Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Contractor's -vs- Cabinet saw upgrade experience

Posts

Contractor's -vs- Cabinet saw upgrade experience

#1

Contractor's -vs- Cabinet saw upgrade experience

Pete in Holland, MI

>Guys -

This information request is directed at those of you who started life on a contractor's saw, but later upgraded to a cabinet saw:

I have been using a JET contractor's saw for 15 years or so now and am happy with it's performance in my hobby (cabinets, furniture, and many other facets of wood working).

Have been pondering a new cabinet saw, but can't justify it right now.

Other than more horsepower (typically), an enclosed base, opportunity for a riving knife, and a "more solid" machine, what are the realistic reasons to upgrade?

Yes, I know that you can balance a nickel on the top of many of them, but minor vibration doesn't seem to impact my work.

What did you guys eventually realize was the reason(s) for your upgrade? I don't seem many folks going backwards in saw purchases. Just curious.

Thanx !

Pete

Re: Contractor's -vs- Cabinet saw upgrade experience

#2

Re: Contractor's -vs- Cabinet saw upgrade experien

Jim Dillon

>Pete,

I think you have pretty much nailed the "advantages" of going to a cabinet saw. I put advantages in quotes because your final product with a cabinet saw verses a contractors saw (especially in your experienced hands) is likely to be minimal. Nonetheless, those advantages are not insignificant, especially after feeding stuff (especially thick stuff) through the saw all day long. It sounds like you are looking for a (good) reason to buy a cabinet saw. While I don't think a cabinet saw will significantly improve the quality of your work output, I think you would find the experience of using a cabinet saw worthwhile. Whether-or-not you are pushing a 4x8 sheet of plywood, or a 12/4 piece of jatoba (a very hard tropical wood) through the cabinet saw, it will easily be done and done in a way that "feels" safer.

I owned a small contractors saw (a Makita) for about a year and it sure did what I needed - mostly interior trim. I eventually sold it and purchased a cabinet saw and couldn't be more pleased. This was before hybrid saws were available, so those were not an option - thank goodness; sure would have made the upgrade option more difficult 8-). Let us know what you decide on and what you go for. That helps keep all of us at WC current with what is available.

Jim

Re: Contractor's -vs- Cabinet saw upgrade experience

#3

Re: Contractor's -vs- Cabinet saw upgrade experien

Mark Salomon

>I found it difficult to keep my Delta contractor saw in tune. Just when I'd get the blade parallel to the slot I'd find that it tailed out when I cranked it over to 45 degree. To fix it requires shimming the trunnions which is a real pain. It can be such a problem that some authors recommend never tilting the blade and using a bevel sled. Anyway, you don't have this problem with a cabinet saw. I also found the cabinet saw to require less room in my already tight garage. Also, I love having a 3hp motor that doesn't bog down when you feed 8/4 hard maple through it. Sure, there are work-arounds to most of these problems but it sure is nice to worry about other aspects than whether your tool will give you rock solid accuracy.

Re: Contractor's -vs- Cabinet saw upgrade experience

#4

Re: Contractor's -vs- Cabinet saw upgrade experien

Bill Earl

>I took the plunge before riving knives were available, so that wasn't a factor. But comparing my cabinet saw to the contractor's saw it replaced, the benefits are (in order of importance):

Better fence system. No more measuring fore and aft and tapping with a mallet to square it up before a cut. Some contractor's saws these days come with pretty nice fence systems. A good fence is worth more than all the other features combined.

Bigger, flatter top. My old saw had sheet-metal wings that sagged. Cast-iron wings, extension and outfeed tables are a big improvement.

Better dust collection. The enclosed base helps a lot.

Easier alignment. The cabinet saw was pretty close to dead-on from the factory. It only took a couple of shims to make it perfect. The contractor's saw needed a lot of tweaking and cussing to get it to line up at both 90 and 45 degrees. Fortunately, I only had to do this once.

More power. I used to trip the thermal protection on the contractor saw while nursing a cut in 8/4 maple. Now I do 12/4 with a power feeder.

Re: Contractor's -vs- Cabinet saw upgrade experience

#5

Re: Contractor's -vs- Cabinet saw upgrade experien

Lewis Dodd

>Ha! They sure looked good in the catalogs to me. My drooling was getting pretty bad. My itch and ego overtook me and jerked my credit card out of pocket. I love mine, the horse power and the weight of the whole unit. It stays in one place. Life is too short to not have good tools!!! Bite the bullet and getcha one, Merry Christmas to you!

Lewis

Re: Contractor's -vs- Cabinet saw upgrade experience

#6

JL

Re: Contractor's -vs- Cabinet saw upgrade experien

JL

>Why did I upgrade?

