Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

A little design help....

Posts

A little design help....

#1

A little design help....

Brian in Sandusky, OH

>I'm going to be making a small cabinet.

I can't decide how thick to make an identical top and bottom member.

Please look through the next three photos, and let me know which you think is best.

Thanks in advance.

Re: A little design help....

#2

Photo #1

Brian in Sandusky, OH

>#1


img

Re: A little design help....

#3

Photo #2

Brian in Sandusky, OH

>#2


img

Re: A little design help....

#4

Photo #3

Brian in Sandusky, OH

>#3


img

Re: A little design help....

#5

Re: No question...#1

Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa

>

Re: A little design help....

#6

Dale Lenz

Re: Agree....

Dale Lenz

>In this case smaller, thinner, is better.

Re: A little design help....

#7

Re: A little design help....

Bill White

>Al's got it.

Bill

Re: A little design help....

#8

#1 I think

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I can't tell for sure from this photo but in any case the top and bottom need to be the same or the bottom needs to be slightly bigger than the top. With the side pieces so dainty the top and bottom needs to be similarly so.

Re: A little design help....

#9

Another vote for #1

David Hay @ Denver

>It may just be an optical illusion, but with both top and bottom the same, the top *still* looks a bit bigger than the bottom.

David

Re: A little design help....

#10

#1 with out a doubt

Frank Orfanello

>

Re: A little design help....

#11

Re: A little design help....

Barry Irby

>I agree, No 1, but you might try No 1 on top and No 2 on the bottom. Or thin down the one on the top slightly.

Re: A little design help....

#12

Understood, however....

Brian in Sandusky, OH

>I understand everyone's comments regarding how the top can be a little thinner than the bottom.

However, isn't this concept more applicable to a cabinet that will be viewed below eye-level?

This cabinet will be hung at eye's height.

It will hold a small liquor bottle, and two glasses.

So I'm not sure if the design principle regarding a thicker bottom member is applicable here.

Does this fact change your input?

Thanks everyone!

Re: A little design help....

#13

cabinet

Philip Duffy

>So why is the little drawer on the bottom? Seems to me it should be above the big one. My 2 cents. P.

Re: A little design help....

#14

Didn't change mine

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>For this sort of thing the "rails" can be equal or the top one a bit smaller. These are small parts and presumably this thing is held together with mortise and tenon such that it can be dry assembled. Make two parts, one larger and one the same size, assemble each configuration and see what you like best.

What is going to make this thing look good, or not, is the proportion of the side to top. If this proportion is off it won't matter whether the top is the same or smaller than the bottom. Hence, a little experimentation may be prudent. It is going to look sharp when you get these proportions right.

One thing I learned when visiting Krenov's college. The students there would likely have mocked up something like this out of scraps to get these proportions right.

Re: A little design help....

#15

Ellis Walentine

Here's an idea for you

Ellis Walentine

>I did a little work on your drawing, to lighten up the top rail a bit and make the lower one just slightly taller than the top one. See if this resonates at all...

Ellis


img

Re: A little design help....

#16

Re: Here's an idea for you

Brian in Sandusky, OH

>Thanks, Ellis. I like it.

And thanks to everyone for the help.

Re: A little design help....

#17

Ellis Walentine

For that matter...

Ellis Walentine

>Your instincts are good. My point was to make the bottom rails at least fractionally wider (taller) than the top rails, not ncecessarily just like my drawing, which was arbitrary. Somehow, my eye just wants to see that additional visual weight at the bottom of the composition.

Ellis

Re: A little design help....

#18

On the utility of mock-ups

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>This design is an example of something that could benefit from building a mock-up because very small changes in dimensions are going to have a large impact on visual appeal.

I never used to mock-up for anything. Thought that was for sissies. But when I visited College of Redwoods I saw most of the students making mock-ups to get proportions perfect. It was a mind altering experience. Not needed for boxy things that can be rendered well in a 2-D drawing, but shaped things may not be easy to get right from a 2-D drawing.

Re: A little design help....

#19

Re: On the utility of mock-ups

Brian in Sandusky, OH

>Agreed.

I used to do a drawings, and then miniature mock-ups.

With this one, I will do a full-scale mockup from MDF.