Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Which Shoulder Plane - Lie-Neilson or Veritas

Posts

Which Shoulder Plane - Lie-Neilson or Veritas

#1

Which Shoulder Plane - Lie-Neilson or Veritas

Jerry Samsen

>So I am asking for a medium sized shoulder plane for Christmas but don't know which one to ask for -- the Lie-Nielson or the Veritas.

I see the Veritas has some features that the Lie-Nielson does not have but also really want to own a Lie-Nielson (it would be my first!).

And opinions?

Re: Which Shoulder Plane - Lie-Neilson or Veritas

#2

Re: Which Shoulder Plane - Lie-Neilson or Veritas

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Jerry,

I've posted a message on the hand tool forum letting folks know about your question, so they can offer opinions. I myself don't have enough miles on mine (a Record, on which the big Lie-Nielsen is based, and a Veritas) to feel confident in my opinions.

As a moderator of that forum, let me invite you to come visit - you might well find yourself on a slippery slope to owning more planes, handsaws, etc., than you realized you needed.

Bill

Re: Which Shoulder Plane - Lie-Neilson or Veritas

#3

As a denizen of the quiet side and

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>an owner of the Veritas medium shoulder plane, I really have to endorse the LV medium model. It is one superb tool. That funny-looking knob on the back will absolutely amaze you, too. It provides a way of getting a better grip than you would have imagined possible. Mine came with the A2 blade, which holds an edge for a very long time. The set screws on either side of the blade also ensure that it holds the position you set.

The only caveat is that I've not held or used the LN model. I'm sure it's good, but I'm so satisfied with Rob Lee's plane that I see no reason to even try the competition.

Bruce

Re: Which Shoulder Plane - Lie-Neilson or Veritas

#4

Re:Consult Handplane Essentials

North of the Border

>by Christoper Schwarz 2009. It just came out and if you decide to go into hand planing, that should be reference book for you, too. He tried to be as impartial as he can in comparing handplanes.

Re: Which Shoulder Plane - Lie-Neilson or Veritas

#5

Re: As a denizen of the quiet side and

Jim Toews - Walla Walla, WA

>I second what Bruce said. I have never laid hands on the Lie-Neilson, but I own the full line of Veritas shoulder planes and highly recommend them. They are used on virtually every project I make and always are a pleasure to use.

Re: Which Shoulder Plane - Lie-Neilson or Veritas

#6

Ergonomic disaster

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Are you buying this thing to look at, or use?

If there is a way to comfortably hold the LN plane I have not found it. I have the large one (its mass and hence inertia have advantages to be considered) and I use it only when I have to. Its not something you will carry around because it feels so nice in the hand.

I have not held the LV plane but it would seem that the the design engineers took into consideration the ill suited shape of the LN plane.

Re: Which Shoulder Plane - Lie-Neilson or Veritas

#7

not necessarily so!

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Some of us keep a leash fastened to the table saw that provides traction to resist the slide. (sorry, couldn't resist)

Re: Which Shoulder Plane - Lie-Neilson or Veritas

#8

JL

I want the really small one.. *LINK*

JL

>The Miniature Shoulder plane that Lee Valley has. The LOML thinks it is "cute", so I'll probably get it for Xmas.


Miniature Shoulder Plane

Re: Which Shoulder Plane - Lie-Neilson or Veritas

#9

Re: I want the really small one..

Thomas S Stockton

>Oh great something else to slip in my pocket and send through the wash

Tom

Re: Which Shoulder Plane - Lie-Neilson or Veritas

#10

Re: Ergonomic disaster - LV is not...

Glenn Madsen

>The Medium from Veritas has been a comfortable and useful plane for me in hand tool work. There's no reason not to use one.

LN planes are wonderful, but their block planes are the ones I started with and love. The LV, not quite as much.

Not all things need to come from the same source...

Re: Which Shoulder Plane - Lie-Neilson or Veritas

#11

Re: Which Shoulder Plane - Lie-Neilson or Veritas

Jerry Samsen

>Thanks.

I'm impartial to hand tool vs power tool. I use whatever tool is most appropriate.

My use for a shoulder plane is primarily for tweaking tenons. I'm tired of the rasp / file / sandpaper approach and had the opportunity to use briefly a LN shoulder plane and it was so effortless. Just trying to decide if LN or Veritas is better -- although probably both good although if a tie, I will lean toward the LN because.....ah....well...ok, I want a LN tool in my shop...

Re: Which Shoulder Plane - Lie-Neilson or Veritas

#12

Re: I want the really small one..

Dan Donaldson

>Ditto here. I have the LN #1 for the same reason. Lori thought it was cute. so......

Re: Which Shoulder Plane - Lie-Neilson or Veritas

#13

Re: Which Shoulder Plane - Lie-Neilson or Veritas

Jim Dillon

>This is a fifth(?) vote for the LV-Veratis shoulder plane. I am a hand tool klutz big time, but about 4 years ago I got the medium LV shoulder plane and that tool is great. I'm sure the L-N shoulder plane is superb as well, but for excellent value and innovative design, I don't think you can beat Veratis. Maybe Santa will bring me that cute Veratis small shoulder plane. My 2 cents.

Jim

Re: Which Shoulder Plane - Lie-Neilson or Veritas

#14

No wrong answer here....

Jesse Cloud

>The good news is that they are both superb tools. I own the medium LV, but have used the medium LN as well. Both are a delight to use. Never saw a need for anything bigger than the medium.

I use them for tweaking tenons and rabbets.

Only caution I might add is that LN occasionally goes out of stock, more often than LV in my experience. I would check their web sites just to see if they are in stock if I really wanted it in time for Christmas.

