Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

How can I pop the grain after waterbased stain?

Posts

How can I pop the grain after waterbased stain?

#1

How can I pop the grain after waterbased stain?

fred

>I am using a water-based stain (first time for that). In the past I have used BLO to "pop" the grain...

What can I use, that will not change the color much, to pop the grain on a vanity? I'm planning on using General Finish's Arm-r-seal as a top coat. As that is an oil-based topcoat, I was thinking of shellac in between.

I am kind of regretting having already applied a water-based stain, but have to "salvage" it....

Re: How can I pop the grain after waterbased stain?

#2

Re: How can I pop the grain after waterbased stain

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>A common finishing schedule for period mahogany pieces is to dye stain followed by oil. After thoroughly drying the oil (several days) it is sealed with shellac.

Re: How can I pop the grain after waterbased stain?

#3

Re: How can I pop the grain after waterbased stain

fred

>I am, admittedly, new to this, but I was under the notion that if you applied a water-based stain, you then could not apply an oil, without some sort of a barrier inbetween.

I have already applied a General Finishes water-based stain. I was thinking of using shellac as a barrier, then GF Arm-R-Seal as a top coat. The project is out of QS oak, and I'd like to "pop" the grain/flecks a bit.

Re: How can I pop the grain after waterbased stain?

#4

Re: How can I pop the grain after waterbased stain

Tony - Memphis

>Actually, a lto of folks follow a water based dye with a coat of oil. Personally, I don't thin it is needed, but a lot of folks do it. This is a table I just finished and I started with a water based dye, then, various top coats - long story.

I like the General Finishes products. I've had real good luck with their wipe ons.

Try some test pieces. Water based dye looks horrible after it dries. But, when you add a clear coat, it realy comes alive. May take several coats, but it will. I've never tried the water based stain you are using, but I would assume it would act similar. Try it with and without the oil. For some woods, it just muddies things up. I tried it on a dark stained mahogany and all it did was make it too dark. And mahogany doesn't really have that much grain normally anyway.

What kind of wood are you using?

Tony


img

Re: How can I pop the grain after waterbased stain?

#5

Jack-o-lantern Carving Table, Tony?

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Its beautiful.

George

Re: How can I pop the grain after waterbased stain?

#6

Re: How can I pop the grain after waterbased stain

fred

>I'm using quarter sawn oak on the vanity.

Re: How can I pop the grain after waterbased stain?

#7

Clint Searl

Re: How can I pop the grain after waterbased stain

Clint Searl

>Any figure that's in the wood has already been emphasized by the differential absorption of the dye stain between hard and soft wood as well as the changes in the grain direction. No intermediate treatment between the stain and top coat is needed. The top coat alone will bring out figure.

Clint

Re: How can I pop the grain after waterbased stain?

#8

I agree....

Tony - Memphis

>I would try the top coat alone and see how I liked that before I got too fancy. I did several test pieces with and without BLO and I couldn't tell the difference. This was on maple, but I wouldn't be surprised if the same was true for the oak. Actually, I've never heard of anyone using BLO for oak. Good luck with it and let us know what you figure our so we can learn something.

Tony

Re: How can I pop the grain after waterbased stain?

#9

Sure!

Tony - Memphis

>Long story, but it almost became firewood!

Thanks for the comment. Blurry digital photographs hide a lot of sins!

Tony


img

Re: How can I pop the grain after waterbased stain?

#10

Ellis Walentine

Wow! Wonderful table, Tony.

Ellis Walentine

>

Re: How can I pop the grain after waterbased stain?

#11

I'll second that. Beautiful!!

Jim Dillon

>

Re: How can I pop the grain after waterbased stain?

#12

The key here is the statement "after"

Michael Dresdner

>The waterbased stain you reference, and in fact nearly all waterbased stains on the market, are pigmented stains with acrylic binders. In other words, they are thin versions of acrylic paint.

Knowing that, it should come as no surprise that your wood is now more or less sealed, so it is too late to pop grain with an impregnating material, like oil. That's just as well, since that method, which works beautifully on curly woods, like figured maple, does almost nothing but create problems on woods with very large pores and straight growth, like oak.

To bring out the grain in oak you need merely use a pigmented stain, then wipe it all off, leaving extra color in the grain or pores. Assuming you wiped the stain completely while still wet, and assuming you used a contrasting color stain so the pores stand out against the oak color, you've already done the right thing. (If you did not wipe the stain thoroughly while wet, you might want to scrub off the stain on the surface with a nylon abrasive pad and liberal amounts of lacquer thinner. If you did not use a contrasting color, scrub off all the stain with a stiff bristle brush and lacquer thinner and start over.)

Pigment stain works perfectly with quartersawn wood as well, since the ray cells that form the stripes resist absorbing stain, so they, too, will stand out more after staining with a contrasting color, again assuming all the stain is wiped off the surface.

As for your other question, you can put oil based clear finish directly over any other finish, including waterbased acrylic, so there is no need for shellac or any other barrier coat between your stain and topcoat.

Re: How can I pop the grain after waterbased stain?

#13

Re: How can I pop the grain after waterbased stain

Fred Davis

>So how long were you going to hide that beauty Tony , outstanding grain and of course workmanship as well.

FredD

Re: How can I pop the grain after waterbased stain?

#14

Ellis Walentine

I can imagine...

Ellis Walentine

>... a tutorial or design discussion on ways to finish quartersawn oak. There must be a million ways, including several of Stickley's experimental finishes.

Thanks, Michael, for your input.

Ellis