Yes...
Howard In Toronto
>and no....
I've made living room cabinets entirely out of MDF
(the doors are frame and panel affairs and zero problems)
I've made book cases for my two boys, Genghis and Attila
(two are eight feet long with an uninterrupted shelf span and no vertical centre support)
You just need to know how to engineer for MDF
You'll never never never experience sag - in ANY direction
I've made shop furniture galore out of MDF
And that's in an unheated, un-air-conditioned garage shop in Toronto where the humidity some summers can approach 80%
So.....
here's what you do.....
- seal EVERY surface with paint or lacquer
- use simple housed joints like dadoes and grooves, nuttin fancy like sliding dovetails
- use the correct number of hinges
- if it's going to be a high-usage cabinet use thru-bolts and nuts on the hinges rather than screws
BUT DO NOT POUR WATER ON - OR SUBMERGE - YOUR CABINETS
because
yes it's true
MDF reacts badly to moisture
so don't make them wet
conversely
wipe up any fluids promptly if you do
I say this somewhat tongue-in-cheek because I use milk paint on almost all my MDF furniture which is just about 100% WATER and no problems
I'm a big fan
The pluses of MDF outweigh the dust and weight and screw holding abilities because it's CHEAP and FLAT and UNIFORM
And if you change your usage patterns and can't repurpose the cabinet, it's cheap enough to throw out
My 2C
HTH
Howard