Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

For the Guys-Prostrate supplemts/

Posts

For the Guys-Prostrate supplemts/

#1

For the Guys-Prostrate supplemts/

Thomas Norton

>Has anyone used a supplement such as Super Beta Prostrate?

THANKS

Re: For the Guys-Prostrate supplemts/

#2

Re: For the Guys-Prostrate supplemts/

R Drouare

>Why waste your money? If you are having problems, or think you do, go to a doctor [urologist].

For your better health---Ralph

Re: For the Guys-Prostrate supplemts/

#3

Re: For the Guys-Prostrate supplemts/

Chuck

>I agree...see a doctor(urologist) and don't waste your money on junk pills.

Re: For the Guys-Prostrate supplemts/

#4

Re: For the Guys-Prostrate supplemts/

Howard Norman

>I have not heard of Super Beta Prostrate but I would almost bet that it contains Saw Palmetto. I took Saw Palmetto because of prostate problems for about ten years on the advise of my primary care physician. It worked fine for those ten years then about a year ago I had to go on Adovart which is a brand name drug.

I was told when I first started on Saw Palmetto that it worked for over half of the men with prostate problems and to take it for 30 days as a trial, that if I didn't see any results in 30 days that it was not going to work for me. I think I can recall one or two men out of maybe a dozen where Saw Palmetto didn't work for them.

Yes, I would recommend discussing the problem with your doctor but I also can say from personal experience that Saw Palmetto does work for some men with prostate problems.

Re: For the Guys-Prostrate supplemts/

#5

Re: For the Guys-Prostrate supplemts/

Gerry In North Surrey

>Bee Pollen worked for me for years, when it quit I went to my Urologist and was put on Flomax. It works for me.

Gerry

Re: For the Guys-Prostrate supplemts/

#6

Saw Palmetto

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>The urologist who diagnosed my prostate cancer was VERY education-oriented; each time my wife and I visited him, he spent a good 50% of very extensive, long visits explaining prostate-related issues.

I asked about saw palmetto, and he said that what it suppresses the PSA (prostate-specific antigen), but doesn't affect the underlying causes that might increase PSA. Since PSA is an extremely useful indicator of prostate problems, in his opinion, saw palmetto is counter-productive, as it may mask problems.

When I used saw palmetto for a while, my PSA indeed went down, only to rise again when I stopped taking it; and, within a couple of years, my physician recommended I see the urologist to explore prostate problems, out of which came my cancer diagnosis. Given how slowly prostate cancer grows, I presume I had it during the period that I was taking the saw palmetto, although I don't know this for sure. Given the direction my medical journey went, saw palmetto stopped being an important issue - not much need to reduce PSA if you don't have a prostate.

I don't know enough to say anything authoritative; but I would do lots of research before depending on saw palmetto. You may be hiding rather than curing a problem.

Re: For the Guys-Prostrate supplemts/

#7

Re: Saw Palmetto

Howard Norman

>What Saw Palmetto and now Avodart did/does for me is elimates the need to urinate during the night. Without one or the other of them I was having to get up three or four times during the night to go to the bathroom. Now it is rare that I have to go to the bathroom during the night. However, as I said before after about ten years the Saw Palmetto became ineffective and I had to switch to a prescribed drug.

My PSA numbers have alwasy been very low.

Re: For the Guys-Prostrate supplemts/

#8

Wow! Didn't know that

Neal in San Jose

>That makes it sound like Saw Palmetto may be a really bad idea. I'll plan on discussing this the next time I see my urologist and report back. A second opinion never hurts.

My PSA shot up from a marginally high 4.5 to 7 between yearly visits. Had further testing done, (biopsy, ultra sound) and I have no cancer, but it was a scary few days until the results came back. One thing I did learn is that sex within the day before the blood test can spike your PSA, so you might want to abstain for a couple of days before your annual to avoid an unnecessary fairly unpleasant proceedure, and a VERY unpleasant wait for results.

HTH Neal

Re: For the Guys-Prostrate supplemts/

#9

Thank you Bill...

paul in AZ------WebKitFormBoundary+isMX5X2paiDYC5e

>for the informed post.

Most of these magic cures are more hype than science. A worthwhile exercise is to search out controlled double blind studies in peer reviewed journals [not the XXXX health magazines]. In almost every case the studies either don't exist or the results are negative.

If you can't or won't do that go see a urologist. Make sure you don't have cancer.

These "natural" cures are a gigantic $$$ business, as in scam, and generally won't stand up to scrutiny.

Re: For the Guys-Prostrate supplemts/

#10

PSA levels

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>As I understand it, PSA is basically an indicator of prostate activity levels (I'm sure there's a technical term; this isn't). Increased activity levels can be normal, as in sex; or abnormal, as in enlargement, cancer, or disease causing inflammation.

As an ex-boss and good friend said of her breast cancer, after I got my prostate cancer diagnosis, I learned a great deal about things I never wanted to know about.

Re: For the Guys-Prostrate supplemts/

#11

Re: PSA levels

paul in AZ------WebKitFormBoundary+isMX5X2paiDYC5e

>Correct.

Normal levels also don't rule out disease.

The initial hope that the test would be cancer specific has faded somewhat. Emphasis has shifted back to the clinical exam as performed by a capable examiner. I say capable because the average doc may miss small changes that a urologist who sees this all day every day is more likely to pick up.

My PSA levels were consistently in the mid normal range and it was the digital exam that picked up my cancer. Three years+ after IMRT and doing well.

