Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Anybody check out the Cyclones on Ebay? *LINK*

Posts

Anybody check out the Cyclones on Ebay? *LINK*

#1

Dominic in Bucks County PA

Anybody check out the Cyclones on Ebay? *LINK*

Dominic in Bucks County PA

>Has anyone seen these cyclones being sold on Ebay? I'm seriously thinking about pulling the trigger on this. I have a shop built one that needs to be seriously modified in order to work with the blower I have. Plus, it looks like it was welded by Bam-bam on a bad day! So I'm thinking that one of these, plus the 3hp 2300cfm blower and filter cartridge might be a good combo.


Cyclone on Ebay

Re: Anybody check out the Cyclones on Ebay? *LINK*

#2

Re: Anybody check out the Cyclones on Ebay?

Joanne near Dansville, NY

>I bought this cyclone when I was setting up my dust collector system a couple years ago. The cyclone was well made and works well.

There was an article in Wood Magazine several years ago (that is how I found out about them)..... I saved the article to look at in more detail when I got to the point of setting up my whole shop dust collector.

Re: Anybody check out the Cyclones on Ebay? *LINK*

#3

Re: Anybody check out the Cyclones on Ebay?

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

>There have been a number of threads about those cyclones on various forums.

They appear to be well constructed, but are NOT well designed nor as efficient separating the dust as one built using Bill Pentz's design and many commercial units. I can't say for sure but they appear to use the old Wood Magazine design. They do not have optimal cylinder and cone dimensions, do not have slanted inlets, do not have a spiral inlet ramp, and in fact the last I heard had no neutral vane whatsoever. All of these are features of a well designed cyclone. When I queried the seller about the absence of a neutral vane his response was akin to "don't need one of those vane things, whatever they are." If some of these terms are unfamiliar to you, check out Bill Pentz's web site. I suspect the seller is a metal bender and not an engineer. I base this on the design and his comments about arbitrarily changing inlet and outlet sizes.

Will it work, to some degree, yes, it will separate out the chips, but based on the design may have a hard time with fine particles, and may add resistance and reduce overall collection at the tool. Are there much better designs out there- yes, MUCH better. Is it cheap? Sort of, when compared to most cyclone only designs (remember you are getting the cyclone only no motor/blower unit, no filter, no stand, etc.,) but you get what you pay for. They are MUCH more expensive than building one yourself from 26 ga. sheet metal and some MDF (about $65) using the Pentz design.