Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

OT- Electric Panels

Posts

OT- Electric Panels

#1

OT- Electric Panels

Larry shapiro, Fairfax, VA

>This isn't exactly wood working but I want to run some circuits in my new house for my small wood shop but I just used the last breaker slot during my remodeling. Can anyone make me smart on what criteria I would ned to understand to know if I can upgrade my electric panel. There is already a panel and sub-panel. Am I limited by the wire coming into the house or am i limited by the panel itself and if I could upgrade to a larger panel the wire from the pole would be fine.. Hopefully someone will understadn my question :-)

Thanks in advance

Larry

Re: OT- Electric Panels

#2

Re: OT- Electric Panels

Lewis Dodd

>Well, not a simple answer!! I am not an electrician but have done pretty extensive wiring. A new panel would or could be great. Most homes have 200 amp lead in service from the utility company. This is the major limiting factor for new panels and new loads imposed upon the existing system. The utility company could of course give you a larger amperage but you would require a new meter loop or a complete higher service entrance panel. The main breaker most likly is the size of your system and the breaker box is rated for the capacity of the main (which is in the same box) or is labeled 100amp, 150 amp or 200 amp. Possible that you have a 200 amp box with a 150 amp main, not likely tho.

I am going to cautiously suggest to you that some of that 200 amps with all the breaker slots filled are never under load all at the same time. There exists breakers that are"piggybacked" that can give you new circuits where there are no more "slots" in your existing panel. You would want to do this on circuits that would not or most likely have no "load" on them when you are in your shop. A 230 volt circuit is nothing more than picking up both sides of the panel, one side being 115 volts and the other also 115 volts.

I suggest a visit from a competent electrician and follow his advice on your specific conditions. Hope this didn't muddy the water too much.

Lewis

Re: OT- Electric Panels

#3

JL

Re: OT- Electric Panels

JL

>As you live in Fairfax, VA - chances are you have a pretty maxed out panel.

As Lewis suggested, have an electrician come out. Don't get a "popular" one like "Mr. Sparky" or whatever. Find one that will come out, evaluate your system and give you a quote.

Chances are you have a 200 amp service, depending on the age of your house. You may have to switch out panels or get a service upgrade. If you are "maxed" out and already have a subpanel, these will probably be the better alternatives.

The smaller "mini breakers" make me nervous. They are a way to cram more lines in a panel - but I feel uncomfortable with them.

Re: OT- Electric Panels

#4

Re: OT- Electric Panels

Randy Johnson

>I will have to differ with the first two posters in saying that, depending on when your house was built and how many square feet it has, you probably don�t have a 200 amp panel. In this neck of the woods, single story homes built before the mid to late sixties all originally had 125amp or less. Older homes, even two story ones, might have only 60 amp panels. The worst I ever saw was a house with four bedrooms, living room, dining room, kitchen, breakfast room, bathroom, and � basement on a single (110 only) 20 amp fuse.

Since you say there is already a sub panel, I am guessing the main is 100 or 125 and someone in the past was trying to expand the system without actually upgrading the service. I have had people get really mad at me when I refused to add one more thing to a service, but there comes a time when you have to upgrade.

Call a contractor. Better yet, call three or four contractors. Most give free estimates. Once again, speaking from personal experience, contractors exist that will try to sell you the Brooklyn Bridge so to speak. I have looked at jobs that really required no upgrade (multiple empty spots in an under loaded panel) where the homeowner was told they needed a service upgrade..

Addy Protocol. Not a licensed electrician (Indiana doesn�t require or even offer it) but one with over thirty-five years of experience in residential, commercial, and agricultural wiring.

Re: OT- Electric Panels

#5

Re: OT- Electric Panels

Pete in Holland, MI

>My house was built in the early 70's with a 100amp panel. I put a sub panel along side years ago. When we originally moved in, the house had an electric range & dryer. Both have been changed out for gas. Thus, the planned power for the house has been reduced, and I am using that service elsewhere, such as in my shop & garage.

Yes, there are codes, and I understand why, but that is also why there are breakers in the system. If you've never tripped your main, then you have not approached the maximum draw for the house. My outlook is that I will most likely never have every circut in the house loaded to the max, thus, can cheat a little here & there.

Your house. Your decisions.

Re: OT- Electric Panels

#6

Re: OT- Electric Panels

Don Evans

>It's interesting to me that with all the assumptions here, NO ONE asked what is the ampere rating on your MAIN breaker?

