Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Dado or rabbet on bottom?

Posts

Dado or rabbet on bottom?

#1

JL

Dado or rabbet on bottom?

JL

>I'm thinking about making a chest out of ash (uncertain as to the exact type). Anyway, I was thinking about either resawing or planing down some ash for the bottom of the chest instead of using plywood.

My rough calculations with a wood movement calculator gave me a dimensional change of about 0.2" or so for the 16" width of the prospective bottom. Not too terrible.

As I am planning on using wood instead of plywood, which makes more sense in terms of aesthetics and strength? Dado or rabbet for the chest bottom?

Re: Dado or rabbet on bottom?

#2

Re: Dado or rabbet on bottom?

Barry Irby

>JL, I was typing away about a chest of drawers until I realized you said CHEST. If you mean a chest like a blanket chest, I would use a rabbett and fasten (Glue) the boards in the center of the sides for about four or five inches and let the front and back float. Assuming a cross grain connection with the ends. If the grain in the ends runs vertically you could glue it all the way across, but then you would have to Dael with the cross grin issue in the vertical corners.

Re: Dado or rabbet on bottom?

#3

D@mn spell checker, oops

Barry Irby

>Not Dael with the cross grin connection, deal with the cross grain connection. I don't even know what a Dael is. I need a better proof reader.

Re: Dado or rabbet on bottom?

#4

Dale Lenz

Re: I vote for Dado's

Dale Lenz

>Think it looks more professional and probably stronger. If you have an open rabbet, all the downward force is going to be applied to the fasteners. You could use fasteners through the bottom panel to the top of the rabbet or glue cauls to the bottom of the rabbet's sides, more trouble than dado, IMO.

True plywood, several plys of the same species, in your case, ash, is more stronger than ash lumber of the same thickness. However, don't see a problem if you wish to use ash lumber for the bottom panel as long as you account for wood movement and build according.

Re: Dado or rabbet on bottom?

#5

Re: Dado or rabbet on bottom?

John McGaw

>I've used various methods and materials for blanket boxes and such but have always avoided the use of plywood. A dado is a fine method of supporting a bottom. I prefer to thin the edges of the bottom on one surface (think Shaker-style frame and panel door where the taper does not show). This allows me to place the dado just a bit higher in the chest for strength without raising the bottom more than necessary. Of course wood movement demands that the bottom not be secured in the dado and I find it best not to make the bottom a single glued-up piece. I've used variations of loose tongue and groove and shiplap joints in building up the bottoms and have never had a problem even when using relatively weak wood like aromatic cedar (juniper).

Re: Dado or rabbet on bottom?

#6

Bart Goldberg

Re: Dado or rabbet on bottom?

Bart Goldberg

>I would definitely go with dado's as the provide for wood movement. I would also use space balls or some other type of sponge filler to keep the panel well fit and still allow for wood movement.

Bart

Re: Dado or rabbet on bottom?

#7

Agree With Dado, But Would use Plywood

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>

Re: Dado or rabbet on bottom?

#8

Bart Goldberg

Agree - Stick with Plywood -

Bart Goldberg

>

Re: Dado or rabbet on bottom?

#9

Aesthetics and Strength

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon JL,

Mill some ash to 1/4"~3/16" slats and pin to the plywood base after it is installed. The inside bottom will look solid stock, the pins won't be seen, and the ply can be glued in all around making it super strong.

George

Re: Dado or rabbet on bottom?

#10

Re: Dado or rabbet on bottom?

Jim Dillon

>JL,

A variation on what George suggested is to employ the concept of a drawer slip, only for your chest. The slip can have a variety of decorative profiles, with the bottom encorporating a tongue, rabbet, or raised (Shaker-style) panel. With this technique, no dado or rabbet is cut into the chest, thus minimizing any structural weakness. I used this technique for thin-walled drawers and it has worked well. Otherwise, a top and bottom ledger would work well too and allow more forgiveness expansionwise.

Jim

Re: Dado or rabbet on bottom?

#11

JL

Clever, hadn't thought of that.

JL

>