Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

OT Vehicle maintenance

Posts

OT Vehicle maintenance

#1

Clint Searl

OT Vehicle maintenance

Clint Searl

>My wife's '06 Jeep has 46,000 miles on it with no sign of any engine or power train problem. When she took it in for inspection and oil&filter change, they "recommended" new plugs, new differential fluids, and new air cleaner to the tune of over $400. Of course, they made it sound like the car would drop dead within a week if the work didn't get done. She insisted that the differential and air cleaner had to be taken care of, but I was able to resist the spark plug swap. Admitting to little knowledge or interest in car stuff, but still able to smell a ripe fish, I'd like to hear this group's thoughts on the experience.

Clint

Re: OT Vehicle maintenance

#2

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: OT Vehicle maintenance

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

>Did she take it to a Jeep dealer, or an 'independent?'

What does the owners' manual say? Most times, the differential fluid is pretty much a 'lifetime' deal. It probably did need the air cleaner, though.

As for plugs - again, what does the Owners' Manual say? Some cars don't need new plugs for 6-~100K miles. My Subaru manual says plugs at 60K miles, the Toyota says 75K. YMMV...

Another sad situation: With car sales (and especially Chrysler/Jeep sales) in the crapper, dealers are trying to make up for it with up-selling service items. Beware of that!

Jim D.

Re: OT Vehicle maintenance

#3

Re: OT Vehicle maintenance

Dave Paine

>If you have never replaced the air filter, at 46,000 miles, this is way overdue. It will not cause the car to drop dead, but it should be impacting fuel efficiency.

I replaced my air filter earlier in the year. I just removed to inspect, and it was in dire need to clean out the many seeds and other debris which was building up.

Look in the manual for recommended replacement of fluids and plugs.

Spark plugs have greatly improved. Gone are the days of replacing every few thousand miles. My Subaru Outback manual states replace spark plugs at 60 months or 60,000 miles, which ever comes first.

Re: OT Vehicle maintenance

#4

Re: OT Vehicle maintenance

Nat Robison

>As others stated, check your manual but many late-model vehicles go 100k miles before needing new plugs, changing anti-freeze, etc. The air filter should probably be done every 10k-20k depending on how dirty yours gets. Most are $15-$25 at auto parts stores and are easy to swap.

In my opinion, one of the easiest ways to save money is to learn to do your own basic auto maintenance..........changing fluids and filters, lightbulbs, etc. Any trip to the dealer is going to set you back $80 just for driving in.

Re: OT Vehicle maintenance

#5

JL

An air cleaner is like a furnace filter..

JL

>When I lived in San Diego county, I replaced my air filter about every 6000-10,000 miles.

Re: OT Vehicle maintenance

#6

Spark plugs... another angle

Grant in Iowa

>Many of todays vehicles have a service interval of 100,000 miles on the spark plugs. These are often the Platinum tipped plugs.

My mechanic (and lifelong friend) says two problems with this:

1. the platinum tips are for extended logevity, at the expense of performance and, by some claims fuel mileage.

2. Many of the vehicles that use these 100,000 mile plugs also have aluminum heads. If you wait the 100,000 miles, you may have a stuck plug in the head, requiring difficult removal and rethreading.

He advises to wait no longer than 50,000 miles no matter what the claim in the manual says if it has aluminum heads.

I cannot see replacing an air filter unless it looked dirty, but that is just me.

I change differential fluid in my pickup at about 60,000 miles, but then I do a fair amount of towing (all that lumber, dontchaknow). I'd consult the manual on this and increase the interval on a vehicle that does towing.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa

Re: OT Vehicle maintenance

#7

Jesper, Denmark

Re: OT Vehicle maintenance

Jesper, Denmark

>All of those come under the preventive maitenance heading, and basically are not a bad idea. All are also easy to perform yourself, if you dont mind lying on your back to change the diff fluid.

If you are not auto-mechanically inclined, you may have a son-in-law or somebody's boyfriend that is and would help you out an hour or two, just to show off.

I do not know about Jeeps, but on some of the newer cars, the plugs are a bitch to get to.

Re: OT Vehicle maintenance

#8

Clint Searl

Re: OT Vehicle maintenance

Clint Searl

>Thanks for the responses. It's obvious that dealerships in particular make every attempt to generate service business, whether it's needed or not. IMO, for the kind of driving this Jeep gets, none of the add-on work was called for, nor will it "prevent" any future problem. If it's broke, fix it; if it ain't let it be.

