Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

December 7,1941- A day that will live in infamy-

Posts

December 7,1941- A day that will live in infamy-

#1

December 7,1941- A day that will live in infamy-

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud,Fla

>68 years ago today

Re: December 7,1941- A day that will live in infamy-

#2

Re: December 7,1941- A day that will live in infam

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Evening Ken,

Dec 7 is also my #1 daughter's 40th birthday. She redeemed the day for my family, but somehow isn't very keen on being 40. I can't understand her on that. I'd beel real keen on being 40. :<)

George

Re: December 7,1941- A day that will live in infamy-

#3

Dale Lenz

Re: December 7,1941- A day that will live in infam

Dale Lenz

>Thanks, Ken, Looked on CNN this evening at 6:45 PM and did not see a thing about Pearl Harbor, sent them a note. Just discovered Fox, they had an article about it. Mmmm...might switch to Fox for my computer news.

Moved in to our current home, 17 yrs. ago today.

Re: December 7,1941- A day that will live in infamy-

#4

Re: December 7,1941- A day that will live in infam

Fred Davis

>While your at it , get a subscription to the National Enquirer and Fate magazine just to touch all bases. ;-))

FredD

Re: December 7,1941- A day that will live in infamy-

#5

Re: December 7,1941- A day that will live in infam

Brian Anderson

>History international is having a show on the Arizona as part of the Hero Ship series.

This day is a day to remember the fallen in Hawaii.

But what bugs me is that current types are all comparing 9/11 to the Pearl Harbor attack. Two different things.

The Pearl Harbor attack was actually planned not to be a sneak attack.

But the Japanese ambassador to the US couldn't type and took a long time to type the declaration of war. It was delivered almost 2 hours late. That made it a sneak attack. The lack of preparedness by the US military was caused by the assumptions of the US military leaders that this was going to be a war fought like WW I. And that it would start in the Philipines.

My 2 cents worth.

Brian Anderson (amateur historian)

Re: December 7,1941- A day that will live in infamy-

#6

Jesper, Denmark

Re:History is a wonderfull thing........

Jesper, Denmark

>There are lots of ignificant events, which changed the World order - in whichever World scale you happen to think in. Wrongs like Pearl Harbor and 9/11 are remembered and referred to for decades. Reviled, condemned and n some ways celebrated.

It seems to me that there is an aspect of these events which are - if not totally ignored - then cetrtainly not a major part of the discussion: Now we had the horrible event, then what do we do to learn from it and change, so that it hopefully does not repeat itself?

The immediate reactions to Pearl Harbor were in a large measure appropriate and effective, seen in the 20/20 hindsight. They were not all appropriate, such as the interment of Japanese Americans in California.

One of the major results of the WW2 aftermath has led to the current World order of much freeer(sp?) movement of people and ideas across national boundaries Worldwide. This is a good thing and a major stabilizing factor for the world Peace. In a way, you could argue that "We" created the beginning of Globalization with things like the Marshall pan after WW2.

Since "we" creaed this, we have to live in the system we created. It is OK to remember the significant events, but our focus ought to be on the future and how to make that better.

On my World scale, in the 1940's that bad guys were German and Japanese, etc.. Yet today, most of my work is split between Japan, Germany, Italy and the USA. I can tell you that except for some local cultural differences, all the different people are very much the same. They want to be able to work, have a safe home and enough to eat. You can focus on the past or the differences and never get close to the real people - or you can concentrate on the basic nature of people in general and enjoy the fascinating diversity of people all over the World.

Open trade and communication is the only hope for our future - or history will repeat itself.

I'll get off the soapbox now.

Re: December 7,1941- A day that will live in infamy-

#7

Re: December 7,1941- A day that will live in infam

Jerry Nicholson

>Dec 7th is my second grandaughter's 18th birthday - born on the 50th anniversary of Pearl Harbor. I tried to get her folks to name her Pearl but they declined.

Jerry

Re: December 7,1941- A day that will live in infamy-

#8

Re: December 7,1941- A day that will live in infam

Forrest Addy

>CNN covered Pearl Harbor several times during the day. I didn't pay much atention but I seem to recall they interviewed a veteran and had a few clips Rooevelt peakng, the B/W footage, etc. No CNN isn't out to distroy America.

