Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Another Jointer Question; Nothing is Simple

Posts

Another Jointer Question; Nothing is Simple

#1

Another Jointer Question; Nothing is Simple

John Foster

>Hello again; thanks for all the previous responses to my 8" jointer questions. One more curious one now, in my previous post I mentioned that an 8" General jointer was coming up for auction in my small town( if you are interested in what else he has ,go to auctionsfind.com and see the listing for a sale in Drayton Nov. 28th, 2009). Anyway last night I stopped by the shop and had a look at the machine, and got the following story, which baffled me. He told me that he had put a couple of shims on the outfeed ways to bring the table up perfectly level. He told me that jointers are not normally set up perfectly level, because traditional woodworkers prefer a slightly concave edge on their boards for a better glue joint. He says he likes a perfectly straight edge so he chose to shim up the outfeed table. I have never heard of this, and now slightly question his knowledge and his integrity. It was a commercial shop, and the machine was purchased new in 1998. thanks John

Re: Another Jointer Question; Nothing is Simple

#2

Re: Another Jointer Question; Nothing is Simple

Virgil Johnson

>A jointer is a pretty simple machine.Unless he beat the crap out of it pull the shims out and it will be the same as new if it does not suit you. Look for obvious signs of neglect, rust, hammer marks, etc. Face a board on it, do an edge joint and if your are happy with the results bid away to the price your are willing to pay. I have no idea how flat and parallel the tables are on my 8" jointer. All I care about is the end result.

Re: Another Jointer Question; Nothing is Simple

#3

Ellis Walentine

Shims are routine fixes

Ellis Walentine

>As I mentioned in my earlier post, all that matters is that the tables are flat -- you can shim them coplanar if need be. That apparently is what these folks did. If the result is a nice flat, coplanar jointer, that's all that matters.

The business about them manufacturing the machine to throw the outfeed table slightly out of coplanar on purpose sounds fishy to me, but it's still okay to shim the ways of any wedge-bed jointer as needed to line things up perfectly. It's very easy to do, too.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Another Jointer Question; Nothing is Simple

#4

Re: Another Jointer Question; Nothing is Simple

Barry Irby

>He's right about the slightly concave joints. It was described to me many years ago as "shot hollow". The edges of the boards are very slightly concave, maybe a few 1/1000's or a couple of 1/100'spending on the length. Difficult to see if you site the board but apparent if you lay two side by side. Allows the center clamp to apply pressure over the entire length and you may be able to use fewer clamps.

A 1998 jointer is not very old and unless it has had a hard life, it's got a lot left to give. Go for it unless it is beaten to crap.

Re: Another Jointer Question; Nothing is Simple

#5

JL

Re: Another Jointer Question; Nothing is Simple

JL

>Shimming the beds is typical as Ellis said. Not having flat coplanar beds on purpose is hooey. IMO, he is blowing smoke with that. If you want something "out of line" - you make a jig or put a shim on the board - you don't do it to the equipment.

That being said - you're buying the machine - not the smoke. If the machine is sound and in good repair - definitely consider it.

Re: Another Jointer Question; Nothing is Simple

#6

As usual, JL is right on the money here

Grant in Iowa

>The guy has either been misled, or is trying to justify why shims had to be added (as if it needs justified). I have never heard of a jointer sold that way...heck, they'd be doing good just to deliver them coplanar most of the time, let alone slightly convex.

If a user wants the slightly sprung (concave) joint, then it can be easily achieved by technique while jointing, or by setting the knives ever so slightly high in relation to the outfeed table. No need to build a machine specially to achieve that.

If you bid and win the machine, try it with his shims in place, and only if you are unhappy would I remove them. This simply follows the rule "don't fix it if it aint broke".

You might also have a look at any adjustments for the ways to see if maybe something is loose, resulting in a need to shim. It may be that it needed shimmed for a reason other than why he stated.

do note that an 8" jointer is usually 300+ lbs, and I'm guessing the General might be heavier yet. Keep that in mind when planning to move it.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa

Re: Another Jointer Question; Nothing is Simple

#7

Re: Another Jointer Question; Nothing is Simple

Jim Dillon

>John,

Although I have not found the need for shims on my General (ignorance is bliss 8-)), from what I have read, shimming is not unusual in order to achieve in- and out-feed tables coplanar with each other. Regarding his explanation though for doing it, I am dubious. I certainly wouldn't want a jointer set up to cut a slight concave surface on everything I do. Maybe they just used it for edge jointing for table tops or wide panels which might make more sense - at least in a production shop. In any case, if the jointer looks in good shape, and your can get it for a good price (compared to a new one), I think it would be worthwhile. A 1998 model is "brand-new" IMHO. If you desire a "spring joint", then adapting your jointing technique (less pressure at the start, then more in the middle) will work.

