Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Exterior door screw rant

Posts

Exterior door screw rant

#1

Exterior door screw rant

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Yet again I just finish fixing an exterior door for someone. The door was not engaging its latch and I quickly diagnosed the problem. The screws were loose allowing it to sag. They were loose because the door factory installed the hinges with piddly 1" screws into a pine stile. Why door factories think a 3' door can be held securely over the ages with such a short screw into soft pine is beyond me. When I replace these inadequate screws it is with McFeeley hardened #10 screws at least 2 1/2" and up to 4" screws depending on what lies beneath.

It is little wonder that in a rash of recent church burglaries the thieves were able to gain entry through front doors with a small pry bar. (they got caught after 20+ jobs by an alert policeman on patrol).

Re: Exterior door screw rant

#2

Re: Exterior door screw rant

Fred Davis

>The Standard door hinge screw size is a #9, 7/8Th's inch long.

It's been that way far longer then I have been installing doors.

Prehung doors would be impossible to handle with a long screw sticking out the back side of the jamb.

As it is we often had to cut the protruding screw flush to have room for shimming the door.

A screw head bigger then # 9 can cause closing problems commonly called hinge bound in the Carpenter trade.

FredD

Re: Exterior door screw rant

#3

which makes them fine for transport

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>but if I were installing doors as a regular practice, I'd be replacing them, as Bill T. has had to do, with screws that reached the framing, after shimming behind the hinges.

My sympathies, Bill: you're not alone in needing to put in longer screws.

Re: Exterior door screw rant

#4

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

What I've seen.

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>I've painted many, many new exterior doors. Typically the hinges have 4 screws on each side of the barrel for exterior doors, versus 3 on each for interior doors. Usually, when I'm painting the door, I see that the hinges will have a couple hinge holes that are not even pre-drilled, nor screwed on the jamb side to allow for a few longer screws to be put in (often provided). The carpenters that do bother to install those missing screws often just stick a long (mismatched) drywall screw. For that very reason, I generally keep a few zinc-coated 3" screws on hand. People love it when their painter knows how to fix that door that never did work quite right.

I've also installed/replaced a few exterior and interior doors for people. I make sure the top two hinges have long screws through the jamb into the framing to "lock" it in place after I have it shimmed and working properly. Then I tell the customer to call me if they ever have problems with the door. No callbacks yet...

Jason

Re: Exterior door screw rant

#5

Re: Exterior door screw rant

John in NM

>I've seen quite a few doors installed with a 3" or 4" screw replacing one of those in the top hinge, but those are never the ones that I get asked to fix! All the screw really needs to do is hold the hinge leaf in the mortise, and if its a good tight fit the mortise will bear the weight. With the advent of those horrible round cornered hinges, precise mortises seem to have gone the way of the dodo and the hinge screws end up taking a lot of shearing force, pulling them out of the jamb. Not really surprising that I've never seen the long screw trick in an old house, though I'm sure it was done when needed.

Re: Exterior door screw rant

#6

Jason is right......

Barry Irby

>I have installed about a half a dozen exterior steel doors lately, at least two different brands. All of them came with one or two screws missing from the top and center hinge and a couple of longer screws to be installed in the holes. The manufacturers leave out the screw(s) closest to the stop. The other screws are too close to the face of the stud and the screw would likely go between the stud and the drywall and hold nothing. If they only send one screw for the top and middle screw, I usually replace the other "inner" screw for a total of four. The bottom hinge does not matter as much, because it is "in Compression".

On my Home Inspections I routinely check for the "jamb screws" in steel doors. (Exterior doors and the door to the garage). Often they are missing and I write it up. On new houses I try to make the builder do it for them.

The screws that Lowes and Home Depot sell for deck screws come in green and "cedar" brown. They must be No 9 screws and they work perfectly. The brown ones match the brass hinges pretty well. A couple of 2 1/2 or 3" deck screws will put the door back up. Driving them is a great use for an impact driver.

Re: Exterior door screw rant

#7

Re: Exterior door screw rant

Phil Joines Krum,Tx

>I think it's done now more for security against someone kicking the door in than to hold the hinge.

Re: Exterior door screw rant

#8

Re: Exterior door screw rant

Fred Davis

>John and Phil are both right in thinking that a long screw is not relevant to holding the door in place.

As John points out the mortise holds the weight of the door , not the screw.

Similarly with security issues , the Screw is there for reinforcement.

Steel entry doors are made by the Iron workers Union under a whole different concept then wood doors made by the Carpenters and Joiners Union.

