Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

8" jointer chices

Posts

8" jointer chices

#1

8" jointer chices

John Foster

>Hello all; my wife and I are currently shopping for a 8" jointer. based on reputation and nationality (we are Canadian) we are looking at General Machinery models. Needless to say, quality costs! So here are a whole batch of questions. 1.)Are North American machines worth twice the money as imports? 2.) how do General International's Taiwanese models compare to other imports? 3.) Are helical cutterheads worth the money? 4.) what about Delta dj-20's , they seem to have both a U.S.A. made and an Oriental made model, anyone have any experience with either? 5.) in our town there is a woodshop having an auction next Saturday, they have a 8" Canadian made General for sale; what should you look for in a used jointer? 6.) While we are not professionals , we prefer to buy things only once, so quality is important, are there any other quality jointers out there, N.A. or imports? Thanks for any help John and Susan Foster.

Re: 8" jointer chices

#2

Bart Goldberg

Re: 8" jointer chices

Bart Goldberg

>I can't answer all your question, but I will tell you that I would not consider any model that could not be upgraded with an Helical cutter head. I upgraded my Delta DJ -20 and I absolutely love the improvement. Worth every penny it cost to do the upgrade.

Work Safe

Bart

Re: 8" jointer chices

#3

Re: 8" jointer chices

McKay

>I have a DJ 20 and I will be upgrading to a helical. The reason? I have an 8" powermatic at the school that I teach at and it makes a huuuge difference on figured woods. On the 12" jointer I changed the head and the jointer is much nicer to use. If I had my way, I would purchase General over Delta, Powermatic or Jet. Delta is now owned by Stanley and I would wonder if they will gut Delta like Dewalt gutted Porter CAble. Powermatic has cheapened their electronics to the point where I consider them to be much less quality than the others. I have had to replace the switch twice on the 8" jointer and three times on the Powermatic up-cut. The wide belt is only a year old and still seems to be ok. Best of luck on your purchase.

Re: 8" jointer chices

#4

Grizzly *LINK*

mdclor

>I think any of the Asian made products can be fine, it just depends on the specs and QC the importer uses. I have a Grizzly G453Z with a spiral head and absolutely love it. As mentioned, tear out is almost non-existent with the spiral cutter. It is also quieter. I think Grizzly offers good value in most of their products. Just not sure if you can get them in Canada.

HTH,

Merle


G453Z

Re: 8" jointer chices

#5

JL

Re: 8" jointer chices

JL

>I have an 8" jointer. If I were to upgrade, I would consider a helical cutter head.

IMO, I don't know if there are enough differences in any 8" jointer to justify paying twice the amount for any of them. That being said - if I were purchasing a jointer today, I would go for the heaviest machine with the longest bed. Grizzly, Steel City and General International all make excellent jointers. I can't really speak for modern Deltas. I never really investigated Powermatics as they were too pricy.

Re: 8" jointer chices

#6

Ellis Walentine

Get the used General

Ellis Walentine

>Jointers are pretty simple machines, and well within the manufacturing capability of China and Taiwan where most are made these days. As long as the tables are flat, you can generally tune them to work perfectly and last forever.

I don't see a lot of difference among the imports, but it's a good idea to buy a reputable brand from a dealer you trust, and make sure they're willing to fix any problems such as warped beds. Most of the fence systems on the Chinese/Taiwanese machines are rather crudely engineered and made -- not nearly as rewarding to adjust as a well-made North American fence such as you find on Delta, Powermatic, General (Canada).

The Canadian-made General jointer is a very well-made machine, with nice polished handwheels. In a test of jointers we did at American Woodworker in the mid 90s, it rated higher than any of the Asian models and just behind the DJ-20. It had the best fence in the test, but the bed was a little shorter than the others -- not a huge problem. Old jointers are pretty bulletproof, so I wouldn't worry too much about buying a used one, but it can't hurt to take a straightedge along to check that the tables are coplanar. Even if they aren't, you can shim the ways to straighten them out. Plus, if you're lucky, you might be able to get it for less than you'd pay for a new Asian jointer.

The DJ-20 is a fine machine and a lot of knowledgeable woodworkers opt for this model. We had one at the old AW shop and it was great. Delta's QC in Taiwan is quite good, so you're not likely to get a clunker. The parallelogram-style table suspension system is very smooth and easy to adjust, although I personally prefer a handwheel to a lever on the infeed table. A lever tends to move the table too much, too easily, while a handwheel can be adjusted with more control over small changes in height. As long as the tables don't get out of alignment, you'd be very happy with this machine. Fixing the table adjustment is complicated and difficult but shouldn't ever be neccessary.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: 8" jointer chices