Jim

Re: Another Jointer Question; Nothing is Simple

#8

Re: Another Jointer Question; Nothing is Simple

Jesse Cloud

>Agree with the advice above. I have shims on several pieces of machinery in my shop. Try a board on the jointer, better still edge joint two boards and see how they fit together. If the outcome is good, don't sweat the details.

Not sure what the market for used tools is like in your area, but here we usually pay about 50% of retail unless it is really something special. May be more or less in your area.

Re: Another Jointer Question; Nothing is Simple

#9

Re: Another Jointer Question; Nothing is Simple

Jim Dillon

>John,

I meant to say "...less pressure at the start and end...". Gosh Ellis, we really need an editing capability; at least I sure do 8-).

Jim

Re: Another Jointer Question; Nothing is Simple

#10

nothing to worry about

Chris Friesen

>General produces solid equipment. If it's a real General as opposed to General International then it was made in Canada. Their new 8" jointer goes for around $3000 depending where you find it.

With standard dovetailed-way jointers it's not unusual to shim them, so I wouldn't worry about that. You can adjust that after purchase if you think it needs work.

As for his mention of drooping outfeed tables, I actually _have_ heard of people intentionally putting their jointer slightly out of parallel. This allows them to create a sprung edge joint. It's actually mentioned in a FWW article called "Jointer Talk". (www.finewoodworking.com/FWNPDF/011055072.pdf)

Incidentally, the Poitras equipment mentioned at that auction is also made in Canada. They were bought out by General in the late 80s. Good solid tools.

Re: Another Jointer Question; Nothing is Simple

#11

Re: nothing to worry about

Fred Davis

>Chris is right about people (some that is) actually springing the joint , the reasoning being given was that prevented the ends of panel glue ups from developing a open glue joint.

I always thought that was a bunch of crap , since you really want to avoid locking stresses into a glue up.

If your skill level and machine doesn't give you a glue joint that is perfectly closed without clamping pressure after the machine is setup to run stright edges, you need to practice some more rather then meddle with the jointer.

On the other hand jointers do need adjustment occasionally, some more then others , especially after a fresh knife install, but Manufacturers actually making one to give a concave joint is a fairy tale I do believe.

FredD

Re: Another Jointer Question; Nothing is Simple

#12

Agreed...

John in NM

>Seems to me its more cost efficient to learn to vary technique with the jointer or take a couple swipes with a hand plane to make a sprung joint.

Its funny, I always hear about shimming, but I've never needed to do it on the 6 or so standard design jointers I've used/maintained over the years. I can usually seem to get away with simple gib adjustment, never occurred to me to use a shim.

Re: Another Jointer Question; Nothing is Simple

#13

Re: nothing to worry about

Chris Friesen

>I believe the rationale for springing the joint is that if the humidity drops the ends will lose moisture faster than the middle of the board, thus causing the ends of the joints to want to open.

If you create some initial stress in the joint, the long middle section of the joint is plenty strong and will tend to keep the ends tightly shut.

In most cases that I've seen springing recommended, it's only a very slight amount--several thou perhaps--and I can't see that causing any problems.

Re: Another Jointer Question; Nothing is Simple

#14

Re: nothing to worry about

Fred Davis

>I must be lucky Chris , never sprung a joint and to my knowledge never had a end joint open up.

Following the notion that the middle of the joint needs to be concave regardless of how little , sure would be silly with say flooring ,wide panels glue ups and so on..

I have been around the woodworking community for a long time and never have yet seen a request or recommendation to plane a wow in a board edge ,based on some theoretical concept that had yet to appear in reality

On the other hand I have seen quite a few people struggle with dry fitting a glue up so that it requires only a modicum of clamp pressure to be invisible .

They need practice....

FredD