For instance the Iron workers mortise is set at 5" and 10" top and bottom. Also if the the Entry door is fire rated wood and the Jamb is steel the same applies.

They also call out the hand of the door exactly opposite of the Wood Door manufacturers which probably dates far back in the development of steel doors purely as a work standard not related to anything that makes sense.

The Carpenters and Joiners Union sets the Mortise at 7" and 11" respectively for entirely different reasons.

Lastly doors are meant to "float " in the opening without any weight or stress transfer from the building to the door unit.

I have seen many a door jamb torqued out of straight by people inserting a long screw that will pull the Jamb toward the Trimmer , unless they were lucky enough to run though the shim before hitting the Trimmer

Same goes for wood sash windows.

Hanging of doors and windows is more a matter of skill and experienced finesse then applying brute force.

When you can hang a door so that placing a index finger against the top of the door holding it against the stop will not reveal any gap between the bottom of the door and the stop when you place your toe against it,then you can call yourself a door hanger.

FredD

FredD

Re: Exterior door screw rant

#9

Related: Doors were kicked in twice *LINK*

Rich Pearson in Mill Creek, WA

>in my town-home development last week. Both doors were the standard prehung exterior doors with "standard length" screws. The thieves made off with TV's, computers, jewelry etc.

After a bit of research I found the Strikemaster II Pro steel door jamb reinforcement system. I have bought and installed it on both exterior doors.

I also replaced all hinge screws with 2 1/2" screws as well. I was careful not to torque the jamb so the doors still operate smoothly.

I know I cannot prevent a determined thief from getting in but I can make it harder and noisier on his part. That should give the thief enough time to hear the sound of me jacking a round into my 12 guage !


Steel jamb reinforcement

Re: Exterior door screw rant

#10

Re: Related: Doors were kicked in twice

Carol Reed - home in Strawberry

>Thanks, Rich. I had renters in my house while I was in seminary. According to the neighbors they had epic fights. Both the front and the back door and the bedroom door had been kicked in. This will solve two out of three. The other I am going to glue and clamp, fill and repaint to repair. The bedroom isn't a security issue.

Re: Exterior door screw rant

#11

Both great ideas

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I got to the same place with home made additions. Wish I knew about this handy device when I was building.

On the second point there was a break in. The lady was on 911 reporting that someone was trying to get in her house. She reported she had her 12 ga and was going to make him "grave yard dead" if he came through the door. Next there was the sound of a chair breaking a window followed by a blast from the 12 ga. End of problem and presumably the mess was all outside where it could be hosed off. My kind of woman!

Re: Exterior door screw rant

#12

Actually Fred...

John in NM

>I meant to say that I felt a long screw in the top hinge does help hold the leaf in the mortise, I'm sorry I wasn't more clear.

As sloppy as prehung mortises have gotten, and as thin and soft as most jamb materials are, short screws can pull out after a few years, whereas a long screw into the framing holds the leaf tight in the mortise.

I would venture to guess that a properly hung door won't need the extra help, not having the added stresses from wracking or being hinge bound, or if it was a good day at the door factory and the hinges fit well. But I've often seen that long screw on doors that work perfectly - its just a little extra insurance against having to come back and do more work, which is very sensible in my opinion.

Re: Exterior door screw rant

#13

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

You touched on the problem.

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>While tight mortises certainly help, one of the biggest problems I see today is that very heavy doors get (pre-)hung on wholly inadequate jambs. When you've got a 100+ lb. 36" door hung on a softwood or particle board jamb, it's going to sag if there aren't long screws in the top two hinges. I don't care how well the carpenter hangs it, the problem is that the jamb will flex, allowing the door to sag. This is at its worst when the door is open only slightly, as the weight of the door is torquing on the thinnest dimension of the jamb.

Jason

Re: Exterior door screw rant

#14

Re: You touched on the problem.

Fred Davis

>Jason,

a manufacturers cost cutting measures are one thing and correctly hanging a door is entirely another.

In the first instance a Heavy entry door requires jambs that reflect this weight , so a competent Contractor and reasonable client will buy a door unit that has heavy four inch brass butts with bearings and square leaves, anything else leads to the various fixes being offered here in place of doing it right the first time.

FredD

Re: Exterior door screw rant

#15

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

There it is...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>...the mythical "reasonable client". ;^)

I also rarely see GCs who have much knowledge of what constitutes craftsmanship outside of whatever trade in which they themselves cut their teeth.

