Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

New Owner Reviews Of Tools, Machines and Jigs

Posts

New Owner Reviews Of Tools, Machines and Jigs

#1

New Owner Reviews Of Tools, Machines and Jigs

charlie belden

>New Owner Reviews Of Tools, Machines and Jigs

Most reviews / evaluations of a tool, machine or jig are done by a proud new owner of the tool, machine or jig who has just recently successfully made the �test joint� demonstrated at a show or on a DVD� or by a writer for a woodworking magazine who is only going to have the thing to play with for maybe a few hours or days and who has a deadline for his or her review.

So it�s not surprising that the tool, machine or jig review will be based on what it takes to do the task probably used in a demonstration of �it� at a woodworking show or on the included video or DVD and how well the results turn out. That demonstration was probably carefully selected by the manufacturer to show off the tool, machine or jig�s strengths � and � not include any of its weaknesses. If you want to sell someone a moderately expensive tool, machine or jig, you want to make it look as quick, easy and fool proof to use � so of course the demonstration is designed to do just that.

Given the above, most tool, machine or jig reviews are pretty favorable and perhaps even glowing. No wonder. The review is typically based on reproducing what the Manufacturer carefully selected to show off the thing�s strengths � and hide its weakness(es).

But to provide a fairly complete and objective evaluation of a tool, machine or jig, you have to have used it for two, three or four Real World projects, each project weeks or months apart. Only then will the evaluation / review provide a real world feel for what the thing does, how well, how quickly, how accurately and how easily.

Here�s where the ball gets dropped. The review / evaluation is usually written before �the glow� of successfully using �it� to make the Demonstration Joint. The review / evaluation is seldom, if ever, revised to reflect �discoveries� after months have gone buy since the acquisition, it�s been used for several real world projects � and �the glow� of new ownership has faded.

To be fare to the reviewers / evaluators, it�s difficult to do a decent evaluation of something � and then do a clear and understandable write up � and probably do illustrations to show things that are tricky to describe with just words. Good illustrations are not trivial to come up with � and new owners don�t usually have an Art Department to turn to for help.

The other difficulty in doing a decent review is having a good idea of what your reader does or doesn�t know about the subject for which the thing being reviewed is to do. There�s a LOT more to a mortise and tenon joint than just making a hole in one part and a �finger� on the end of the other part. Do you explain the need for proper stock prep, the importance of layout lines � from Reference Faces and Reference Ends � and the need to identify and keep track of them, the significance of parts orientation when performing operations, . . . ?

It sure would be nice if there were One Year Later or Six Months Later follow up reviews of tools, machines and jigs that really evaluated it, based on actual experience making real world projects � like say a table, with set back apron in the case of a mortise and tenon or loose tenon mortise and tenon jig.

It would also be nice if the reviewer looked for weaknesses rather than focusing on strengths. If the weaknesses are easily compensated for and aren�t worth mentioning that�s fine. But if a fairly common operation is a PITA to perform THAT should be noted and potential buyers be made aware of.

So � have YOU acquired a tool, machine or jig based on a demonstration or review/evaluation � and later found yourself asking �Why wasn�t this pointed out in the review or demonstration?� or �Now how in the world will I get this thing to do ____?� If so, did you provide ANY feedback � to the reviewer, or ask the demonstrator at the next woodworking show how to get around this �shortcoming�?

If you�ve done a review or evaluation of a tool, machine or jig, did you go back and revised the review later � after you�ve used the thing on a few projects � and found some weakness(es)?

Re: New Owner Reviews Of Tools, Machines and Jigs

#2

Re: New Owner Reviews Of Tools, Machines and Jigs

jesse cloud

>Very interesting comments Charlie. I think you made several good points. I think long and hard before saying anything negative about a tool, thinking 'maybe its just me' or 'maybe if I fiddled with it a little longer I could get it to work.'

Here are some ideas we could try...

How about a thread titled something like "What tool is gathering dust in your shop and why?" or "What tools have you had for 2 years now, and what do you think of them?" or "What tool was a surprise for you?" or "What tool has left your shop lately?" or "What tool are you thinking of selling/tossing/etc?"

I admit that I'm pretty impatient with tools and if I don't bond with them in a year, they go on Craigslist. Maybe some of these reviews would have sped up my process or even have convinced me I had a gem in the rough....

I have been using Festools for about two years now. Most of them I love, some I still haven't figured out, and a couple just didn't fit my style. Maybe I could write that up if anyone is interested...

Re: New Owner Reviews Of Tools, Machines and Jigs

#3

Re: New Owner Reviews Of Tools, Machines and Jigs

charlie belden

>Jesse

"Maybe its just me." or "Maybe if I fiddled with it a little longer I could get it to work." are probably what most of us think when a tool doesn't meet the expectations The Ad or The Demo implied. Sure would be nice if the tool came with a Trouble Shooting Section to help diagnose common User Errors - and provide solutions to them. Finding out if It's Me Or The Tool would be really nice.

Your ideas for thread titles to bring out actual users' Likes & Gripes about a tool they've become familiar with using - or not - would be helpful to someone thinking about spending a chunk of change on a tool, machine or jig.

As for Festool tools, I agree that some are really good - and some ho-hum or not so good. Though I wasn't sure about HOW it would make doing loose tenon mortise and tenon joinery quick and easy I recongized what I believed to be a revolutionary tool which used a new idea to make a very old type of joint. Festool's jig/reciprocating saw on the other hand has been a big disappointment - the additional cost doesn't add anything to its functionality - which is what I expect from Festool tools. I still lust after their plunge circular saw and guide though.

Don't know about others, but I'd like to learn about your Likes & Gripes of a tool or jig you've used and gotten to know.

Re: New Owner Reviews Of Tools, Machines and Jigs

#4

agree - need longer term, depth

Simon St.Laurent - Dryden, NY

>It's funny as I return to my shop after a few years mostly away, and wonder why I bought certain items. Sometimes it becomes very clear quickly, but other times I remember a review that convinced me and just sigh. And then I have a few tools I really don't like, but use frequently anyway.

I do, however, have one item in the basement that's gotten mostly lousy reviews and made me fairly crazy but I've decided I'm not going to let beat me: a Craftsman dovetail jig. More on that as I get... somewhere.