Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Saw Stop Question

Posts

Saw Stop Question

#1

Saw Stop Question

Wayne Carson

>Every time I see a demo on the Saw Stop they show a hot dog going through the blade at a snails pace. When I push a piece of wood through the blade it is at a lot faster speed. They need to push the hot dog through sitting on a piece of wood and cutting at normal speed and let us see the damage to the dog.

Re: Saw Stop Question

#2

Re: Saw Stop Question

Howard Norman

>>They need to push the hot dog through sitting on a piece of wood and cutting at normal speed and let us see the damage to the dog.<

Good point!

h

Re: Saw Stop Question

#3

Re: Saw Stop Question

Neal in San Jose

>I don't know where you are seeing the demos, but every one I've seen has been done at a faster speed that I usally saw. Come by the Sawdust Shop in Santa Clara, the Woodcraft in Dublin or the Woodcraft in San Mateo. Their demos are always at higher than normal speed so that the hot dog gets a cut that is large enough to see. If they just crept up on the blade, you wouldn't even be able to see where the blade touched the hot dog. I just checked the SawStop website, and their on-line demo is not in slow motion. I don't know how fast you normally saw, but that looks about right for my sawing.

I suddenly feel like an authority on this subject. Saturday evening I put my right index finger where it shouldn't have been, and my SawStop did exactly what it is supposed to do. As a result, I'm typing this response with 10 fingers instead of 9 1/2. I was sawing at a normal (for me) speed using a sled when my saw triggered. It took several minutes for any blood to show up, the cut was so small. I didn't feel a thing, and at first I thought the saw had mis-fired. I was already removing the spent brake cartridge before I realized that I had made a mistake and my saw had just saved me from myself.

Neal, true believer!!!!

Re: Saw Stop Question

#4

Re: Saw Stop Question

jesse cloud

>Good point about the demo - sounds pretty lame.

The saw stop does work though. They use them at the community college where I take woodworking classes. They have fired a couple of times. Once might have been a misfire, the other clearly saved a finger. Hard to tell about misfires, no one wants to admit doing something stupid...

Re: Saw Stop Question

#5

There's another reason why during demos *LINK*

North of the Border

>the operator would push the hot dog not too fast: doing so may distort the actually cutting outcome. This is what I mean: the cutting teeth of a blade are very sharp, even if it is not spinning but held steady, and if you push you finger hard and fast into it, you may get a deep cut on the finger. To avoid people thinking that the sawstop doesn't prevent a deep cut, that's why the hot dog is fed into a blade at a pace or speed that is normal when we push stock through a blade. I don't know about other woodworkers' practice, but I never push my stock too fast or too slow or in a sudden manner.


http://www.woodworkingteachers.com/Default.aspx?g=posts&t=571

Re: Saw Stop Question

#6

Re: Saw Stop Question

Brian in Sandusky, OH

>I forget where I saw it, but I did see a demonstration where someone put a hot dog on a stick.

They then swung the hot dog into the blade.

Much faster of a rate than what a woodworker would ever do in normal operation.

It was still a tiny nick.

Consider this - the brake stops the blade in less than a thou of a second...literally.

The blade is stopped so fast that only two teeth make contact on a 40 tooth blade, before the blade is stopped and retracted

Go to the Sawstop website and look at the high speed videos.

Whether your hand is traveling at .5 feet per second, or 5 feet per second will make very very little difference.

Also - look again at the regular speed videos on the website.

They are feeding that 1/2 sheet stock faster than I feed 1/2 stock. And the thicker, the slower I feed.

Re: Saw Stop Question

#7

Re: Saw Stop Question

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>IIRC, the guy sticking his finger into the blade was the SawStop inventor. He did it very slowly, but I was still pretty well convinced it would work.

Re: Saw Stop Question

#8

Re: Saw Stop Question

GalenV in Iowa

>I've seen the hot dog demo and I cannot say it was fed in as fast as you would in normal cutting. I just figured you would end up with a deeper cut but hopefully have your finger.

I did watch a film of the inventor putting his finger to the blade. Not being totally stupid he put his finger up to the SIDE of the blade back of the teeth.

My former father-in-law was a farmer and his hands were as dry and tough as old leather. He could hold on to a 120 line and just say he thought it was live by a light tingle. He would pull a fibre catridge fuse out of the box by griping the metal end caps while line was live.

I figure if he would have had a saw stop he would be missing fingers.

Wonder also at what moisture content the unit would conduct and trigger just cutting. Maybe the owners manual covers wet wood but probably not leather like paws.

Not going to test one!

Galen

Re: Saw Stop Question

#9

Re: Saw Stop Question

davhamm

>You can test to see if your wood is to wet by touching the blade when its not on and checking or light or some such thing. If it is, you can deactivate the system to cut the wet wood.

Not sure how your FIL would lose his finger on a saw with this feature.

Re: Saw Stop Question

#10

Faster than I would saw...

Joe Pack

>I've seen the live demo twice. In fact, I was offered the chance to be the guy pushing the 3/4 ply and hotdog into the blade, but I chickened out. Both times the feed rate was as fast, and, I think, faster than I would cut a piece of 3/4 ply.

Re: Saw Stop Question

#11

Re: Saw Stop Question

GalenV in Iowa

>Just figured if it takes a condutive finger to activate the safety feature then FIL hands are so dry and hard they are like a well seasoned wood. Seems like his finger would not activate the system.

He would have been the type to stick his finger in the saw just to see IF it worked.

Re: Saw Stop Question

#12

Re: Saw Stop Question

Fred Davis

>Conductivity may not be case Galen, I had a retired Electrical Contractor who did Kitchen rewires for me and he routinely checked the back splash outlets for current by grasping both sides of the outlet.

He too said he only felt a slight tingle and his hands were not work worn like your Father-in-law or my hands for that matter.

He did however use a Wiggy for 240 V. though . ;-))

FredD