Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

DIY Motor Brake?

Posts

DIY Motor Brake?

#1

DIY Motor Brake?

John M in Mid Mich

>I love the automatic brake on my planer/jointer (Rojek) and on my miter saw (Makita). I think it is a huge safety advantage compared to the other machines in my shop. Sometime I make a cut on my table saw and have to stand bent over my piece in discomfort/terror while I wait patiently for the blade to spin down. I have a foot brake on my band saw, and this is better than no brake, but the brakes that engage when I turn off the power are such a pleasure. Can one add a motor brake to any motor? Are they electronic or mechanical (or both)? Anybody have instructions/plans/links/advice? The way my planer works, I'd guess we're talking some kind of solenoid actuation, but I'm not sure. I "did a google" and all I got was a DC circuit design. I'm thinking I'd love to put one on both the band saw and table saw if I knew how.

Thanks.

Re: DIY Motor Brake?

#2

Re: DIY Motor Brake?

Fred Davis

>John I think that if brakes were easy to make a feature of table saws , they would have them, but that is just what I think.

What I know, is if your experiencing "discomfort/terror" while using the table saw, you need to find out why and remedy it before you hurt yourself.

Woodworking should be a happy pastime.

FredD

Re: DIY Motor Brake?

#3

Re: DIY Motor Brake?

John M in Mid Mich

>Well, OK. But I asked about DIY brakes. I'm not so scared, just trying to embellish the point. I'd like to have a brake.

Re: DIY Motor Brake?

#4

Re: DIY Motor Brake?

Thomas S Stockton

>Actually brakes on table saws are fairly common, most european sliders have electronic motor brakes. I believe the unisaw has one as well.

You could also switch the motor to 3 phase and use a vfd with an electronic brake feature.

Tom

Re: DIY Motor Brake?

#5

Re: DIY Motor Brake?

Phil Joines Krum,Tx

>Of course if you stop it too fast the blade will come loose. :<)

Re: DIY Motor Brake?

#6

Re: DIY Motor Brake?

Fred Davis

>I have a Unisaw , new in 1974 and what it has for a brake certainly wouldn't fit most expectations.

FredD

Re: DIY Motor Brake?

#7

Re: DIY Motor Brake?

Bill Earl

>I have a Rojek jointer/planer too and I love the braking feature. The Rojek brake is a magnetically actuated mechanical brake built into the motor frame. That's why you have to have it plugged in order to rotate the cutterhead to change the blades (It took me some time to learn to trust those electrical interlocks!).

My SCMS also has a brake, but it is an electrical brake. Basically, when you release the switch, the spinning motor becomes a generator. A load is connected across the power terminals which causes the motor/generator to slow down. This is essentially the same principle used for regenerative braking in diesel-electric locomotives.

Re: DIY Motor Brake?

#8

Re: DIY Motor Brake?

Dan Donaldson

>Unfortunately, the brake for the scms will only work for universal (brush) type motors.

Re: DIY Motor Brake?

#9

Re: DIY Motor Brake?

del schisler

>i have a Makita chop saw When the brush's get wore on one side the other side get's pitted That side is what stop's the saw That would be what i would look at ?

Re: DIY Motor Brake?

#10

Motor brakes are a safety asset

Forrest Addy

>Motor brakes are a safety asset especially on a aable saw.

If you like cheap and simple there's everythng you need on a bucle caliper brake. You have to devise a mount to the arbor elevating casting and a foot pedel thingy for the hand brake but outide of that, it's all there no further away thant your wife's bicyle. The caliper grabs the blade and slows a little or a lot depending on how hard you step onn the pedel.

There days of millions of junk computer power supplies are a gold mine for the resourceful tinkerer. If you apply a DC voltage to the de-energized leads of a spinnng induction motor a current will be induced in the armature slowing it. If the DC supply has anough oomph the motor will decellerate repidly enough to loosen a table saw's arbor nut and you don't want that. You want to lmit the brakng current to some safe level you can live with.

If your saw has a motor starter (rubes, yokels, and people that are simply misinformed call them "magnetic switches") with a spare pair of NC contacts you are home free. You need a one shot timer, a DC power supply, a current limitng resistor, and maybe a relay to make a "dynamic brake" for your table saw. The timer limits the braking period so the motor doen't fry and the saw arbor will pn freely. The relay is connected to ensure the DC is applied only when the AC power is off. I've found about 3 seconds is about right as a brake time.

My saw motor is three phase powered from the single phase service via a VFD. A VFD already has a "motor to decel" function and a "DC injection" brake. These are programable operatng parameters that can be set to most any decel time you wish.

Re: DIY Motor Brake?

#11

How much current

Dan Donaldson

>How much current/voltage do you need to get it to work?

Re: DIY Motor Brake?

#12

Dan, the current

Forrest Addy

>Dan, the current required for desirable DC braking is at best a guess followed by experimentation and refinement. My guess is you would get roughly full motor torque braking if you applied full load Amps DC to the stator. How many volts would have to be calculated from winding DC resistance and the Amps you draw.

The retardng torque would depend on armature RPM and the DC magnetic flux of the stator. Braking torque would be max at full rated RPM and peter out as the motor slowed. If you wanted linear braking the RPM would have to be tracked and the DC braking current modulated accordingly. I'e played with this. Even at standstill the shaft of an induction motor with DC applied to the stator will strongly resist turning by hand.

I checked the winding resistance of a 3/4 HP induction motor and the found it was about 1 ohm. A 5 VDC 20 Amp power supply would be more than enough for this motor but I'd still want a reistor to trim the braking to a value that won't overcome the arbor nut. YMMV.

Re: DIY Motor Brake?

#13

Re: Motor brakes are a safety asset

John M in Mid Mich

>Now we're talkin'!

A real response! Yay! Unfortunately, you are still a bit above my head, even though I get some of it. Suppose the challenge was a 3hp cabinet saw motor. Suppose you were writing for one of the magazines. What would the complete writeup look like with the equivalent of a "cutting list", and all the diagrams and pictures and text to go with it. Not asking for much, am I? Ha! You know, that would make a great "Article" for the site... Anyway, I may try to get through all you've written and see where it gets me. Doesn't sound totally impossible as a DIY project. Thanks Forrest.

John

Re: DIY Motor Brake?

#14

Thanks

Dan Donaldson

>Was wondering what range of power supplies would be needed. Five volts at 20 amps is fairly heavy, but not too outrageous to find. May have to play with it one of these days.

Re: DIY Motor Brake?

#15

Noooo problem. Watch this space.

Forrest Addy

>Little piece of writing like that, the experimenting and verifcation, the photos and llutrations, the editing and revising. Piece of cake. Still there? Keep watching.

I recall an article on DC motor braking every now and then but it' been a while. Any electrical tinkerers feel ambitious?

Re: DIY Motor Brake?

#16

Re: Thanks

Bill Earl

>Many computer power supplies will source 5v @ 20A. You can probably find one free for the taking at the local recycling station.

The generator projects I have worked on used a relatively small external DC source to bootstrap the system, then transitioned to "self excited generator" mode where the field current was supplied by the generator itself.

I'm familiar with the control systems for these generators, but I'm not qualified to do the electrical engineering on one.