Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Garage heating - - user question

Posts

Garage heating - - user question

#1

Garage heating - - user question

Pete in Holland, MI

>Hi guys -

Have an uninsulated garage (walls & ceiling) 24' square, 10' to the bottom of the open rafters.

A few times per winter, I need to work in the garage to fix the car or something. 4-8 hours a few days per month. Outside temperature here in Michigan dips into the teens (F) most of the time, but can drop below zero on occasion. Don't need to bring it up to room temp, but only to be tolerable, say; 60F or so.

Radiant gas heat is probably my best choice. Sheeting in and insuating the facility makes sense, but is not an option, nor cost feesible for the little I use the garage in the winter.

Anybody have a situation similar to mine?

What have you done & been successful at?

Thanks !

Pete

Re: Garage heating - - user question

#2

Re: Garage heating - - user question

Nat Robison

>I'm on the other side of the state from you in the Detroit area but my grandparents had a cottage in Holland.

Anyway, I have a similar situation. To finish the entire garage isn't in the budget yet so I'm insulating and finishing with 10-ft. tongue & groove boards bought at Lowe's. I buy 3 or 4 boards a week, stain them and nail them up. Hopefully, I'll be finished in the next year. It costs me about $12-$15/week.

Regardless of what you do, it would seem you need to at least finish/insulate the ceiling to help keep the heat in. Otherwise, you'd just be helping to melt the snow on your roof, right?

Re: Garage heating - - user question

#3

Re: Garage heating - - user question

Bill Wilkinson from Montreal

>Boards are probably fine as you wish, but I would go with 6-mil polyethylene behind drywall - you cannot get much cheaper than gypsum, and the poly air-barrier would hold heated air in and prevent leakage.

Now that I think about it, the poly would be less of a benefit behind the drywall than behind the wood boards - less leakage already.

I still would probably throw insulation behind in the walls as I do it, but I have an aversion to removing something I have already done to put the insulation back in. Fiberglass (4") is cheap and easy too. It all depends on your budget and expected use - will you EVER need to insulate - then do it now. better than ripping the old wall surface down later and replacing it in a few years. You can always add insulation in the attic without ripping down the ceiling.

Good luck.

Re: Garage heating - - user question

#4

Re: Garage heating - - user question

Pete in Holland, MI

>Thanks for the feedback thus far, and I fully understand the benefits of insulation & sheeting in the walls.

I am only interested though in hearing from folks with a building like mine and what their experiences are.

Again, I want to heat it for 1-2 afternoons a month to take the edge off of working on the cars, then let it go cold the rest of the time.

Cost to drywall, insulate, create several trap doors to access the attic & all the seasonal stuf, replace the 16' tin garage door, and re-do all my heavy stud-mounted shelving will allow me to spend $20-40 per month for 4 months out of the year for years before I break even on the project.

Thanks !

Pete

Re: Garage heating - - user question

#5

JL

Forced air propane heater - aka Hotdog?

JL

>Would that work for your application? You would need ventilation, but it would get it warm really fast.

Just a thought. They run from $100-200.

Re: Garage heating - - user question

#6

Kerosene

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Hi Pete,

Up until a couple of months ago I worked all winter in an unfinished, uninsulated shop. Exposed studs, no ceiling, old rickety drafty windows. It was bad. The shop is 18x20. I used a torpedo kerosene heater for about 8 years, and then a couple of years ago I bought a radiant kerosene heater. The radiant was much better than the torpedo. Less noise, less humidity on the cast iron tools too. It really made the place toasty and comfortable. I'm in central Indiana so my temps are probably not as consistantly cold as yours, but last winter we dipped to -12. Pretty chilly. It's a cheep way to heat your shop and heats up quick too. I averaged about $75 a winter on Kerosene. It drifts between $3.50 and $4.50 a gallon mid winter. I get it at local gas stations. A tank (probably a gallon and half?) in the radiant heater would last about 8 hrs. I got the heater at Lowes in mid summer on clearance for $69. It sells right now for about $130.

Stay Warm!

Jen

Re: Garage heating - - user question

#7

Re: Garage heating - - user question

Dan Donaldson

>I have a similar situation. I hung a 220 volt 4 foot radiant heater (the kind with the quartz tubes) from the rafters. It doesn't heat the air, but under it and for a reasonable distance around, it is fairly comfortable to work. It gets the bench warm and after a bit I can work without a coat.

Re: Garage heating - - user question

#8

Re: Garage heating - - user question

Barry Irby

>I have both a torpedo propane heater and an infrared one that mounts on a propane tank. Both are about 40,000 BTU. Either will run me out of my small shop in a matter of minutes. My shop is 14 x 22 and insulated and has a loose garage door. On cold days I run the infra-red for maybe fifteen minutes and then run a small electric "barn" heater to keep it tempered. Both heat quickly and get to be uncomfortable quickly in my shop. One distinction is that the torpedo is noisy and requires electricity. The other one is quieter and does not require electricity. If you have the electricity I would look at an electric radiant heater. Quiet, no moisture output.

Re: Garage heating - - user question

#9

Re: Garage heating - - user question

davhamm

>If your garage door is not insulated don't bother with the other walls, just get a heater big enough to heat the space, turn it on a bit before you want to go out. Just remember the cars will hold their cold for a long time.

Re: Garage heating - - user question

#10

Re: Garage heating - - user question

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

>I heat my 20x20 shop with a single Lee Valley 120v quartz heater. LV has recently reintroduced such a heater to their catalog after a few years absence. Aim the heater so that it heats the floor near where you'll be working. Electric is nice, no fuel to store, no venting of combustion fumes, and extremely portable.

Re: Garage heating - - user question

#11

Re: Garage heating - - user question

Bill White

>Whatever you decide, get a carbon monoxide detector. I don't use a combustion heater in my shop at all. I find 'em too risky. I've had great success with the oil-filled radiators because my shop in insulated.

Bill

Re: Garage heating - - user question

#12

Thanks all !

Pete in Holland, MI

>

Re: Garage heating - - user question

#13

Thanks all ! !

Pete in Holland, MI

>