Power - 5 hp (overkill, but it was only $50 more versus 3 hp) - I can saw through cherry, oak, maple or any other hardwood quite quickly. I don't have to worry about my saw bogging down. If I want to make a cove cut or an angled cut (think tapering), I don't have to worry about it.

Fence - my original one was a piece of C&@%. I replaced it and it was better. My fence now is rock solid. I can slide jigs on it, set it consistently, etc. I also have 50+ inches to the right of my blade.

Table - yes, I could have built a table around my old saw - but why? I now have about a 4' table. Makes a real difference.

Dust collection - I had mounted a piece of plywood and a dust hood on the underside of my contractor's saw. I used it and I partially blocked off the back. Didn't really work well. Now I have a sloped enclosed bottom. I can turn on the DC or not (when I cut a bunch of dadoes in PT lumber, I left the DC off and collected the cutting there).

Repeatability - I can set my fence to the same distance and know it will be accurate. I can set the angle on the blade and know it can easily be repeated.

Weight - my contractor's saw weighed maybe 200 lbs or less. My cabinet saw weighs over 500 lbs. When you are cutting large, weighty pieces of lumber it makes a difference.

Do you need a cabinet saw - no. If you have a good sharp thin kerf blade and 1 1/2 hp, you can cut almost anything. But you'll probably cut it better and faster with a cabinet saw.

Re: Contractor's -vs- Cabinet saw upgrade experience

#7

Re: Contractor's -vs- Cabinet saw upgrade experien

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>If you are happy with your current saw and it does what you want it to do then why switch? Enjoy the saw you have and use your tool money for other needs.

Tom

Re: Contractor's -vs- Cabinet saw upgrade experience

#8

Re: Contractor's -vs- Cabinet saw upgrade experien

Marvin Horn

>I had a Crapsman that was useless for bevel cuts. Also I never realized everyone didn't have to retune their saw every month or so until I got a cabinet.

Re: Contractor's -vs- Cabinet saw upgrade experience

#9

Re: Contractor's -vs- Cabinet saw upgrade experien

JohnM in mid Mich

>I had a Craftsperson contractor saw for many years (1977 'til 2002?) and it was a great workhorse. I can't disagree more with the previous poster's general statements about them. Perhaps he had a lower end unit. They aren't all bad. Around '02 I upgraded to a Jet Cabinet Saw. In hindsight, the contractor did everything I needed. For $500 to $700, you could add an Incra fence and an Incra miter gauge to your contractor and end up with what, in my opinion, is a way better woodworking tool than any stock cabinet saw. This does, of course, presume you are starting with one of the better contractor saws.

Re: Contractor's -vs- Cabinet saw upgrade experience

#10

Re: Contractor's -vs- Cabinet saw upgrade experien

Tony - Memphis

>I just did that last year. My old saw was a Delta CS (34-444 I think). The saw was never realyl a limiting factor in my work. A couple of things came up that made me get serious about upgrading. I got real frustrated trying to get my saw tuned up. Every time I'd get it pretty close (slot to blade), it would move when I hung the motor. I also had two episodes of locking up the blade with a piece of maple (even with a splitter). So, for me, it was just that I was ready and able and there was a 10% off sale. I can't justify the purchase. I am very happy with the new saw though. One thing is that it doesn't move! Wow! I really like the riving knife for safety. I'm not picky about dust collection, but it does that pretty well. Power was never an issue with the old saw really, but I can tell a difference on thick stock and I like it better for that too. I complain about the accuracy of the CS, but there was one fellow that was making extremely precise puzzles using the same saw. So, it can be done! I don't have any regrets and I love the new saw. I'm glad I did it just before the recession - a few months later and I wouldn't have pulled the trigger. To qualify, I mainly build furniture. Usually 18th century. Most of my stock is 4/4 maple, mahogany (well, not lately), cherry, and the like. Oh, another thig I like is the knee bump switch. One thing I didn't like was the gaurd. So, I installed my old Brett Gaurd. Oh, my saw is a PM2000. In summary, its realy a matter of feel for me (the weekend warrior). Kind of like cars. We drove several sporty convertibles, but twhen we drove a Z, it was no comparison. Anyway, sorry to ramble. Enjoy your new saw if/when you decide to get one.

