We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>First of all I'll say that I respect other peoples choices of equipment for whatever reason they choose them, but one thing I can't stand is someone blowing dust up my port. There is what I believe is a disturbing sales pitch going on in a Ryobi BT3 forum, and I know not everyone can afford the best, I certainly can't, but I have learned that junk is expensive also in the long run. The site in question heavily promotes Harbor Freight tools as good quality tools and promotes the Ryobi BT3 table saw as being as accurate as a Cabinet table saw, and that it also is possibly the first Hybrid table saw. Some members have claimed to actually have sold their Unisaw's for a BT3 and never looked back, how stupid do these people think others are ? The place reminds me of a cult.
>I guess what also bothers me about the trend is that this country is loseing jobs left and right, we just lost 450 jobs intown yesterday at a plant that makes Bobcat skid steer loaders. Maybe it's time people start fighting back and start buying made in the USA machinery, and if you can't afford that, buy used. In the long run it's a much better investment, and it doesn't reward companies that send jobs overseas. The next job loss might be your own.
>Suddenly I had a flashback to late-90s BT3000-bashing, something I thought had vanished over the years as Ryobi pretty much gave up on the idea of innovating. And looking through recent BT3Central postings - this likely relevant one in particular - I don't see anything particularly shocking on the Harbor Freight front.
Whatever your opinions about the BT3000 - I have one, and my opinions are mixed - I have to say I've always found the community impressive, resourceful, willing to help, and supportive even of people who make other choices. A little defensive perhaps, but that's not surprising given the history.
The saw was ahead of its time in a lot of ways - instead of a splitter, the guard moves like a riving knife. It had dust collection that I think compares well with the hybrids. It's adjustable and extensible in all kinds of ways. However, it uses much softer and less stable aluminum construction than most cabinet saws, and a universal motor which has drawbacks even if it did make the design possible.
If you're willing to fiddle with it, though, you can get great results. That's a big if for a lot of people, especially as parts get harder to find. I expect to replace mine in a few years, but for now, it'll do just fine...
I've never been on the BT3 forums so I don't know what claims they are making, but I can speak to my experience with the BT3000 that I've had for about 3 years.
I bought the BT3000 for two reasons. The first and primary was cost, the second was portability. I get a little tired of the attitude on so many woodworking forums that the key to fine woodwork is buying expensive tools.
At any rate, what I discovered with the BT3 was a saw that was far beyond my expectations. I have used unisaws and I would put the precision and the ease of adjustment of the BT3 in the same class. Plus, you have to spend extra to get a sliding table for your unisaw. 8^]
I would not claim that the BT3 has anywhere near the power of a cabinet saw, but it does have adequate power for the work I do. I don't know how many thousand turning blanks and pen blanks that I've sawed with it out of all varieties of wood including dry hickory and osage orange.
If I had the money and never needed to move the saw, would I buy a unisaw or similar? Of course I would.
As far as Harbor Freight tools go, there is some very good value in that store if you know what to look for. There are a lot of us around who can't afford to shop at WoodCraft, much less the pricier vendors.
>Yeah, I don't know, a site where alot of it's members praise Harbor Frieght, and have to stretch the truth about what the BT3's actually are doesn't impress me much. I'm not so sure that I'd take much of their advice seriously.
>and it's generally been right on when I needed it. Mostly about the BT3000, of course.
I'm not sure what inspires you to dive into BT3Central to challenge a community of folks who love their saws. The folks there have used the saws for years, and I think you'll find pretty much all of them are aware of the limitations as well as the benefits. You use something else, and that's great, but why the missionary fervor?
Will you be visiting Festool Owners Group next, to tell them that their tools are overdesigned and overpriced? I mean, they do talk about how their system can be an alternative to table saws completely...
>I probably wouldn't buy one myself, but there was a guy, can't remember the name, that posted either here or possibly on Badger Pond several years (over 5) back that lived either in Australia or New Zealand and produced magnificent furniture matched only by a few people I've seen posting here. I mean this was really nice and very original stuff. He used a BT3, with an assortment of home made jigs. His stuff was in no way simple to make and completely original. I think I have some pictures, but I don't have them on this machine and I won't be home for another week.
Michael Fortune an exceptional woodworker who, based on his articles, favors the bandsaw over the tablesaw and typically uses a 14". Not what you would expect from someone of his standing. He also dispelled the idea of bandsaw drift in an article that broke down how to properly tune your bandsaw so drift was never an issue. Yet Laguna, Mark Duginske and others still sell bandsaw fences designed to "eliminate" drift.
Anyway, I wish I had access to those pictures now so I could give some examples of what can be done with a BT3.
-Craig
Again, I probably wouldn't buy one, but I won't pay $3000 for a Unisaw either.
>Was the handle of that Aussie gentleman. You are totally correct in that he did create some of the most outstanding work I've ever seen. Howie Long doesn't know what he is talking about in that commercial when he says, "Don't blame the carpenter, blame the tool." A truly talented individual can indeed make a silk purse out of a sows ear.
>Yeah, I think that was him. There is a Woodcentral "Craftsmen" link to what use to be his site, www.australianwoodart.com, but the link is up for sale now, so he must have moved on.
>I think that it's fairly obvious that you don't need alot to be a good woodworker, for instance, the woodwright shop. But for those that try to make a liveing in woodworking generally try to buy whats more efficient and hopefully pays for itself. The guy you talk about that did, or still does great work with a Ryobi table saw only tells me that he's got more time then money, and that woodworking probably isn't too profitable for him, if it was, he'd have a better saw. I bet you won't find many, if any Ryobi BT's in proffessional cabinet shops. Whatever, I'm so tired of explaining what should be so obvious, or is even just plain common sense.
>As a former BT-3 owner, I can state from experience that the tool will do quality work if taken care of properly. It will not (and wasn't designed for) do production work or replace a 3+hp cabinet saw for ripping heavy/tough stock. The biggest drawbacks I found were the need to retune it every other month or so and its propensity to burn up the geared belts by putting too much stress on the blade. I sold mine for about 70% of what I paid for it after I bought my cabinet saw, but should probably have held it for a "garage" saw. It had a number of innovations for it's day (like the integrated router table, riving knife, and linear elevator).
Websites like the club for this saw are a mutual admiration society for the main object of their affection. It's a waste of time trying to convince them otherwise. There are similar sites for the Chevy Corvair and Ford Pinto ("Unsafe At Any Speed" and "Four Door Portable Oven") and you'll never convince their devotees that they're anything other than great cars.
I know a number of professionals (contractors and tradesmen) who buy tools from Harbor Freight and similar outfits all the time, the reason being that the tools will get trashed, stolen, or lost while in use so it makes no sense to them to buy good stuff. These guys do high quality work with what some would call junk tools, but their choices make economic sense for them from a cost/benefit view. If you drop a $100 saw and a $500 saw off the same roof, they both wind up in the same dumpster.
>I did a search for him and, unfortunately, didn't find an recent posts. I think the last dated post was 2005, which stated he had been professionally woodworking for 7 years. That means he wasn't doing it as a hobby. If you could see his work you would know that was true.