Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

(OT) protecting concrete from ice

Posts

(OT) protecting concrete from ice

#1

(OT) protecting concrete from ice

Grant in Iowa

>Here in Eastern Iowa, the weather man is forecasting freezing rain and ice tonight. I have a northwesterly facing concrete driveway that is a moderate hill.

I was brainstorming what I might be able to do in preparation for the impending ice. I was thinking that I might go out after all cars are in for the night and put a layer (maybe an inch?) of snow on the driveway before the storm hits. My thinking is that the snow will provide a release layer for clearing in the morning. The ground and concrete are below freezing, so it shouldn't melt and refreeze.

I have a Kubota compact utility tractor with a loader so spreading the snow would take me maybe 10 mins tops. It would be equally quick to remove the ice/ snow in the morning, assuming it works as planned.

So am I all wet? Sound like it might work to keep the ice from sticking to the concrete? We live in a rural suburb, so I have no sidewalks to worry about.

Interested in input. I dislike salt or other ice melters due to how hard they are on concrete... looking for an alternative.

Thoughts?

Re: (OT) protecting concrete from ice

#2

I'm thinking why bother....

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

>Forcast for your area is 37 and rain by Thursday. Whatever sticks tonight will probably be gone after tomorrow. Unless you really, really, really need to go somewhere tomorrow and the ice will keep you housebound, I don't think I'd go through the trouble. Then again, if it only takes 10 minutes, it's a good opportunity to have some winter fun on the tractor. Go for it.

Re: (OT) protecting concrete from ice

#3

Two words for you....

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>Ice Melter. You need Ice Melter or plain old rock salt. Put it on tomorrow after the ice stops. Putting snow on the drive could more than double your work if there is enough rain to totally saturate the snow you put on. Instead of a 1/4" layer you could have an inch or more to deal with.

Lee

Re: (OT) protecting concrete from ice

#4

Rain Doesn't Freeze Here-

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud,Fla

>

Re: (OT) protecting concrete from ice

#5

SILENCE from the tropics!

Grant in Iowa

>

Re: (OT) protecting concrete from ice

#6

I say go for it...

davhamm

>Should work. We often don't shovel the snow if they are calling for freezing rain to follow.

Re: (OT) protecting concrete from ice

#7

Yeah, I was going to say

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>that the best way to protect concrete from ice is to pour it in Florida.

Although it is subject to minor ice impact, when someone spills a mai tai...

Re: (OT) protecting concrete from ice

#8

I say try it too...

John in NM

>If its not much work, then go for it.

We have a lot of trouble with ice on the slab outside the front door at work. Between water soaking in, then freezing, ice being chipped off, and ice melting salt products, the slab is in bad shape after less than 20 years.

Re: (OT) protecting concrete from ice

#9

Siloxane

Joe Pack

>It won't keep anything from freezing on the driveway, but it sure does help prevent damage!

One of the worst enemies of concrete is moisture soaking into concrete from the top, then freezing. Most concrete "sealers" are a joke...not much more effective than plastic wrap laid on the concrete. Most are curing agents, not actual sealers. And so-called sealers only put on a coating that wears off in just a short time. Siloxane based sealers, though, are different in that they actually soak in and form a chemical bond within the top 1/4" or so of the concrete. Siloxane sealers do NOT wear away; they are chemically combined with the concrete. They then work like Gortex...liquid water is repelled, but water vapor can escape. By keeping most of the water out of the concrete, there is little or nothing to freeze. Spalling is kept to a minimum.

I used a Sherwin-Williams product on my driveway 10+ years ago. Any spalling evident was there before the application. I look regularly and can't see ANY spalling since applying the siloxane based sealant. 10+ years with no spalling is good enough for me!

This stuff is not cheap, but is much cheaper than replacing concrete. My only regret is not knowing about it 28 years ago. The only downsides are that it does darken the concrete slightly...maybe 10%, and it can be a bit slippery on very smooth concrete. Still, I can live with that.

Many brand names are out there. Just make sure it has a very high siloxane content. The carrier is not important since it evaporates anyhow. Easy to apply, either by spray or roller. I sprayed mine with an old garden sprayer, then backrolled.

Siloxane sealers are expensive compared with the bargain brands, but, as usual, you get what you pay for.

Re: (OT) protecting concrete from ice

#10

Go To The Ag Store

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>and get a 50lb bag of 46-0-0, pure urea. It will melt your ice without harming your concrete of the grass and plants within reach.

