Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

"Brown" red oak?

Posts

"Brown" red oak?

#1

JL

"Brown" red oak?

JL

>I prepped some of the 8/4 "red" oak that I recently purchased (and some of the 5/4 also). The 5/4 is about the shade that I expected for red oak. The 8/4 is definitely brown or tan in hue.

The grain and pores are red oak type grain and pores (as opposed to white oak). It isn't an unpleasing shade, just an unexpected one. I will have to stain or dye to get a uniform color (or resaw some of the 8/4 to get thinner pieces).

Is this a different species of red oak? An area variation? I'm used to working with Southern red oak which is definitely reddish in hue.

TIA

Re: "Brown" red oak?

#2

Ellis Walentine

Red oaks

Ellis Walentine

>Oaks are loosely divided between the white oaks and the black oaks. Red oak (Quercus rubra) is one of the black oaks, but there are probably two dozen others, each with its own character that may or may not resemble the red oak you're familiar with. Many of them are commonly included with genuine red oak at the lumberyard.

Then there's the geographic variable as you mentioned. The wood of trees of the same species, growing in different locations, with different soil conditions, elevation, rainfall, etc., may look and act very differently.

Ellis

Re: "Brown" red oak?

#3

Re: Red oaks

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>I've built a number of items from red oak and notice the same color variation in red oak that I know all comes from our local area. Some boards are nearly pink in color and others are more tan in color. What I do is work with my lumber source to get boards of the same hue and when I do glue ups, I mix and match to get the most appealing grouping of boards for grain and color. The good news is that if you are staining the wood, the color variation is less pronounced. Still you don't want the darker tan boards adjacent to the very pink ones.

Lee

Re: "Brown" red oak?

#4

Another possibility

Robert R. Clough - Thorncraft

>of confusion. I wonder how often Red Elm is confused with Red Oak. I recently purchased about 100 bf of Ulmus Rubris for a project. It might, just might, be mistaken for Oak.

Re: "Brown" red oak?

#5

be patient and more on "fresh" wood colors

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>The color of all species of freshly planed wood is fleeting. The purples of walnut, the green and yellow of poplar, the white of ash and maple, the reds of hickory and yes, the red of red oak is temporary. As soon as the sun hits these woods these fleeting colors will vanish. In the case of your red "red Oak" it will turn brown like the other red oak.

Red oak is the more uniform in color of the oaks, more so than white which can range from cream to very dark brown.

Re: "Brown" red oak?

#6

Re: be patient and more on "fresh" wood colors

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>Your statement is true, but certain red oak boards are noticeably dark brown all the way through, while the red ones tend to stay redder inside. Perhaps the total age of the tree has something to do with the color of the wood, though I can't recall seeing a board that was partially red and partially brown.

Lee

Re: "Brown" red oak?

#7

JL

I don't know, it was pretty brown...

JL

>

Re: "Brown" red oak?

#8

This observation is accurate

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Here in E TN essentially all the red oak comes from just two species- Northern Red or Southern Red. And as you observed the heartwood can be all sorts of shades of red and tan/brown. The coopered chest I posted some time ago was made from the reddest red oak I have seen sawed but now its become tan like all the other red oak I have worked.

A tree that has been stressed/damaged can have exceptionally dark heart wood, and indeed it tends to stay darker and it is often streaked.