Being familiar slightly with Fairfax if I had to guess I'd say you probably have a newer home, but then again you could be outside the town and in a 100 year old house former farm house, so what is it?

Look in your main panel and if a modern box it should have a main breaker at the very top and see what the number is on the trip handle of that largest breaker. If it is 200 then you have a 200 amp service box,

Even with this information you're still at the junction of what to do, but if you have a 200 amper then you have a good chance that the addition of another panel is a good posibility without huge expense and you should then persue getting an electrician to give you some options to chose from.

If you find a lesser breaker that doesn't mean stop and forget it it simply means that you may be looking at replacing the main panel and possible wiring to house etc but at least you are armed with info at that point to know the electrician isn't trying to rip you.

Also back to the main panel, there should be an info sheet glued inside the cover. Sometime they are difficult to read and understand but look it over and see if you can determine anything from it.

In a newer home it is also very possible that you have a box outside the house with nothing in it but the main breaker and it is feeding a panel inside the house with all individual breakers in it. In that case it's much easier, check the breaker outside and you will know what the feed coming to the house is based on it's marked amperage.

Don

Re: OT- Electric Panels

#7

Re: OT- Electric Panels

riley140

>All thanks for your response, I will have an electrician review my situation and get advice from a pro as suggested.

Thanks,

Larry

Re: OT- Electric Panels

#8

Re: OT- Electric Panels

Don Evans

>Lewis:

One caution:

A panel isn't constructed with one leg of 115 on one side of the panel and other leg on the other side of the panel.

The panel is constructed with every other breaker on one leg and the other breakers on the other leg.

Simply put: count the left side from top to bottom and the right side from top to bottom, all odd numbered breakers are on same leg and all even numbered breakers are on the other leg.

This is why 240 volt one breaker is in the slot just above the other breaker one on odd number slot and other one on even number slot.

This very fact is why these slim breakers can be a big problem if one doesn't understand this. For 240 volt you cannot have both breakers on the same leg.

I speak only of the USA.... don't know how the rest of the world is wired!

Don

Re: OT- Electric Panels

#9

Re: OT- Electric Panels

Lewis Dodd

>A possibility? Call the utility company, they work for you and get one of their guys to come out and tell you what you have, always remember tho, you pretty much get what you pay for.

Lewis

Re: OT- Electric Panels

#10

Re: OT- Electric Panels

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>There is already a panel and sub-panel. Am I limited by the wire coming into the house or am i limited by the panel itself and if I could upgrade to a larger panel the wire from the pole would be fine.. Hopefully someone will understadn my question :-)

(1) The size of the entrance wire (and the meter base/meter) determines the maximum "main breaker" you can have in your entrance. To increase the main breaker capacity you must have the proper size entrance wire, conduit and meter base/meter. However, you can add sub-panels to your main - 99+% of homes never approach the capacity of the main panel (if it is 200 amp or even 100 amp unless you use electric heating). The limiting factor is normally the number of breakers you can install. You may find the simplest solution is to remove some of the existing breakers in either your main or sub-panel and replace them with "dual breakers" - these are breakers that fit into one slot and have 2 breakers/wire connections. These allow you to add one circuit for every one you install. Even if you want to add a 240V breaker you can install 2 dual breakers and free up the space to install one 240 breaker. I was a manufacturing Engineer for about 40 years and did contracting work on the side including a great deal of electrical entrance installation and other wiring. I really don't see any downside to using the dual breakers. REMEMBER you must not replace an existing breaker with one of a larger capacity without making sure all wiring in that circuit is large enough to legally carry the load. As this normally cannot be checked (some of the wiring is in walls etc.), it is proper to only replace two 15 amp breakers with a dual 15 amp or two 20 amp with a dual 20 amp etc. The other option of installing an additional sub-panel would require you either remove two 120 or one 240 Volt breaker from your main and install a breaker to feed the sub-panel - the removed circuits can then be installed in the new sub-panel or connected to dual breakers.

Re: OT- Electric Panels

#11

Re: OT- Electric Panels

Jerry Nicholson

>My master breaker is composed of four 100 amp breakers rather than two 200 amp breakers. The people we bought the house from in 2000 were required to upgrade from 100 amp to 200 amp service (new wires from the pole, new weather hood, new breaker panel) before the sale could be closed.

Jerry

Re: OT- Electric Panels

#12

Re: OT- Electric Panels

Lewis Dodd

>Wow, if you use all that, your electrical bill must be "jolting"

lewis

Re: OT- Electric Panels

#13

Re: OT- Electric Panels

riley140

>Larry,

Thank you for directly addressing my question, that was very helpful.

