Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Hearing Protection - Custom fitted or no?

Posts

Hearing Protection - Custom fitted or no?

#1

Hearing Protection - Custom fitted or no?

Brian in Sandusky, OH

>I really need to look into better hearing protection.

I see my two choices as this...

1. Custom fitted, going to an audiologist.

2. Electronic earmuffs that have an electronic noise filter, radio receiver, iPod plug-in, etc.

Audiologist

Pros

Probably the most comfortable

Not clumsy

Cost less than, or ballpark of $100 (?)

Cons

Electronic noise filter possible?

Am I going to still hear the radio, phone, etc?

Earmuffs

Pros

Electronic noise filter

Still hear the radio, phone, etc (?)

Plug in my iPod, tune into FM radio

Cons

Uncomfortable? Clumsy?

Looks like a good pair is going to be $150-250

Anyone have experience with both?

Comfortable is important, as I'm going to be wearing them 8-12 hours a day.

Having my radio to listen to is important. I would go nuts in the shop without some music and talk radio.

Thanks.

Re: Hearing Protection - Custom fitted or no?

#2

Re: Hearing Protection - Custom fitted or no?

Scott in Montana

>Hello Brian,

You can have the best of both worlds... but of course it costs a bit more. Etyomotic, Shure, and other brands of headphone manufacturers make transducers that audiologists can custom fit. You see rockstars wearing these as monitors on stage.

Depending on the amount of attenuation you are seeking, you might try a pair of the Etymotic iPod headphones alone. I frequently wear mine all day long and they provide 30db of protection.

A good source of information on such is www.headphone.com. I have no affiliation.

Happy Holidays!

Scott in Montana

Re: Hearing Protection - Custom fitted or no?

#3

Re: Hearing Protection - Custom fitted or no?

Charles Yawn

>I wore ear muffs, fitted plugs and the occasional disposible foam plugs while competitive shooting for years. More recently, I wore fitted in-the-canal hearing aids for years.

I recommend ear muffs for hearing protection. They were more comfortable to me. With plugs, even fitted, it takes some getting used to the "fullness" discomfort. There is also the possibility of packing ear wax further into the canal and maybe up against the ear drum when you stuff a plug in your ear.

Another reason for muffs is the risk of infections from plugs, again, even fitted. If not carefully cleaned and disinfected after each use, reusable ear plugs can contribute to developing an itchy, flakey type skin rash (like psoriasis) in the ears that is usually not dangerous but is aggrevating and, at least mine, is not curable. Even taking care to keep the fitted plugs clean, they can still trap moisture in the canal and against the skin and encourage nasty stuff to grow. My experiences.

Charles

Re: Hearing Protection - Custom fitted or no?

#4

Re: Hearing Protection - Custom fitted or no?

mdclor

>If you wear glasses be aware that they will somewhat reduce the effectiveness of ear muffs due to the temple piece providing a small opening that will let sound waves get in. A bigger issue for me is that I got new glasses and the new piece that wraps behind the ear sticks out a little straighter than it did on the old glasses and after about 1.5 hours I can feel the pressure from the muff. After 2 hours I find something else to do that doesn't require hearing protection.

Re: Hearing Protection - Custom fitted or no?

#5

Foam PLugs

Tony - Memphis

>So, what is the typical drop of a foam plug? That's what I wear. My loudest tool is the shop vac and the chop saw. I've probbaly already done some damage listening to Van Halen loud as it would go in my '69 VW as a teenager, so I don't want to do anymore damage if possible! What would SWMBO do if I couldn't hear her nag? (Just kidding sweetie!) I mounted my router in a cabinet recently and that made a huge difference. I still wear plugs when using it though.

Tony

Re: Hearing Protection - Custom fitted or no?

#6

JL

Re: Hearing Protection - Custom fitted or no?

JL

>I have a pair of the noise canceling ear muffs. I also have a pair of "shooter's muffs". I usually wear the shooter's muffs.

If I am working with really noisy equipment for a period of time, I'll also put in a pair of the foam ear plugs.

Re: Hearing Protection - Custom fitted or no?

#7

Re: Hearing Protection - Custom fitted or no?

Fred Davis

>Shooters muffs used on Pistol ranges work great , I have a pair , was about 35.00 ten years ago.

FredD

Re: Hearing Protection - Custom fitted or no?

#8

Re: Hearing Protection - Custom fitted or no?

Chris Friesen

>I have the custom fitted earplugs, the big Peltor H10 muffs, "Airsoft" insertable plugs, and ZEM protectors.

The custom plugs make my ears feel quite "full". I bought them to sleep in (when my wife started snoring in pregnancy) because the Airsoft ones have little posts sticking out of them.

For shop use I actually prefer the Airsofts to the custom fitted ones, as they have a bit more "give" to them while still giving excellent protection.

With either of the in-ear plugs, once properly inserted they're a bit of a pain to remove. For short-term intermittent use I prefer the muffs. In summer they get pretty hot and sweaty though, and safety glasses tend to reduce their effectiveness.

Not a huge fan of the ZEM for working in a one-man shop. If you touch the red plastic bits with anything while wearing them it's quite loud.

Re: Hearing Protection - Custom fitted or no?

#9

What did you say?

Virgil Johnson

>

Re: Hearing Protection - Custom fitted or no?

#10

Re: Hearing Protection - Custom fitted or no?

Pete in Holland, MI

>I usually use ear muffs. I do wear glasses, but that doesn't really bother them or me too much. I like them because they are easy on & off as compared to ear plugs.

Draw back is that they do trap heat and will make you sweat some around that enclosed area, especially when it is warm.

I make sure to leave my muffs skewed some when done with them so they are not clamped together, thus have a chance to dry. Would suspect it would be a good idea to occasionally clean them with some form of disinfectant.

How much you want to spend depends on you. Hearing damage comes from extended exposure to noise. Louder noises result in hearing losses sooner.

I think my muffs cost around $20 or so 8 years ago.

I would caution you about getting ear muffs with any kind of entertainment audio feature. Getting focused on a song or discussion on the radio will cause you to lose focus on where your hands are.

Pete