Tony

Re: Contractor's -vs- Cabinet saw upgrade experience

#11

Re: Contractor's -vs- Cabinet saw upgrade experien

Chuck in ND

>It sounds to me as if your trying to find excuses to replace a saw that your happy with. Someone else here points out that they had a Makita Contractor's table saw, I'm thinking that it was a Jobsite table saw, big difference. Anyway, I have tossed around the idea of a Cabinet table saw before several times, only because it gets brought up alot in these types of forums. Do I need one ? No. I have a American made Delta 34-445X with a Unifence and mobile base that I bought new in 1995. Since then I have done a couple inexpensive upgrades to it. I rewired the motor to 220V, replaced the tiny toggle switch with a paddle switch and relocated it under the fence rail for easier access. I replaced the stock V-belt with a Fenner Drives PowerTwist link belt with that helps the saw run smoother. Dust collection I worked on for close to a year on the design of it and am extremely happy with. As far as the motor hanging out the back and useing more shop space, I have a Delta removeable outfeed table on the saw when I'm useing it, so I really don't take that complaint to seriously, also for storage reasons the motor is also easy and quick to remove. There are deals out there on cabinet saws, no doubt, but remember that few people will ask you before makeing such a purchase, how is your shops electrical system? Can it handle it, plus a dust collector and a few other small things such as lights, radio, etc ? My garage/shop couldn't and that would be an added expense, especially if I had to hire it out.

Re: Contractor's -vs- Cabinet saw upgrade experience

#12

Re: One other thing

Chuck in ND

>About 95% of crosscuts are done on the miter saw in my shop, i feel that I have better control of the board, and I get better cross cuts that way. The table saw sees mostly 90 degree rip cuts and dadoes.

Re: Contractor's -vs- Cabinet saw upgrade experience

#13

Re: Contractor's -vs- Cabinet saw upgrade experien

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Morning Pete,

I "upgraded" from a Jet Contractor's saw w/18 amp motor to a Jet Hybrid last year. My contractor's saw was the better saw mechanically, but the switch was justified by a left tilting arbor on the hybrid. I judge the fence on the hybrid is better, although I was completely satisfied with the Jet Fence on the contractor's saw. I also gained a little room in my small shop by not having the saw stand off from the wall to accommodate the contractor saw motor.

If I had it to do over, I would have either stuck with the contractor saw (had more power) or would have bought another contractor saw with a left tilting arbor. I like and frequently use the left tilt feature of the hybrid. However, I would rather have my old saw back if it was configured for left tilt.

George

Re: Contractor's -vs- Cabinet saw upgrade experience

#14

Louie Lovas

Re: Contractor's -vs- Cabinet saw upgrade experien

Louie Lovas

>A long time ago I considered upgrading to a cabinet saw, looked at a bunch of them. But I have two contractor style saws now. I dedicate one to ripping the other to crosscutting. I've upgraded both to that specialized purpose. Both saws are 1980's vintage Craftsman saws. But I've added a Delta Unifence, both now have 2HP 220v motors for extra power (a much needed upgrade), balanced pulleys/link belt, PALS alignment system and the JessEm sliding crosscut table. I also built mobile cabinets around them both. The ripping saw has a Router table built in. Both have dust collection too. I have no trouble keeping them perfectly aligned for accurate cutting.

While I have sunk a lot of money into them, I now have no interest in a cabinet saw.


img

Re: Contractor's -vs- Cabinet saw upgrade experience

#15

Hummm . . . interesting feedback thus far

Pete in Holland, MI

>My JET Contractor's saw (pretty much the last of the blue ones) has been upgraded with cast wings, link belt, steel pulleys, 220v, and several plugs to make the dust collection work better. I had to replace the arbor bearings a couple years ago, but overall, it is still treating me right. The JetFence is also doing well.

Maybe when I win the lottery, or get the kids out of college, or stumble into "the deal of the century", I might pull the trigger on a bigger saw, but you all have confirmed my thoughts about keeping my current saw for the time being. Woodworking is still a hobby (one of many) for me.

Thanks for your sharing your experiences !

Pete

Re: Contractor's -vs- Cabinet saw upgrade experience

#16

Bart Goldberg

Re: Contractor's -vs- Cabinet saw upgrade experien *LINK*

Bart Goldberg

>One last item that I don't think was mentioned, and is a huge benefit to me, is that on my Cabinet saw, I could mount a roller outfeed table. I use it all the time and would not be able to use on a contractor saw.


HTC Outfeed Table

Re: Contractor's -vs- Cabinet saw upgrade experience

#17

One benefit not mentioned yet is Size

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>I think I agree with just about everything said in this thread thus far. The one thing that I didn't see anyone mention is size.

I upgraded from a Delta 34-445 contractors saw to a Unisaw about 10 years ago for two main reasons.

The main reason was size, believe it or not. My garage is terribly undersized for my workshop and every square foot counts. The footprint of the Unisaw is smaller than the contractors saw because of the motor sitting inside the cabinet rather than hanging off the back.