Snow, detergents, coatings or other "release" agents ain't gonna help now. [IMHO]

Re: (OT) protecting concrete from ice

#12

Re: Two words for you.... *LINK*

C.John Hebert

>Lee....Rock salt is the absolute worst thing to put on concrete!! it will cause scaling, and pit marks with to much use, especially over new stuff.


http://cjohnhebert.com/

Re: (OT) protecting concrete from ice

#13

Re: Or...

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Beer is far better. The alcohol content lowers the freezing point.

Re: (OT) protecting concrete from ice

#15

Buy two bags of 46-0-0 and .....

Barry Irby

>increase the local terror threat level to orange. Careful with the high nitrogen stuff.

Re: (OT) protecting concrete from ice

#16

I'm lazy.....

Basil

>...and would worry about the ice tomorrow...if it comes.

The way I read this is that you're worried about getting the cars up and down the driveway. I'd buy a couple of bags of sand and store them where they won't freeze into a lump. Then in the norning if needed, I'd spread some sand on the ice.

If you're just looking for an excuse to play with the tractor (or to justify the tractor purchase to the wife) put the sand in the bucket and spread it with the tractor.

Re: (OT) protecting concrete from ice

#17

Sawdust

Al Goldstein

>Here's a great use for all of that sawdust we generate in our workshops. A drain pipe that empties my backyard of rain water discharges onto the sidewalk in front of my house. It causes a large patch of slippery ice in the winter. I keep a barrel of sawdust in my garage and spread it on the ice when it appears. The sawdust adheres to the ice and makes it safe to walk on. Also, the sawdust color warns my neighbors of the ice patch. The only downside is that some sawdust sticks to the bottom of shoes and can be transported into the house.

Try it, you'll like it.

Re: (OT) protecting concrete from ice

#18

I agree - did the salt thing once, NEVER again.

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

>I used a salt spread de-icer a number of years ago when we had a bad ice storm. The concrete was at least 6 years cured so it wasn't new by any means. I even used the potassium chloride which was supposed to be friendlier to the grass and plants than normal sodium chloride. In the spring, I had little pock marks from spalling all over what previously was a perfect finish.

That was the last time I ever used salt on the driveway, and never will again.

Re: (OT) protecting concrete from ice

#19

Especially

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>if you drive a diesel.

BTW, this is a good place to use the ash from your fireplace (assuming you have one). Just be sure to clean the shoes before screwing up

"MY NICE CLEAN FLOOR!!!"

Re: (OT) protecting concrete from ice

#20

Better idea

Doug Ridley

>If you're retired like me just let'er freeze and then wait for it to thaw out.

Re: (OT) protecting concrete from ice

#21

Re: Siloxane

Don Orr

>Will this work on concrete about 5 years old ?

Re: (OT) protecting concrete from ice

#22

Yes, works on old concrete

Joe Pack

>The siloxane sealers will work on concrete of any age as long as the sealer can penetrate the concrete. If there is an existing sealer, it has to be removed in order to allow the siloxane sealer to penetrate. But if your concrete is old and has not had a sealer put on within the past few months, you should have no problem...the older sealer probably was washed off by the first few driving rains or scuffed off by your car tires. To be safe, test the concrete by pouring a little bit of water on the concrete. If the water beads up, there is something there that needs to be removed. Most likely, though, the water will soak right in. If it soaks in, there will be no problem with the new siloxane sealer.

Remember, my concrete was 10+ years old when I applied my sealer. I had previously applied Thompson's best product twice...before I learned I was wasting my time and money on a product that Consumer Reports found so lacking that they suspended a long term test of it just a few weeks into the test. Not just picking on Thompson; the same is true of a number of sealers...they are great until they wash/wear off, which takes very little time in actual use.

Re: (OT) protecting concrete from ice

#23

Read the labels carefully

Joe Pack

>Folks should always read de-icer labels carefully. Many of the pricey "won't harm your sidewalk" products actually have sodium chloride (salt, but they don't use that word) included in the mix. If the product is pure potassium chloride, there should be little, if any, problem with damage to concrete. How do you know the difference? $$$$$$$ The pure potassium chloride product is twice as much as the blended product.

Reading the ingredients label should let you know if there is any salt in the mix. If the word "sodium" shows up in any product, that is a fancy way of letting you know that you are about to cause a severe case of concrete acne.

Re: (OT) protecting concrete from ice

#24

Re: (OT) protecting concrete from ice

Richard McComas

>Don't you all have studded snow tires don't there?

Re: (OT) protecting concrete from ice

#25

Thanks Joe !

Don Orr

>I have 3 small patio-like pads that have never been sealed and I need to use salt occasionally on one of them. This sounds like a good way to protect it.