Larry S.

Re: OT- Electric Panels

#14

Re: OT- Electric Panels

riley140

>Hi Don,

The house was built in 1969 and the "Main" breaker is one that is 60 amp I think, I will double check tonight.

Thanks for your info.

Larry

Re: OT- Electric Panels

#15

Re: OT- Electric Panels

Fred Davis

>Larry . I was a Building Contractor in California for many years and I can tell you two things to avoid.

I. If you Mickey Mouse a amateur wiring job based on faulty advice it will most likely come back to bite you , for instance in a house fire , it will give the Home Owners insurance a legal loophole to deny any claims.. Or if you sell your home , then you will have to fix the problem at a far more costly rate (after the fact Electrical permits can be expensive) plus the Inspector will give your home a far greater scrutiny for violations.

2. This forum is not a place for Electrical advice however well meaning except for the one or two Electricians who drop in and do it for a living.

I would in your case get a small Electrical contractor for a quote or a Master Electrician who does a occasional side job and is licensed to pull permits.

Do not avoid the permitting stage , it is required in any area that I am familiar with. Also a visit from your local friendly Inspector will give you the mechanics they require.

FredD

Re: OT- Electric Panels

#16

Re: OT- Electric Panels

Barry Irby

>Generally I have to agree with Fred on this. There are far too many variables for any of us to answer your questions.

As Fred points out, the vast majority of us are not electricians. Most of us are rank amateurs at electrical stuff and may be well intentioned, but that doesn't help you much.

Different states and jurisdictions have different standards about permits and who may do the work.

So, the smart move is to get a qualified local electrical contractor to give you a bid on the work. Get several.

You are in Fairfax. I am south of Richmond, VA. I'm taking a wild guess here but generally in VA you need a permit from the local building code office. You are permitted to do the work yourself, but will have to pass inspection. Though many of us think we don't need no stinking permit, its not a good idea to do this type work without the "benefit" of local inspection.

There are at least three things that determine the size of your main panel. The size of the incoming wire, the size of the main breaker, and the size of the box or "can". They are inter-related. One way to look at it is that the main breaker protects the wire that feeds power to the panel. (It does not allow the system to pull more power than the wire can safely deliver.) The individual breakers protect the wires that feed from them to the devices. They do not allow the devices to draw more power than the wire can safely deliver. The size of the can is important because the wires tend to get hot or at least warm. Air space inside the panel allows the wires to dissipate the heat. This is why its not a good idea to jamb in lots of extra half sized or mini breakers and add lots of circuits. All the extra wires make it more difficult for the system to dissipate heat.

You will notice that no matter what your panel size is or what the main breaker is, the individual breakers add up to far more amps than the main. This is based on non-concurrent use and the fact that most circuits are seldom loaded to capacity. An example of non-concurrent use would be that you might have electric heat and air conditioning. You never run both at the same time (I hope).

You may be connected to VA Power. They have a policy that they will upgrade/enlarge your service at no cost to you. That is, they won't charge you for what they do, but you have to pay for your part of it. You provide the new larger panel(s) and the wire to the weather head. They will give you the new larger meter and meter base, but you or your electrician will have to install them and get them inspected. The power company does their part to avoid discouraging people from upgrading and continuing to use dangerous under sized services.

Your shop can run comfortably on a fairly small amount of current. In a one man shop you seldom run more than two tools at once. I run my DC and Planer or DC and TS and the lights, but seldom more than that. Non-concurrent use. I have been known to trip a breaker if I turn everything on at once.

We have not even discussed three wire vs. four wire panels and a dozen other things.

Re: OT- Electric Panels

#17

Re: OT- Electric Panels

Jay

>Larry, you are limited by the size of the wire from the pole to your mast head and the size of the wire from the mast to your main breaker. In one of your posts I saw that you think your main is a 60A. If that is the case you are not a candidate for more circuits. Call a contractor out for an estimate on upgrading to a 200A service. This will involve a new riser, meter socket, service wire, and panel with 200A main. These usually will accomadate about 40 circuits. Then you eliminate your sub panel, put everything into one box, properly distribute the existing circuits, pull another circuit to the kitchen (you know you need one more there :) everyone does), and you will never have to upgrade in this house again. By the way, if it is not a 2" conduit for the riser it is not 200A. The utility company's drop may or may not be large enough. They often ran triplex big enough for 200 even though the builders skimped and installed smaller services to cut costs. Electrician for work, woodworker for fun.

