Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

A question for the Computer Literate OT

Posts

A question for the Computer Literate OT

#1

A question for the Computer Literate OT

Barry Irby

>I have two older computers and my son has a third. We have taken them all to a shop we have dealt with for maybe twenty years. All have come back in worse shape than when they went. Hard drives in at least to cases failed. Replaced the hard drive in one and reached the other two. The guy in the shop says Microsoft is doing it. That they are sending out some sort of patch or automatic update to all the computers with XP and killing them off to force people to buy new computers and switch to Version 7.

I know there are plenty of people that love to hate Microsoft and Windows, but I can not believe such a thing is true. OTOH, the only thing that I can think of that causes all three of my computers to crap out at the same time it, CRAP Happens. Any thoughts?

Re: A question for the Computer Literate OT

#2

Bart Goldberg

Find a New Repair Shop!

Bart Goldberg

>

Re: A question for the Computer Literate OT

#3

JL

Ditto on the new repair shop.

JL

>That excuse doesn't fly. I am NOT a computer professional. I've got two machines that have been running quite well on XP for a few years.

That being said - hard drives do crash. That's why you back them up. That's why I really like flash drives. I can back up all of my sensitive and changing stuff on a rotating basis.

The following things come to mind:

Environment - is the environment dirty or dusty? Are there pets shedding fur and dander in, on and around the machine?

Electrical - is the power supply conditioned? Do you have a cheap surge surpressor and that is it? My former employer's "new" lab building had to redo a lot of the electrical when we made the building into a lab. It was a former industrial site that had really C%@))y power. Between the voltage fluctuations and spikes, we lost 3 computers after we moved in. I know you are a home inspector - have you monitored your power?

However, I am still most suspicious about the shop.

Re: A question for the Computer Literate OT

#4

Re: Ditto on the new repair shop.

Barry Irby

>I have not monitored the power. I know I should have a UPS connected to these machines, but I don't. OTOH both of the desk tops have been running here for years without problems. I just thought it freaky that both of them and the lap top crapped out with a few weeks of each other and got worse at the shop. If they had both or all died on the same day I would have thought it to be a power surge or lightning.

I am also getting really tired of all the conspiracy crap. My son went to Best Buy last night and bought a Sony laptop. They tell us that MCafee is worthless. (It's free from Comcast.) Their computers all come with free virus protection that much better. Kasperski (sp?) or Webroot something. They will install the first one for $69 and clean off all that other crap that slows the computer down (What??). So my son brings it home and try=is to install the Webroot thing himself. Apparently the machine already had Norton on it and it got tangled up in webroot. He has removed the Norton and is trying to remove the Webroot to start over, but it is hung up. What a bunch of crap.

How is anyone to know whether MCafee is worth a crap or not? Why would Comcast support a program that is worthless? Perhaps Comcast got an really good deal form McAfee. OTOH perhaps Best Buy got really good deal from those other two????

Too much to expect the thing to work out of the box????

Re: A question for the Computer Literate OT

#6

My thoughts

Howard Norman

>Barry, I think that you need someone else to repair your computers. Their arguments about Microsoft intentionally sabotaging older units doesn't pass the logic test.

I would recommend that you consider getting a UPS.

I am not a fan of McAfee or Norton anti virus programs. I have been using AVG Free on all of my computers for several years now. However, I am about to explore other free versions for the simple reason that AVG, on the last two new versions, have made it very difficult to find the free versions on their web sites.

Re: A question for the Computer Literate OT

#8

Re: A question for the Computer Literate OT

John McGaw

>As others have stated, your "repairman" is totally clueless. Run, do not walk, away from the shop and find another.

As for hard drives failing, I have five computers, four of which run 24X7. The other, a notebook is allowed to hibernate. Among the five there are 12 hard drives ranging from 160mB to 1gB. There are also three 200gB drives in portable enclosures used for offsite backup and two 1gB drives hung on the network. Overall, I've had one hard drive in stationary machines fail in the past five years. I've had two hard drives in an older notebook fail over about seven years. So, yes, hard drives do fail but if they are of good quality to begin with and are treated with a bit of respect a good number of years can be expected between failures.