#7

Re: 8" jointer chices

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>Ellis made some very intelligent comments. Personally I don't rely on my joiner to be extremely accurate. For instance, when I am edge joining for a panel or table top I always alternate the face side of the boards on the joiner to eliminate any "out of 90 deg." conditions (Even though the boards measure perfectly square when checked with a precision machinist square). When face jointing, I only use the joiner to even the surface enough to allow me to move to the planer. That said, I have been extremely satisfied with the two Grizzly joiners I have owned. I had a 6" for several years with straight blades that served me very well and stayed very co-planer during the 15~20 years I used (and mishandled) it. At that time I didn't have a shop and often moved the joiner by lifting it at the end of the beds, to move it where I could use it. The only issue I had with it was some tearout on gnarly, or brittle woods. I checked it just before selling it to a friend and it was still within .002 of flat and co-planer. I purchased a new 8" Grizzly with the Grizzly spiral head and was amazed to see all tearout vanish. I have a 5 hp, 20" Yorkcraft planer (an import previously sold by Wilke machinery) with a Byrd spiral head. I can see no appreciable difference in the surface finish of the two heads so I think anyone would be very satisfied with the Grizzly. I do agree that the imported machinery does not have the "fit and finish" of the American, Canadian or European machines. However I don't think imported Delta/Powermatic equipment is quite as good as Grizzly. I purchased a new Powermatic PM 2800 drill press and it is actually worse in fit and finish than any of the Grizzly equipment I own or have seen. I have Powermatic, Delta, Dewalt, Grizzly, MinMax, Fisch and other equipment in my shop and do much prefer to purchase American or European equipment if available and affordable.

Re: 8" jointer chices

#8

Re: 8" jointer chices

Jesse Cloud

>I have been using a DJ-20 for a long time. Always did everything I needed, though helical sounds cool.

Is there a used machinery market in your area? Don't hesitate to look at the older machines. They were made better and unless terribly abused should still perform well at a sweet price.

Re: 8" jointer chices

#9

Ellis Walentine

Old machinery

Ellis Walentine

>Good point about older machines. In my old shop we had an old Colliday 16" jointer with babbit bearings that ran just fine. It was mighty nice to have that width capacity, too. I've seen many old "heavy iron" jointers in the 12" to 20" range that sold for under $1,000. Usually the only thing they need is a phase converter or a different motor. If you need dust collection, you might be in for some fancy sheet metal work, as most of the old machines had open chasses. Check out used machinery dealers and also the auction guys. A lot of older millwork and production shops are going out of business. If you can find an old Oliver, snap it up. Those things were the best ever, IMO.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: 8" jointer chices

#10

Re: 8" jointer chices

Fred Davis

>John,

I tend to agree with Ellis about the General or a used Oliver especially the Oliver.

For myself this last shop of mine got a new DJ-20, ran fine for years, developed adjustment problems with the eccentric adjusters that Delta couldn't fix , so they replaced it with a DJ-20X which has a five year warranty.

I paid to upgrade it with a Shellix Helical head and couldn't be happier with the result. Delta's willingness to stand closely behind their product makes them head and shoulders above any less quality machine or company support in my view.

FredD

All of that said in your case, the General is a fine machine and if it can be upgraded with a Helical head , I wouldn't hesitate a second on getting it . You will see as others have stated, that Helical head is a huge improvement over a standard knife head.

Since it is a stationary machine that does a lot of work in seconds , don't let dollars be the overriding factor in the choice, a good machine's cost spread over it's lifetime is very easy on your pocketbook

Re: 8" jointer chices

#11

Grizzly Cutter Heads

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

>They will also sell you a spiral cutter head for a General 80 series or 480-1 for $275 or a Byrd Shelix head for $325.

Re: 8" jointer chices

#12

Re: Old machinery

Kneale Brownson..Back enjoying CO snow

>What about a new Oliver?

Re: 8" jointer chices

#13

Re: 8" jointer chices

Jim Dillon

>John,

I have had my 8-inch General (Canadian made) jointer for roughly 13-14 years now and it has been great and never gone out of adjustment. I've changed cutter blades once, and that was after milling a lot of jatoba (a very hard wood) and hickory. I would love to get the helical head for it sometime in the future. Yes, it has a shorter bed than the Delta (or at least did; I really haven't kept up on jointers), but that has never been a problem because I just use an adjustable sawhorse for anything over six feet or so, and I have done 12 footers on it with no problem. For value, the Grizzly seems nice to me, as others have suggested. I live in the US and purchased mine directly from Canada when the dollar was a lot weaker - so the General was even more attractive. As you live in Canada, I would give the Canadian made General line a serious look. I don't know anything about their international line.

Jim

Re: 8" jointer chices

#14

Re: 8" jointer chices

John Foster

>Thanks for all the responses; lots of good information. john

Re: 8" jointer chices

#15

Re: 8" jointer chices

Jim Dillon

>John and Susan,

Sorry, I meant to say "...when the dollar was a lot stronger."

Jim Shaver, a WC member and Canadian, has both a General TS and jointer IIRC. I hope he sees this thread and can respond. Some time ago he posted on WC a nice tutorial on replacing his normal General jointer head with a helical one.

Let us know what you decide to do, if you do purchase a jointer; we like to keep up on what is currently available and the experiences folks have with their purchases. Well, at least I'm nosy that way 8-).

Jim

Jim

Re: 8" jointer chices

#16

Re: 8" jointer chices

Rick Garner

>I have late 90's 8" PM. One solid and stable machine. From all I've read the Byrd shelix cutter heads is about the only improvement I could make to it. Unfortunately the finances don't allow at this time.

My suggestion to you would be to get the General at the auction and then check out www.holbren.com for the Byrd cutter head. If you get the General for a decent price, it will hold it's value forever.

Good luck with your decision.