still not my favorite experience.

Re: OT Leaky toilet Question, need help

#13

Tall Enough That My Legs Reach The Floor

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>

Re: OT Leaky toilet Question, need help

#14

When I Am Standing Up

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>

Re: OT Leaky toilet Question, need help

#15

Wow, we must be exactly the same height.!

Barry Irby

>

Re: OT Leaky toilet Question, need help

#16

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: How tall are you?

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

>I'm 5'8". My wife is 5'0". We both find the Kohlers to be comfortable.

Note - they're not ADA height - just a couple inches higher than 'standard.' The ADA compliant ones are a fair bit higher than that.

Jim D.