The other reason was that I wanted to own a Porshe (car) and came to the realization that I probably would never be able to afford that luxury. So I figured the next best thing would be a Unisaw in my garage.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Contractor's -vs- Cabinet saw upgrade experience

#18

Re: Contractor's -vs- Cabinet saw upgrade experien

Chuck in ND

>Delta 50-390 outfeed table hardware for their Contractor's saws with stamped steel wings.


img

Re: Contractor's -vs- Cabinet saw upgrade experience

#19

Re: Contractor's -vs- Cabinet saw upgrade experien 

Chuck in ND

>


img

Re: Contractor's -vs- Cabinet saw upgrade experience

#20

Re: Contractor's -vs- Cabinet saw upgrade experien

Chuck in ND

>Dust collection results.


img

Re: Contractor's -vs- Cabinet saw upgrade experience

#21

Re: Contractor's -vs- Cabinet saw upgrade experien

Dan Donaldson

>The cabinet saw has a smaller footprint, will cut thicker materials easier, has a better fence if you have not upgraded yours. I was like you and would probably still be using the contractor's saw had my wife not given me the unisaw for Christmas one year.

Re: Contractor's -vs- Cabinet saw upgrade experience

#22

Re: Contractor's -vs- Cabinet saw upgrade experien

John Horner

>Years ago when I first decided to buy a table saw I bought a Delta Contractors saw at the local Home Depot. It only took me a week of using the thing to get frustrated with its lack of repeatability and need for constant re-tuning. Luckily back then HD had a 30 day satisfaction guarantee, and I was so disgusted I packed it all up and took it back. That isn't the sort of thing I normally do, but I didn't want to have to keep struggling with the equipment.

My replacement saw was and is a Unisaw with the 48" Biesemeyer fence & table. I have never once regretted spending the money for the upgrade. The blade to table alignment has been perfect for twelve years now without any need for adjustment. I've had to slightly adjust the fence parallelism once every few years to account for wear. My saw is always up to the job, no matter what the job is. The only variable is the operator! If you can readily afford it, do the upgrade for sure. If, on the other hand, money is tight ... then it certainly is something you can live without.

Re: Contractor's -vs- Cabinet saw upgrade experience

#23

Re: Contractor's -vs- Cabinet saw upgrade experien

Len Rogers

>I made a simialr decision several years ago. My Sears "hobby" saw gave me such frustration, I resolved to upgrade. I checked every saw I could find to look at, and discovered that all cabinet saws required 220 voltage to work, and there was no way that could happen.

Then, I limited my search to 110 and discovered the DeWalt, with its slider, outfeed, and 52" fence. Sweet! A hybrid, yes, but it's capable of anything I need to do. As to horsepower, I don't need the speed so I can feed the work through more slowly. Besides, a kickback at 1.5 hp is a lot less to deal with than one at 5 hp!

Re: Contractor's -vs- Cabinet saw upgrade experience

#24

Re: Contractor's -vs- Cabinet saw upgrade experien

Fred Davis

>Pete ,

when I first started accumulating tools that a Cabinet Maker would need, it was far more common to build Cabinets on site ,then in a shop environment.

So I bought a Delta saw that was identical in the top and fence to a Unisaw and was on a open stand and back mounted 1 1/2 HP motor which let me use 52"rails and load it myself into a Pickup simply by grabbing the table formed by the rails and a piece of 3/4" plywood and tipping it onto a clean sheet of 1/2" ply which was what we used before bed liners.

This saw like I said was cast iron , just like a Unisaw and a far better machine then I see nowadays being called a "contractors saw".

Years later the Chief Building Inspector of Newark ,Ca bought it for $300.00 more then it retailed for in 1964.

Then much later in my Contracting life I started doing fancy wood interiors at BlackHawk ,Ca in huge and expensive homes and I needed that setup again.

I bought a Makita portable saw with a after market table and off feed and used that . The later setup while functionally sufficient for Trim work, left a lot to be desired compared to the old Delta which has a flimsy substitute today , that I now use only rarely, bought for a song from a Hardware that discontinued it.

That Makita setup combined with a Makita 14" chopsaw handled all of the trim cutting needs in very large homes.

I would say that except for the ease of moving one , given a choice in a shop environment, I would go for a Cabinet saw, for all of the reasons you stated.

FredD

Re: Contractor's -vs- Cabinet saw upgrade experience

#25

Re: Contractor's -vs- Cabinet saw upgrade experien

Bernie Lasiewicz

>I own a Dewalt contractor saw and have no problems with it. Once set up at 90� it stays there. The geared track for the fence is the reason I purchased it - it stays parallel to the blade. The only addition was a sliding sled I made of plywood with metal runners.