Re: For the Guys-Prostrate supplemts/

#12

Re: PSA levels

Fred Davis

>A woman Surgeon in Salina , Kansas , near where I live has been quoted as saying "a PSA test result without a accompanying digital exam is worthless in her opinion".

I ran that by my primary care physician at the Veterans Hospital in Topeka and he "Nah , don't agree".

On the other hand after some reflection , the Female doc may have some sadistic tendencies.

I hate it when medical people disagree .

FredD

Re: For the Guys-Prostrate supplemts/

#13

Anotehr reason

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>I had a scare about 10 years ago. When I turned 50 I promised LOML to get a physical every year. So, I signed up for an appointment with my doctor, went in he did a complete exam including a physical prostate exam. Then at the end of the visit he gave me paper work for blood tests. I fasted that night, went in first thing the next day and got the blood work taken care of. Everything is great right....wrong my PSA reading was very high. Since my Dad died from complications from prostate cancer I was gravely concerned. Went to see a urologist who did a physical exam and then ordered a blood test 3 months later to check PSA levels again. The second test was normal as was the one 6 months after that an all the ones since.

What I learned is that a physical exam of the prostate can inject large amounts of the antigen into the blood stream and it remains there for several months in decreasing levels. You should always get your blood work done before a physical exam or wait several months after the exam to get it done. Otherwise you will likely get an elevated reading.

Lee

Re: For the Guys-Prostrate supplemts/

#14

Re: Anotehr reason

Kneale Brownson..Back enjoying CO snow

>Even taking a pill for a stuffy nose can cause prostate swelling and an elevated PSA. Be sure to mention any meds you've taken recently if you're in the "scare zone".

Re: For the Guys-Prostrate supplemts/

#15

Re: PSA levels

paul in AZ------WebKitFormBoundary+isMX5X2paiDYC5e

>"a PSA test result without a accompanying digital exam is worthless in her opinion".

I ran that by my primary care physician at the Veterans Hospital in Topeka and he "Nah , don't agree".

Sorry Fred, but studies in Europe and the US following large numbers of men for many years support the surgeon.

As few as 1 in 4 positive PSAs turn out to be due to cancer. OTOH a rapidly growing cancer may produce no PSA. Your VA doc needs to head to the library.

Re: For the Guys-Prostrate supplemts/

#16

Ric Taylor

Not So Fast..........

Ric Taylor

>This is all based on my personal experience as a prostate cancer survivor.

Point number one: Having good results from a needle biopsy of your prostate does NOT mean you don't have cancer. The needle is inserted into the prostate a number of times (6 times in my case, but I've heard of as many as 12). A small sample is taken at the point of the needle and withdrawn to be sent for a pathology analysis. Cancer can be in small spots within the prostate, like a bean in a bag of sugar. The rest of the tissue can be normal. If the needle doesn't happen to hit the bean, then the pathology results will show no cancer when in fact there is a spot(s) of cancer in there.

In my case, my PSA was 4.6. I was very lucky, the needle did happen to hit a bean (spot of cancer). After my surgery (the prostate is removed and sent to the pathology lab for further analysis), the pathology report states, "This is the earliest and smallest sample of prostate cancer this lab has ever seen." In fact, the first report said there was no cancer, and my doctor made them look at it again. The second time, they found the cancer.

Point number two: regarding the statement that a test without a digital exam is useless. False statement. In my case, the digital exam showed nothing, because the spots of cancer were so small, but I did, in fact, have cancer.

Eight years later my life is completely normal.

For you Vietnam vets out there, if you served even just one day in Vietnam and later are diagnosed with prostate cancer (or any of 12 other cancers), you are automatically disabled and eligible for very worthwhile benefits. I have a 20% disability. Look on the VA website for details.

All men (who still have a prostate) should get their PSA checked regularly.

Ric

Re: For the Guys-Prostrate supplemts/

#17

It is a delicate business

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>in more ways than one.

I was referred to the nearby university med center for treatment of my cancer, once it was diagnosed, and got very good treatment. One of the docs there praised my primary care doctor for picking up the texture change in the prostate, which was part of what led to my diagnosis.

PSA tests and, as much fun as they're not, the digital exams are both important; what's most important, as always, is the skill of the physician(s).

Re: For the Guys-Prostrate supplemts/

#18

Not just the prostrate but also..

North of the Border

>the colon. Colon and prostrate cancers kill lots of men. Since turning 50, I have had both physical and lab. (PSA) exam. to ensure I'm cancer free on those two organs. The colonscopy is done once every 5 years and there wasn't noticeable discomfort to me. We can prevent death, but we minimize the risk of dying from painful illness like colon and prostrate cancers. As long as you're checked regularly and prostrate cancer is ruled out as the cause for your urination issue, that's fine to take whatever prostrate medication prescribed for you fro a good quality of life.

Re: For the Guys-Prostrate supplemts/

#19

Please

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>I know it's a small thing, but it really grates.

There is no "r" in "prostate". "Prostrate" means to lay down or be subjugated and subservient. Pros"tate" is the gland.

My grandfather died of prostate cancer. My father had radiation for it. I assume I'm next. But I'll not prostrate myself to anyone. (except, of course, SWMBO)

rant off

Re: For the Guys-Prostrate supplemts/

#20

Re: Please

Howard Norman

>I noticed the same thing Mark. It is a common mistake.

Re: For the Guys-Prostrate supplemts/

#21

Re: PSA levels

Fred Davis

>Well the Doc was willing to do the digital , . I passed when given the choice ;-))

FredD