Re: December 7,1941- A day that will live in infamy-

#9

Dale Lenz

Re: Talking about CNN.com

Dale Lenz

>During my work day, have very little time for TV. Save it until after 10 and watch a little History and Discovery channels.

Re: December 7,1941- A day that will live in infamy-

#10

Dale Lenz

Excellent point, Jasper, thanks.

Dale Lenz

>

Re: December 7,1941- A day that will live in infamy-

#11

Fully Agree.......

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>

Re: December 7,1941- A day that will live in infamy-

#12

Re: Fully Agree.......

Fred Davis

>Likewise George,

one addition I would make to Jasper comments which are timely, concerning History, it is wise to remember that it is written by the winners.

FredD

Re: December 7,1941- A day that will live in infamy-

#13

But wait for the revisionists

Brian Anderson

>The problem with some views of WW II is that once the war has begun to fade from current memory the authors of books can twist the truth a bit to suit their own agenda.

Witness the book by Misuo Fuchida about the Battle of Midway.

(Midway; The battle that doomed Japan, the Japanese Navy's Story)

In this book he states that the US divebomber squadrons dropped bombs on 3 carriers with decks full of fueled and armed bombers ready to lauch a crippling airstrike. The concept is that they missed winning the Battle of Midway by just 5 minutes.

The truth is that the decks were NOT covered by bombers armed and ready to take off. They were more like a half hour to an hour away from launching. The only planes on deck were the Zeros of the Kido Butai's CAP.

The book is part of what is referred to as revisionist history.

It was published almost 10 years after the war ended.

While Commander Fuchida was technically at the battle he was not really a participant being a refugee from sick bay. By the end of the war he was promoted to captain.

It is important to view history and the things that happen from the view of those that were there and particpating.

Another example of what might be called revisionist history may be the yarn of what happened when the German ships Prinz Eugen and Bismark encountered the British Hood and Prince of Wales. We all know that the Hood blew up. But the Prinz Eugen was credited with starting fires on the Hood prior to the massive magazine explosion.

ANd yes a heavy cruiser such as the Prinz Eugen can damage a BattleCruiser such as the Hood. The British won the hunt for the Bismark so what ship sank the Hood.... The Bismark did. Right???

Did all countries or their leaders do the right thing at the right time all the time? No. Not when viewed a bunch of years later. But the decisions were executed by those that were there based upon what they saw and experienced at the time.

We cannot judge what happened decades earlier based upon our "complete" knowledge in hind sight.

Brian.

Re: December 7,1941- A day that will live in infamy-

#14

Re: But wait for the revisionists

Fred Davis

>For a real eye opener Brian, there is a book about 'Custer's Last stand" that is researched and written from the eye witness accounts of the Indians who were in that fight and survived to tell the story in ther oral history.

You would swear the different stories told by each side , were entirely two different battles. ;-))

FredD

Re: December 7,1941- A day that will live in infamy-

#15

Re: But wait for the revisionists

charlie belden

>I personally witnessed the beginnings of an international incident referred to as either the 1964 Flag Pole Incident or the 1964 Panama Riots.

What Pamamanian newspapers, radio and one TV station reported as having happened and what I saw with my own eyes and heard with my own ears were 180 degrees apart. Even the Christian Science Monitor, one of the more accurate papers of the day, did the same thing.

And now, 45 years later, the recollections of Panamanian students who say they were there at the time don't jive what I witnessed much at all.

And since we lived less than a quarter mile from The Border, and had two rifle and one weapons platoon, and about a dozen APCs hanging out on our cul de sac and had rounds that had to have come FROM the Border hit our home it definitely WAS NOT unarmed innocent Panamanian civilians being gunned down by ruthless aggressive Yankee Imperialists.

As is the case with any crisis, they present opportunities. The Marshall Plan changed how wars ended, for the better I believe. The idea of the winner helping in a big way to rebuild the vanqueshed was a new idea in human history - and changed the world - for the better in my opinion.

stepping down from the soapbox