Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Help! Outrageous Fisheye Problem

Posts

Help! Outrageous Fisheye Problem

#1

Help! Outrageous Fisheye Problem

Steve in East Tennessee

>I just sprayed lacquer on some cabinet fronts I am refinishing. Most turned out just beautiful, but a couple fisheyed like I had never before seen. As I was applying the spray, you could see the lacquer almost bead up like water on a freshly-waxed car. This only happened on a couple of pieces, and they all were prepared the same way.

The original finish is (most likely) poly, and I scuffed all of it with 0000 steel wool. I hand-sanded flat areas with 600-grit wet/dry paper lubricated with mineral spirits. Areas with damage I sanded down to bare wood, and applied a water-based dye, feathering it in to match the original tint. This worked great.

Before applying the lacquer, I wiped everything down with a mineral-spirits soaked rag, and left to dry overnight.

The good ones got a second coat, and rubbed out with rottenstone to a beautiful finish. The oddball ones I've had to re-level, re-tint the areas I sanded through, and generally start all over.

Does this sound like perhaps the fisheyed pieces were somehow contaminated before applying the lacquer? Should I consider adding a washcoat of shellac before re-applying the lacquer? I've never seen lacquer bead up like this did. I knew there was a huge problem the moment the finish hit the wood, so I've got the project idled until I can figure out what went wrong.

I've heard of steel wool having rust-inhibitors or remnants of lubricant from the wool-making process. Could I have gotten some wool that transferred something incompatible with lacquer to the surface of the panels?

Re: Help! Outrageous Fisheye Problem

#2

Re: Help! Outrageous Fisheye Problem

e

>most often the problem with lacquer is temp and humidity. fisheye usually comes from drying too quickly before the lacquer can settle evenly.

Re: Help! Outrageous Fisheye Problem

#3

Dale Lenz

Re: Try the wash-coat with Seal Coat, Good luck

Dale Lenz

>

Re: Help! Outrageous Fisheye Problem

#4

Re: Help! Outrageous Fisheye Problem

Steve in East Tennessee

>IIt's been cooler in the shop, but the humidity is controlled. I have not had blush problems before, which typically arise from excess humidity. This appeared to be more of an adhesion problem. But I may try adding a little retarder to see if that helps.

I'm just flummoxed why on some pieces the lacquer laid down perfectly, and some were total failures.

Re: Help! Outrageous Fisheye Problem

#5

Re: Help! Outrageous Fisheye Problem

Kirk (KC) Constable

>I've had a couple occasions of unexplained fisheye... and never did figure out what the problem(s) were. It's frustrating, for sure.

Re: Help! Outrageous Fisheye Problem

#6

Jesper, Denmark

Re: One possible reason......

Jesper, Denmark

>Is that the pieces amy have been waxed before with a silicone containing wax. Mineral spirit does not remove the silicone, it only dissolves the wax and smears it around.

You might try with acetone or MEK.

Re: Help! Outrageous Fisheye Problem

#7

Ellis Walentine

Silicon

Ellis Walentine

>I agree with Jesper that the most likely contaminant is silicon in some form, or grease that had splattered on the door(s) and stuck in the old finish. But there are a couple other things you mentioned that could have contributed. First, mineral spirits is oily in itself. If a thinner is needed prior to a lacquer top coat, I usually use lacquer thinner, which also dissolves waxes and oils nicely. The caveat here is that if the original finish is lacquer, the thinner can soften or remove it.

The other thing has to do with your abrasive routine. Under a film finish like lacquer, there's no need to sand any finer than about 220 grit, as the finish levels and fills the surface. And, steel wool is best left for applying a final satin sheen and luster to a finish that is too glossy. I don't know about today, but it used to be that Elephant brand steel wool was the go-to brand because if didn't have any oil in it. If you used some generic brand, that could have been the source of the contamination.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Help! Outrageous Fisheye Problem

#8

Re: Help! Outrageous Fisheye Problem

Frank on Chestnut Hill

>Been there done that ..... Here is my outrageous solution. Take a good quality rag and wipe it down. Don't try to remove everything , just get it to reflect somewhat smooth. Let it dry and hit it lightly with 400 grit hand sanding w/ the grain. Apply you next coat. The wiped off finish acts as a wash coat and allows the next coat to flow out. I suspect the mineral spirits had not completely evaporated.

I know it sounds crazy, found the method out of complete frustration!!!

FFG

Re: Help! Outrageous Fisheye Problem

#9

Re: Fisheye Problem

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Steve,

You've made a good list of the Usual Suspects. Given your description, if I was a bettin' man, I'd be most likely to put the money on the wool. I NEVER use steel (or any metal) wool to abrade wood; it leaves too much (oil and metal fibers) behind.

I'm assuming you're using solvent lacquer. If, however, you're working waterborne like Target/Emtec, you can add the sandpaper and MS to the Rogues' Gallery.

To confirm your self-suggestion, "Shellac sticks to everything and everything sticks to shellac" (as long as it's dewaxed). If your contaminant is silicon, it might have been there before you started your refinishing; household cleaners and polishes are full of the stuff to make them flow better. Once on the surface, silicon is almost impossible to remove other than by running the wood through a planer. The only way I have found to effectively deal with it is to seal it under a coat of shellac.

m

Re: Help! Outrageous Fisheye Problem

#10

Re: Silicon

Steve in East Tennessee

>I think the silicone theory is the problem. These cabinets have been dusted/waxed with Pledge, Endust, the whole gamut of bad actors during their lifespan. Yes, I am using solvent-based lacquer.

I'll try the lacquer thinner wipe down, and probably apply a shellac washcoat for good measure. Heck, I use it on everything else. I'm not sure why I didn't washcoat these before I applied the finish.

And Ellis, you caught a typo. I used 220 for initial sanding. I used the 600 to knock down any peaks before hand-rubbing.

I'll also leave the wool locked up and only use it to flatten finishes in the future.

Thanks, everyone for all the advice. I'll let you know how the rest turn out.

Re: Help! Outrageous Fisheye Problem

#11

Re: Fisheye Problem

Bill White

>Don't have a brand name, but you can buy a "fish eye eliminator" that will stop the problem. Call your lacquer supplier.

Bill