Clint

Re: OT Vehicle maintenance

#9

Re: OT Vehicle maintenance

Tony - Memphis

>I think that much/most of the car maintenance stuff is myth. I worked in the aftermarket biz for many years, so I have a skewed prespective on what they try and sell. Like the 3000 mile oil change! I have a 2001 S10 truck. I change the oil once a year. I clean the air filter at the same time. I've never changed the plugs over the 107k miles. I've never changed any other fluid on it. The coolant was mostly drained when I replaced the radiator a few months ago. It still gets exactly the same mileage I got when it was new (I keep a spreadsheet). I did pretty much the same on the last truck. It had 160k on it when I sold it and it was driven for several years after that. The people that bought it did zero maint. to it. Last time my wife took the Z in for an oil change (I let them do it while it was under warranty - plus, its a pita and they only charge $20 and she takes care of it) they tried to sell her new rotors when she asked abotu pad replacement. I let them change the pads before because they only charged $90 and the pads cost $67 - each set!. I told her to say no thanks and I just did them myself - actually very easy on this car. One time, they tried to sell her a tire rotation and alignment and you can't rotate the tires on a Z! Etc. etc. Its finny how they giive us good deals on some things, then try and hose you on others. We called around when she was stranded at work with a bad battery and the dealer actually had the best deal on the battery -installed even. Go figure. Don't get me started on the Chevrolet dealer! My next ride won't be one, that's for sure.

Tony

Re: OT Vehicle maintenance

#10

Tony, thought you were praising your Chevys.

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

>Low maintenance, plenty of miles, consistent mileage. What's the big problem?

Re: OT Vehicle maintenance

#11

Re: Tony, thought you were praising your Chevys.

Tony - Memphis

>There have been lots of other issues. And the worst part of it has been the lack of support or capability of the dealer service dept. You are correct though, there are several points I cannot complain about. The truck still looks pretty good too. The paint has held up well, the interior still looks good, etc. That's all great, but then the ABS system went kaput after 6 years and they want $1800 to repair it. I replaced the cheap parts myself, but it still doesn't work. Air pump went out, window scrapers came off (both doors), instrument cluster quit working, battery cable corroded away, heater core plugged up, fuel gage isn't calibrated correctly, mass air flow sensor failed, etc. etc. And none of these were unique to my truck. I'm just glad I am able to do my own repairs. I can't imagine what folks who can't would have spent on this truck! I should have known better after the first S10, but I got such a good deal via our corporate discount program, that I got sucked in. And, the S10 package was the perfect size, price, etc. for me.

Tony

Re: OT Vehicle maintenance

#12

Re: Garbage Motors

Brian in Brighton

>Tony, Sounds like a common theme with many Chevy owners I know. The engines can be good, depending on the one you get, but everything else in the car is junk. I've known 3 fellas with Cadillac STS's and they had many problems with stuff like you mention. Not to mention the electronic shocks at $800 a corner.

BTW: I change the oil on my F-150 every 5000 miles and it has 225,000 and counting. It could not go for a year with one oil change as it would eventually run out of oil. It burns about 1 qt every 5000 miles and still gets 17mpg and flies thru emissions testing. So, something I'm doing must be right.

Brian in Brighton

Re: OT Vehicle maintenance

#13

Re: Garbage Motors

Tony - Memphis

>Kind of sad. I wish they would step up. Patrt of me wants to keep driving Chevy's (of course they quit making small trucks, so I would have to go to another brand anyway). Oh, my '54 Chevy changes its own oil! My brother in law has an S15 that has close to 200k on it, but the list of repairs required to get that is huge! It seems silly to me - the engine runs fine after 107k but the windshield wipers won't "park" if its cold out. Geez. I just read that Toyota is having to do a recall. I just don't know what to buy anymore. Hopefully, the S10 will continue to roll for a while. I'm spoiled with not having a car note.

Tony

Re: OT Vehicle maintenance

#14

Chevy quit making small trucks?

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

>They still make the S-10, Colorado and Silverado.

I've had to replace the rotors on my 2000 Silverado, but that's all. My neighbor had to replace his brake lines due to rust on his 2002 S-10. But he's had no other problems.

At least it's not being recalled 'cause the frames rust through in 5 years.

By the way, what are the "window scrapers" that came off both doors of your truck?