Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Trimming a workbench with dissimilar wood

Posts

Trimming a workbench with dissimilar wood

#1

Trimming a workbench with dissimilar wood

Ed Beck

>I have a workbench top made from an old bowling alley lane. It�s hard rock maple and in the process of trimming it to size I cut through nails and have left behind some burn marks. Even if I were to sand the burn marks out the exposed nails would still be there, so I figure I need to trim it.

I�d like to trim it with jatoba (Brazilian cherry) because it�s a hard wood, will match the mahogany dots in the top of the table but is less expensive than mahogany. I�ve got a few questions about these woods growing and shrinking at different rates.



  • How much should I worry about these two woods expanding and contracting at different rates?


  • What kind of joint would you use?


  • Since I�m building this in my freezing cold garage (average of about 40 degrees) about how much room would you leave for expansion? (The top is 92 �� x 38 1/2�)


  • What should I be thinking about that I haven�t mentioned?




By the way, my wife got me a propane heater that I can use inside use for Christmas, it looks like it�s going to make life in the garage this winter much more bearable.

Thanks all,

Re: Trimming a workbench with dissimilar wood

#2

Re: Trimming a workbench with dissimilar wood

Howard Acheson

>You can not attach a solid wood to the end grain of your top. The bowling alley part will want to expand/contract with changes in relative humidity any that restricts this movement will lead to failures or warping.

Re: Trimming a workbench with dissimilar wood

#3

JL

Re: Trimming a workbench with dissimilar wood

JL

>Sure, you can trim it out with jatoba or anything you wish. Just make sure you don't anchor the end grain down.

I trimmed my maple bench with maple. I've got side skirts of maple (3"+ thick x 3+" wide) that I drilled for my dog holes and then glued to the 2 1/4" thick top. I bolted my end skirts to the bench top with a central bolt and two end bolts with elongated bolt holes. I cut a long tenon for the top and a dado for the length of the skirt. The bolts go into the tenon. I've know people who have used sliding dovetails.

Re: Trimming a workbench with dissimilar wood

#4

Re: Trimming a workbench with dissimilar wood

mdclor

>Ed,

Propane heaters put a lot of moisture into the air. Since your tools will be colder than the newly heated air, you will get condensation on your cold tools. Be certain to apply a good coat of wax or other protective coating to any metal surfaces that you don't want to rust. DAMHIKT.

Good luck,

Merle

Re: Trimming a workbench with dissimilar wood

#5

Through slots on ends

Ed Beck

>This is almost what I was thinking of doing. I was planning on a central bolt which would be tightened down, and then use my router to route out a couple of through slots on the ends of the skirt about 2" long. The through slot would be large enough to accomodate a bolt and I'd route out the top of the slot to accomodate the bolt head and a socket wrench. The end bolts would not be tightened down, instead I'd leave them loose so they could move in the slot when the wood moves.

Does that sound reasonable?

I had not thought of the tenon and dado, mostly because I don't want to go anywhere near that top with a router (it has nails all over the place).

Can I afix the jatoba trim to the sides and not worry about the wood moving or would the same type of slot be better?

Thanks,

Re: Trimming a workbench with dissimilar wood

#6

JL

Re: Through slots on ends

JL

>You aren't really going to get any movement along the length of the wood, so you can glue the skirts.

What you have described is what I did - but I have the tenons. With the tenons, I didn't have to worry about leveling the end skirts to top. I really contemplated doing a dovetail - but the router that I had at the time was not up to it.

Re: Trimming a workbench with dissimilar wood

#7

Re: Through slots on ends

Fred Davis

>Ed,

since you do not want to risk a router bit in the nail embedded Maple, think about a nice healthy spline , say about a 1"1/2 and a 1/2" thick and screw it to the end .

One bolt or screw in the middle is all you need to hold it against the bench. Even better is a making a sliding dovetail out of it as one poster suggested. Anyway you do it , you do not want to capture the end cap between the side skirts, so you will see the ends of the splines.

Just to my way of thinking I see no problem with using the alley as is with a good sanding and scraping, after all it is a work bench , not furniture.

FredD

Re: Trimming a workbench with dissimilar wood

#8

Re: Trimming a workbench with dissimilar wood

Barry Irby

>I was thinking about that heater. I have had one for about two years, still sitting in the box. Also have the long hose for it that allows it to connect to a larger tank. Have not used it because I have a small electric heater that manages to do the job, if somewhat slowly. I have use prob[pane before, but had a much lager heater and it would run out of the shop in a matter of minutes. Used it to knock the chill off quickly and then the electric could keep up, but the moisture was a problem in cold weather. In mild weather the electric heater was enough. Consider getting an electric "barn" heater and use the propane sparingly.

I might run the Jotaba along the sides mostly for decoration and leave the ends alone, or work out one of the scenarios that allows for expansion.

Back to the heater for a second. My shop is in a basement garage. If I get it toasty warm, I find that air rises from the shop into the house and carries dust with it. Better to have the shop cooler than the house.

Re: Trimming a workbench with dissimilar wood

#9

Re: Through slots on ends

Howard Acheson

>>>> I was planning on a central bolt which be tightened down, and then use my router to route out a couple of through slots on the ends of the skirt about 2" long.

Plan carefully where you put the fixed (non-sliding) bolt verses the sliding bolt. Sometimes it's best to keep the front of the end board fixed and let all of the movement be at the back. That's how it is on my bench.