Jason

Re: Exterior door screw rant

#16

Now days the mortises are gone

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Many (all?) exterior metal clad or fiberglass doors don't have mortises. The hinges screw right to the door edge. So forget a mortise supporting anything. It's all on the piddly screws that are supplied. It was these piddly screws that I just replaced because they had worked loose.

In the case of the interior doors which I installed the hinge sits in a snug mortise in a hardwood jam and indeed the mortise supports the door weight.

Re: Exterior door screw rant

#17

Good grief!

John in NM

>I'm astounded its gotten that bad! Anything to save 10 cents I guess, and fixing the mess is somebody else's problem. Does the lack of a mortise at least make it easier to come in and install a proper hinge?

At one point around 2002 I figured a decent craftsman could make a good living fixing up the second half of badly botched installations - if it didn't drive him nuts! I do hope the bad economy is at least weeding out some of the true hacksters.

Re: Exterior door screw rant

#18

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Not really...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>...on weeding out the hacksters. They have an unfortunate advantage in that they're used to working for much, much less than a true professional. We're back to that problem of what happens when you have unsustainable growth in the new construction housing industry--a severe lack of skilled workers.

Jason

Re: Exterior door screw rant

#19

Re: Both great ideas

Carol Reed - home in Strawberry

>Time to dust off my 12 gauge? I hope I live in a neighborhood where that is not necessary, but I own one just the same. Along with a pistol and I know how to use both. Used to live in a much more populous place! There a single lady was a fool to not avail herself of some equipment and knowledge.

Re: Exterior door screw rant

#20

Re: There it is...

Fred Davis

>Ahhh so many and so little time .

Jason in a effort to describe that "Mythical client" here is what I meant and I am sure you know also.

Since I was a Journeyman Carpenter long before I was a General Contractor, and advising and hanging extremely expensive Entry doors here are a few things I advised the client to look for and if he didn't opt for the advice I recommended that he look elsewhere for a Contractor.

Most of the Entry doors I have hung were hardwood, especially Oak and if the rails and stiles were not one piece members I advised against the door choice.

For instance there was or still is a door company in Utah that shipped to California door shops ,doors that had two piece laminated stiles and rails which meant that the glue line was directly under two out of every four screws in the hinge leaf.

I insisted on blind stops milled into matching hardwood jambs.

This eliminates the too thin Jambs you see so much now.

Solid brass 4 inch ball bearing square leaf hinges.

Quality entry and deadbolt locks, not subdivision sheetmetal ones

This generally meant Baldwin box mortise locks.

Brass kick plates were a option , but a good idea.

Naturally we advised matching casing.

When you consider that some of the doors from International door company in San Diego and Feather River door in Oroville , Cal, ranged from six to twenty thousand and up depending on how wide the entire entry was and how much artistic glass was incorporated, the price of goodlocks was worth it.

We installed a 16 foot wide double entry in a twelve foot high arched Cherry jamb that was $38,000.00 delivered to BlackHawk,Ca. job site in 1988.

So all told I have done a few doors in forty plus years and I believe that many here would be pleased with McKinney hinges (commonly called Okie hinges in the trade) since they do not require any mortise , only a screwdriver.

Any housewife would have no trouble in hanging a door with these. ;-))

FredD

Re: Exterior door screw rant

#21

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: There it is...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>Fred,

That's probably the difference in markets. I could probably count on my two hands the number of houses that have that quality of door installed in this county. And, there are probably only a few dozen more that would deserve that grade of entry system, but were not built with such. A few years ago, the average new home in this county was probably no more than $150K, with most falling under $250K, and typical costs are in the $80-90/s.f. range (tract home garbage is closer to $60-70/s.f., fully custom homes go $100+/s.f.)

Jason

Re: Exterior door screw rant

#22

Re: Not really...

Phil Joines Krum,Tx

>A skilled worker can't get a job with most builders here. It's mostly illegal day labor getting minimum wage or less.

Re: Exterior door screw rant

#24

Re: There it is...

Fred Davis

>Jason, ,

cost really doesn't enter the picture , I am sure your less expensive material and labor jobs of painting get just as much effort , as if you were doing the Governor's Mansion.

That was the point of this thread for me, done right the first time eliminates nearly every gripe found in construction or any other endeavor.

Since I am not wealthy and I liked the look , in our home when I pushed the front out 16 feet , I had two VG DF 15 lite French doors shipped from a California door shop I had done business with for years and I made the jamb for one fixed and one operator door in a double entry orientation and painted it white 12 years ago.

Still looks like I recently installed it , though I had to replace a fairly expensive Schlage lock and dead bolt combo.

last thought I have on this thread.

FredD