Re: Which Shoulder Plane - Lie-Neilson or Veritas

#15

tweaking tenons

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>There was a discussion of this topic on the hand tool Forum recently. It seemed to be I was the only one tweaking with a shoulder plane. Many thought there were better tools for the task.

The large plane works fine for tenon tweaking. Its mass is advantageous for this task. It is why I bought such a plane and it has led to perfect tenons.

Re: Which Shoulder Plane - Lie-Neilson or Veritas

#16

Re: tweaking tenons

ThomD

>Though one wonders from the whole shoulder thing, whether it was meant for the tenons at all?

Re: Which Shoulder Plane - Lie-Neilson or Veritas

#17

Re: Ergonomic disaster - when used wrong

ThomD

>This comes down to the whole using a shoulder plane to adjust a tenon. The LN is a shoulder plane, so the handle is way up there so that one can keep the fingers that make the whole process so easy. But this is awkward for tenons, on which one can really use a block plane since nobody sees the tenon anyway. So the LN is from the craft and the admirable LVs are post modern.

Now in the power tool world I use the TS or jointer to get tight tenons, no fiddling required.

Re: Which Shoulder Plane - Lie-Neilson or Veritas

#18

Re: Which Shoulder Plane - Lie-Neilson or Veritas *LINK*

Victor Parisian

>I prefer my Clifton to the others. Maybe it is just set up a tad better.


clifton shoulder plane

Re: Which Shoulder Plane - Lie-Neilson or Veritas

#19

Re: Ergonomic disaster - when used wrong

Fred Davis

>I use a Record Bullnose plane to tweak tenons when the occasion arises , the size is just right for one hand operation and cuts right up to the Tenon shoulder.

FredD

Re: Which Shoulder Plane - Lie-Neilson or Veritas

#20

Re: I want the really small one..

charlie belden

>From a functional standpoint the LN & LV shoulder planes, at least the medium shoulder planes, are essentially the same. The attached photos and text show that they don't work the same way.

Ergonomically they're significantly different, especially when used on their sides - for planing the SHOULDERS of a tenon. There may be a reason why LN illustrates the use of their shoulder plane - trimming the cheeks of a tenon - and no pictures of it being used to trim up the shoulders of a tenon - the primary purpose of this type of plane. Wonder why?

Then there's the often overlooked thing about hand planes - and any other cutting tool. If the cutting tool is easy to remove, sharpen and replace - where it needs to be - it'll probably be sharpened as soon as it begins to dull. If it's a hassle to remove it and replace and reset it - it's cutting edge is less apt to be removed for touch up or sharpening. And a dull cutting tool is often going to cause more trouble than the problem it is intended to fix.

The LV large shoulder plane is $18 more than the large LN shoulder plane. The extra $18 will seem quite a deal once you use the Veritas - and an absolute steal when you take the iron out to touch it up or sharpen it - then replace it.

LV's Veritas - hands down - IMHO. Pretty is nice - but function should come first.

ps: I've got and have used the LV medium shoulder plane as well as the Clifton 3110 which is similar to the LN configuration. The latter has some pretty sharp corners in places where you're apt to encounter them with fingertips. Not comfortable.


img

Re: Which Shoulder Plane - Lie-Neilson or Veritas

#21

Contrary opinion a

Raney

>I have the medium veritas, and a large LN. I actually prefer the LN ergonomics slightly. The LV is indeed more ingenious, but I don't really find the rear knob all that comfortable between the webbing of my thumb and forefinger... the LN/record/preston design has been 'the' shoulder plane of choice for over a century for a reason - it is very comfortable to use, and keeps the wrist directly above the plane, whereas the veritas wants the wrist lower, more like a pistol grip. Because of this, I find it somewhat easier to judge plumb with the LN.

The truth is that I think they're both very comfortable to use and excellent performers -- you really can't go wrong with either. But it sounds like you want the LN, so I figured you'd like to hear that not everyone prefers the LV ergonomics.

Re: Which Shoulder Plane - Lie-Neilson or Veritas

#22

Reasons for getting the LV

charlie belden

>I inadvertently posted my reasons under

"I want the really small one".

Sorry about that.

Re: Which Shoulder Plane - Lie-Neilson or Veritas

#23

Re: Which Shoulder Plane - Lie-Neilson or Veritas

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I've got 3 shoulder planes, way more than I need since I typically neaten up shoulders with a chisel these days - to make the outer shoulder longer than the inner for neat closure. My small one is a LN after Preston, very small, only problem is that often the humidity mucks up the wedge and it won't set properly; so I wait for dryer days. I don't know if they still sell this one, sure don't see it in their online catalog.

My middle one is an HNT Gordon, which is also very nice, no problems, except that I never use it. My large is the LN, which I use more for trimming the tenons than the shoulders. It's very good, but again, I just don't use it for shoulders.

The tiny LV is very attractive, but it's even demonstrated in the LV site as a dado plane, not a shoulder.

So, take your pick, they're all good and all more or less unnecessary for shoulders. Much better to practice sawing to a line so you don't need to neaten up the shoulders.

Pam

Re: Which Shoulder Plane - Lie-Neilson or Veritas

#24

Re: Which Shoulder Plane - Lie-Neilson or Veritas

Bob Entwisle in NJ

>I was able to try both the LN and LV out at a show and found that the LV fit my hands better than the LN.

The LN sure is pretty to look at though.

Re: Which Shoulder Plane - Lie-Neilson or Veritas

#25

IIRC, it's stainless steel...

Alexander Grigoriev

>