In your case I would expect either 1) poor-quality drives or 2) power problems, or 3) bad environment (shock, vibration, heat, etc). But given the things you wrote about your repairman it may well be that there was nothing wrong with the drives -- I would be inclined to believe the opposite of anything he says.

Just my $0.02 worth, of course...

Re: A question for the Computer Literate OT

#9

ebd

Re: Ditto on the new repair shop.

ebd

>My qualifications are that I've worked in the field for more than 35 years before retireing, both as a hardware tech and a programmer/analyst.

First, NO Microsoft isn't sending out a Win-XP killing ap. What BS. And second,McAfee sucks just as much as Norton. Both are resource hogs, both are nearly impossible to remove cleanly, both do not play nice with other security software, and neither is especially effective. There's more but you get the idea.

To get rid of the crap on your son's new laptop you will either have to re-install the operating system and your aps or get something like RegSeeker (free) and try and find all registry entries that come from the program you are trying to remove. This can be tedious and unless you are very careful and know what you are doing it can be dangerous. I would say your best bet is just re-install.

Re: A question for the Computer Literate OT

#10

Re: A question for the Computer Literate OT

Jerry Nicholson

>That Microsoft conspiracy theory sounds like something from a Linux "fanboy" forum. I bet your computer shop guy believes that the moon landing in 1969 was all a hoax too ;-)

Jerry

Re: A question for the Computer Literate OT

#11

Re: Ditto on the new repair shop.

Tony - Memphis

>I work for a very large corporation. Our IT dept. is pretty uptight about all this stuff and they chose McAfee. I can't speak to whether it is any better (by whatever criteria), but I have not had any issues with it here at the office or at home. I did have Norton at home before they bought a license for those who access from home and Norton seemed to slow things down.

Tony

Re: A question for the Computer Literate OT

#12

PC's

IEW

>Nature of the beast!

Re: A question for the Computer Literate OT

#13

My opinion.....

chuck

>I used to take the computer to a repair shop but decided, on day, to learn how to repair them myself. it's the best route as there is no reliance on others. Once you get used to their nature fixing them is easy as pie.

Re: A question for the Computer Literate OT

#14

Re: A question for the Computer Literate OT

wilbur

>Some thoughts:

1. It doesn't have to be a lightning strike to give you a voltage surge big enough to fry your computers. A voltage surge would hit all at the same time, which may explain why all three of your computers went out at the same time.

2. How old are your "older" computers? Most computers are not built for much more than 5 years of service.

3. The guy in your shop is a moron. Even though the best thing that Microsoft could do to boost Windows 7 sales is make it so that everyone still running XP has to upgrade, even this Mac/Linux fanboy would not believe that Microsoft would do such a thing. Pharmaceuticals and investment banks, maybe, but not Microsoft. :@)

Re: A question for the Computer Literate OT

#15

Re: My opinion.....

Nat Robison

>We got a new desktop last winter and it came with 1 year of on-site repairs if anything went wrong. Anyway, the power supply blew during the summer and they sent someone out to repair it. I was very surprised how relatively simple everything was inside the CPU. It's literally a case of plugging everything in in the correct spot. He removed everything but the hard drive and reinstalled it along with the new power supply......took about 15 minutes and a screwdriver. Assuming your not actually repairing the defective modules, it's quite simple to get a replacement and plug it in.

Re: A question for the Computer Literate OT

#16

Re: A question for the Computer Literate OT

del schisler

>if they were reloaded with xp and not a bought copy or regester and cost $$$ It will come on with lot's of things first it will up date from ms with up date's Now here is where crap come's in it will not pass the WGA and a bit tag from the right side of the screen saying a bootleg copy of xp ? This can be got rig of and the comp will work But it take some doing Is this something that is happening ?? Also the screen will go black ? if so do a right mouse click and reset the desk top it will say none in the little window ? I won't go on tell i know a little information del

Re: A question for the Computer Literate OT

#17

Definitely way over five years old....