Good Luck,

Jay

Re: OT- Electric Panels

#18

Re: OT- Electric Panels

Jerry Nicholson

>No unusual amount of power available. Two 100 amp breakers on each leg of the 240 volt input = 200 amp service. The four breakers are ganged together. The only reason I can see for having two 100 amp breakers on each leg rather than one 200 amp breaker is that the bus bars in the breaker box can be smaller.

Some prior owner of the house had done some creative things like scabbing #14 wires onto 40 amp breakers and leaving wire splices out in the open in the attic. This led to a big loud "UH-OH" from my inspector and considerable expense to the folks we bought the house from.

Jerry

Re: OT- Electric Panels

#19

Re: OT- Electric Panels

Howard Norman

>There are places in the US where a permit is not required to upgrade or install new electrical service. Yavapai County in Arizona was one of those places until a two or three years ago for those of us who live in the "rural" part of the county. The county has now gone to the other extreme where permits are required for everything and the inspectors are a bunch of idiots.

I am not as enamored with licensed electricians as you are Fred. I have seen some of them who where complete idiots. In fact when I started building this place I used one to do a limited amount of wiring for me. I quickly found out that he was doing things that were according to code acceptable but they were not acceptable according to the way I wanted things done so I fired him and did the rest of the electrical work myself. No regrets ten years later.

The building trades have some good craftsmen and they have some terrible craftsmen also. The same applies to those with contractors licenses.

Re: OT- Electric Panels

#20

Re: OT- Electric Panels

Fred Davis

>"I quickly found out that he was doing things that were according to code acceptable but they were not acceptable according to the way I wanted things done so I fired him "

I don't know about "enamored" Howard, but speaking as a successful contractor I am much fonder of people who know their job and do it in a workman like manner in spite of clients personal short comings.

Why would you think the Electrician you hired would forgo the code and do it your way and run the risk of criticism by the Building Inspector who you apparently feel is a idiot.

People's safety and properties security rest on the Electrician doing his job and the Inspector certifying that it passes code.

Anything less is hazardous as any Fire Marshall , Insurence adjuster, Building Official and Police Officer can tell you.

If you have a found a place where you can exist without any regulation, congradulations.

FredD

Re: OT- Electric Panels

#21

Re: OT- Electric Panels

Howard Norman

>It was not a matter of my methods not meeting code, they do, his methods meet code but they didn't meet my standards which are higher than code. At the time of my encounter with this electrician no building inspections were required for me.

A friend of mine who built here in the same time frame as I hired an independent inspector because he didn't trust the tradesmen. His independent inspector found numerous substandard procedures by tradesmen. BTW, my friend is a registered civil engineer in five states but he couldn't be around during much of the construction of his home.

My experience has just been that hiring licensed contractors doesn't mean that you are necessarily going to get good quality work done. You having been a contractor means you have some bias in the matter.

Re: OT- Electric Panels

#22

Re: OT- Electric Panels

riley140

>Thanks Jay.

Maybe first thing I should do is call Dominion Power and ask them what is running to my house.

Larry

Re: OT- Electric Panels

#23

Re: OT- Electric Panels

Jerry Nicholson

>When the service was upgraded at our house, including a new weatherhood on a conduit that went up through the roof, the electrician just laid the flashing for the conduit on the shakes and screwed it down. I discovered it when I saw rainwater coming down the conduit and splashing on top of the meter box! I have always hoped that the electrician knew a whole lot more about electricity than he did water! I later had the service put underground and watched every move my electrical contractor made. In fact any time I have a contractor doing something I monitor the activity so closely that I am probably in the way much of the time. And I have pointed out errors and omissions several times.

Jerry

Re: OT- Electric Panels

#24

Re: OT- Electric Panels

Howard Norman

>>In fact any time I have a contractor doing something I monitor the activity so closely that I am probably in the way much of the time. And I have pointed out errors and omissions several times.<

The errors and omissions that you note are not a surprise to me. I have seen the same thing many times myself. As I noted in a message to Fred Davis hiring a licensed contractor does not guarantee quality work.

The other thing that annoys me is the amount of thefts that apparently occur with installers and tradesmen at your home. I have had two incidents this year alone where there is not other likely option and the local sheriff's office agrees. One of the incidents was a weapon stolen and the other one was an expensive electrical test instrument.