Re: Which Shoulder Plane - Lie-Neilson or Veritas
Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX
>I've got 3 shoulder planes, way more than I need since I typically neaten up shoulders with a chisel these days - to make the outer shoulder longer than the inner for neat closure. My small one is a LN after Preston, very small, only problem is that often the humidity mucks up the wedge and it won't set properly; so I wait for dryer days. I don't know if they still sell this one, sure don't see it in their online catalog.
My middle one is an HNT Gordon, which is also very nice, no problems, except that I never use it. My large is the LN, which I use more for trimming the tenons than the shoulders. It's very good, but again, I just don't use it for shoulders.
The tiny LV is very attractive, but it's even demonstrated in the LV site as a dado plane, not a shoulder.
So, take your pick, they're all good and all more or less unnecessary for shoulders. Much better to practice sawing to a line so you don't need to neaten up the shoulders.
Pam