Barry Irby

>They did not all fail on the same day. The laptop crapped out several moths ago, saying Can not find operating system. The shop offered to replace the hard drive, but then the screen went bad (back light out?)

Then I took my computer, the system came up looking for the config sys file. They thought they fixed it but then the hard drive failed.

A few weeks later my son's computer crapped out and they said his hard drive was failing also.

So, there was not specific event here. They just all crapped out and got worse at the shop. while at the shop, the guy was complaining that all four computers he had on the bench had suffered hard drive failures on the same day on the bench.

I just have a hard time believing in cowinkydinks.

Another part of it is times are tough right now and I don't need to be buying a new computer if you know what I mean.

Re: A question for the Computer Literate OT

#18

Re: A question for the Computer Literate OT

Barry Irby

>Del, I don't know what to say. I provided them the registration number for the XP. It had a legitimate copy on it and I thought they could down load it again. They did not indicate it was a boot leg copy.

Other than getting tangled up in WORD and it saying the files were Read Only I have not had any other problems. Oddly, the first three or four files I did in Word came up as read only. Then those files just disappeared and all has been well. I find it to be strange that the offending files just went away.

Re: A question for the Computer Literate OT

#19

I have repaired computers 20 + years

Dustmaker Mike

>and that sounds like pure BS. If you know the MFG of your hard drive they have a test you can get from them for FREE to test the hard drive and see why it failed or if it is really bad. The whole test takes about 10 minutes and if it passes the drive is good if not the drive is bad. If it repairs sectors and states the drive is now good run it again to be sure then reinstall software. Any one who can turn a screw driver can replace parts in modern computers it really is pretty simple. The cost of replacement parts is way down also if you don't need or want the latest and greatest. I also instruct computer repair for the company I currently work for.

Re: A question for the Computer Literate OT

#20

Stay away from that shop plus Antivirus

davhamm

>I use to be an AVG fan, but they bloated it up. I now use Avast (its free). I don't like Norton or Macfee to much bloat, and why pay when I can get a better product free.

Microsoft is not bombing computers. Get a new shop.

Re: A question for the Computer Literate OT

#21

Good for you but...

davhamm

>The CPU is just the little square wafer with the big heat sink and fan on it.

But yes PC's are pretty easy to swap parts on. The software fixes get to be a bit trickier.

Re: A question for the Computer Literate OT

#22

Shops power might be bad...

davhamm

>sounds like the shop had a brown out or drawing to much from one circuit (local brownout) and messed up a bunch of folks hard drives... NICE.

Buy a new hard drive and install your software(you still have the original disks right). Its easy to do.

Re: A question for the Computer Literate OT

#23

Re: Definitely way over five years old....

wilbur

>I know what you mean about not needing to replace a computer now. I just had to replace the furnace in my house this week.

In this case, it may be that the reason all of your computers are failing is simply old age (for a computer, that is). As I said before, computer components are definitely not built for posterity. And although I'm sure that there are some who have computers running for a very long time, the fact is that over time electronic components wear out with heat, vibration, and use.

In woodworking terms, it's kind of like trying to figure out why your bandsaw blade isn't cutting as well as it used to after resawing several hundred feet of black locust.

Re: A question for the Computer Literate OT

#24

Re: I have repaired computers 20 + years

Jerry Nicholson

>And some of them don't even need a screwdriver, like the HP I have sitting on the bench right now. It wouldn't boot consistently so the owner's son stuck in the system restore disk which of course reformatted the drive right off the bat. Then the recovery failed because the second restore disk was badly smudged. I had to order a whole new set of restore disks to get it going again. I considered installing Win 7 to bypass the whole system restore fiasco. (I tried the Win 7 RC and it worked fine).

Jerry