Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

OT Universal Remotes?

Posts

OT Universal Remotes?

#1

OT Universal Remotes?

Sawman

>I saw a Logitech Remote at someones house last week. It was program via a USB cable off his computer. Looking at Amazon they are like $120 and up.

Are these really worth it?

Thanks

Re: OT Universal Remotes?

#2

Re: OT Universal Remotes?

del schisler

>i belive you can get a cheaper remote Just depends on how many unit's you have to run with the remote I have 4 remote's and i use the original remote for each I guess you can spend and replace 4 with 1 ?? if it is worth it Now if the orig. quit than i would look for the orig. replacement probly less than store unit ?? I guess to answare your question I wouldn't pay that much look around my 2 cents

Re: OT Universal Remotes?

#3

Re: OT Universal Remotes?

Ken Krawford

>I have a Logitech remote (although I only paid $59 on sale) and have mixed feelings. I think it makes the most sense if you have to turn on multiple pieces of electronics at one time. An example would be watching TV involves turning on the cable box, TV and a surround sound system. Press 1 button and everything powers on (or off). Otherwise they are just an expensive remote IMHO.

Re: OT Universal Remotes?

#4

Re: OT Universal Remotes?

IEW

>I have a universal remote that I no longer use. The learning curve to program it was pretty steep and the learning curve to use it was impossible. I have gone back to individual remotes.

Re: OT Universal Remotes?

#5

Re: OT Universal Remotes?

Jerry White

>The remote you saw sounds like the Logitech Harmony One, which I've been using for just under two years. I like it a lot. Software that is installable on your computer comes with the unit. You then tell the software what equipment you have and how it is connected. Then you get online and download the settings for your particular configuration and equipment and feed the stored setup into the remote through the serial cable. There is no looking up numerical codes to program into the remote. With today's multi-function devices with several different types of inputs and outputs, it really simplifies operation for users.

Is it worth it? I think that is something everyone must answer for themselves.

Re: OT Universal Remotes?

#6

Re: OT Universal Remotes?

Dave Paine

>As others have stated, universal remote controls are a mixed blessing. They can have a steep learning curve. A USB interface can help, so the programming is on a PC then downloaded.

As another person stated, the most useful feature can be "scripting" where you can program a series of steps. Some units call this "macro".

I have several universal remotes, and they are no longer used. I would need to buy one with a joy-stick/paddle arrangement used by my TV, DVD player and Audio receiver.

I am not eager to spend more money on an item which may end up not being used.

I really would like to script the series of key strokes. My wife is frequently frustrated that she cannot get the correct video input, or else has the wrong audio stream for the video.

My DVD player is now set to HDMI out. My Audio receive switches HDMI. However, all the HDMI ports are auto-detected, and if the equipment is not turned on a a specific order, the HDMI signal is not detected and so fails to connect. I know how to re-do the manual order, but my wife gets confused.

Re: OT Universal Remotes?

#7

Re: OT Universal Remotes?

John McGaw

>One of the low-end Logitech controls (Harmony 550) came with my TV when I bought it. I'd say that it is worth it if you have a number of pieces of equipment to coordinate and if all of your equipment is amenable. The latter if is a big one because things like my Sharp TV (the one that came with the control) has such a screwy input select sequence that controlling it dependably with the control proves nearly impossible. If it would have had a direct-control of inputs rather than "press the select control" then "wait for the input menu to come up" then "press that same select control until the proper input is highlighted". That is easy enough if you are looking at the screen but the remote can't exactly do that so I am left trying to program delays and other fiddly things to make it work (about 20% of the time, anyway).

Wow, that sounds like a negative review but I really do mean it that the 550 is pretty nice with almost any sort of entertainment setup (just not mine).

Logitech's website has a listing of pre-programmed equipment that you can just select and add to your remote. If all of your equipment is listed there you are probably home free. Otherwise you will have to do some training.

Re: OT Universal Remotes?

#8

Re: OT Universal Remotes?

Scott in Montana

>I might put forward another way of thinking in regards to these remotes. The remote is the piece of equipment that you interface with the most and it can make a complex system a joy to use.

Many of the remotes today are "event" based meaning that when you want to watch television you push one button and the remote will automatically run a "script" of commands that turn on the television, turn on the surround sound receiver, set the reciever to the right input, and can even dim your lights. All with the push of one button.

If programming is for you, many A/V dealers have programmers on staff that can program your remote to your desires, but expect to pay for this service.

The price of the remote sounds reasonable. The remote we specify most often in our designs is $1000 plus programming. The clients are delighted with them.

Scott in Montana

Re: OT Universal Remotes?

#9

Re: OT Universal Remotes?

Lee Schierer, McKean, PA

>We have one that we can program sequences in so that all the electronics needed can be turned on by pressing one button. We can also switch automatically from satellite to dvd and back with a single button push. The remote will change the inputs to the amp, and tv and then will control the dvd player. Basically one remote properly programmed will allow you to put all the other remotes away. The one we have will even learn commands from older remotes that aren't preprogrammed into the universal.

Lee