Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Substitution for Birch?

Posts

Substitution for Birch?

#1

Substitution for Birch?

Ed in NY

>Hi, I went out and bought some Birch plywood for some bookcases I'm going to build. I've been looking all over my area for some birch boards for the edge banding but can't seem to find it for sale anywhere. I'm not going to stain the wood, just apply clear poly. Is there any wood, such as Poplar, that I could substitute that wouldn't look ridiculous?

Thanks,

Ed

Re: Substitution for Birch?

#2

Re: Substitution for Birch?

Grant Wilkinson

>I'd go with maple.

Re: Substitution for Birch?

#3

JL

Maple might look reasonable...

JL

>Of course if you live around here, I'd give you a few board feet.

Re: Substitution for Birch?

#4

Re: Substitution for Birch?

Charles Yawn

>How about slicing off the top veneer of some more birch plywood and use that for the edge banding?

Charles

Re: Substitution for Birch?

#5

I'm surprised you can't find any...

John in NM

>I wouldn't have guessed it would be hard to find - I bought some in Albuquerque a couple years ago, we're probably 1000 miles from the nearest birch tree...

Maple would look fine, especially soft maple.

Re: Substitution for Birch?

#6

Basswood

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Some years a ago when there were many small shops making kitchen cabinets, and cabinets of birch plywood were popular, we sold mountains of basswood for the cabinet trim. The shops said that basswood stained up well to match the plywood. We could have sold them birch lumber but they felt the basswood was better. If you ever tried to stain birch lumber you will know why. So, there you have it second hand from persons that made their living doing what you want to do. There is almost no demand for basswood now so it should be cheap if you can find some. Much is harvested in central and southern NY.

Re: Substitution for Birch?

#7

Edging

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Ed,

I've not seen dimensional birch stock in years, but every "yard" the I've been in that sells birch ply also sells the hot-glue birch veneer tape for ply edging. Obviously, it won't take the abuse that solid stock will, but it will match the face veneer.

If you can't find any local, both Rockler and Woodcraft sell birch edge banding in rolls up to 250'

Re: Substitution for Birch?

#8

Clint Searl

Beech

Clint Searl

>

Re: Substitution for Birch?

#9

Different idea

Joanne in Pt. Pleasant, PA

>I usually edge birch plywood with cherry. Great combo. I only use clear coat on cherry anyway.

I'd post a picture, but I just set up this new Mac and all my photos are on the old pc (which is not on right now). I'll post one tomorrow.

Re: Substitution for Birch?

#10

Re: Substitution for Birch?

Ed in NY

>Thanks for all your suggestions...Maple is in plentiful supply here, of course, so I may have to go with that. Haven't seen any Basswood around either. I was thinking about edging it with the adhesive veneer but I'd really like to keep it all wood and, yes, it will be subject to abuse from lots of kids! The idea of taking the top layer off of the plywood itself is interesting, I really never thought of that. Finally, the idea of Cherry is VERY interesting, thanks for that idea Joanne, I really would like to see those pictures. I also have to put on a couple of raised panel doors at the bottom of the bookcase. I can get birch for that throught the mail as I don't need any 7 1/2' long pieces. I'm now wondering what it would look like with the shell made of birch, banding and making the doors out of cherry?

Re: Substitution for Birch?

#11

Re: Substitution for Birch?

Lynn Baker

>Ed,

Most cabinetmakers here in the Pac. NW use Alder as a solid wood when using birch plywood. It seems to take finish to match birch ply better than birch lumber. I've been told that it has somethig to do with the way the rotary cut birch is treated when made into plywood.

Of course, Alder is readily available here in the Northwest.

Lynn

Re: Substitution for Birch?

#12

Re: Substitution for Birch?

Ed in NY

>Thanks Lynn....I have about 20 years to go, then I'm off of Long Island and then hoping to head to Sequim Washington for a peaceful retirement. Nice to know the Alder is in plentiful supply up there. I haven't seen any here though....

Re: Substitution for Birch?

#13

Birch with cherry edging samples

Joanne in Pt. Pleasant, PA

>Ed,

I�ve made a few pieces with nice birch ply, edged in cherry. These pictures are terrible, sorry, but hopefully, you�ll get the idea. I�ve done edging, moldings, and base molding. I�ve strengthened shelves with strips thicker than the �� plywood.

The first shot is the side of a tv cart I built for my Dad. It�s a really bad photo, but the point is the edging, molding, and cherry drawerfront. The cherry ages beautifully and really makes a nice contrast with the birch ply.


For the bookcase I actually got to keep in my house, I used cherry to frame the top, thin �� strips down the upright pieces, thicker strips to reinforce the shelves, and to make a base molding.



And here is the bookcase (jam-packed, of course) with the cherry darkening with age.


I also made a nightstand for my sister out of birch ply with cherry edging, molding, drawerfront and knob.




Re: Substitution for Birch?

#14

Re: Birch with cherry edging samples

Ed in NY

>Wow! Very nice! I think you've convinced me to go with cherry. I like how you faced it with thicker stock, I was going to go with 1/16" or 1/8" thick pices, now I might do 1/2 to 3/4. Thanks so much for the samples!