Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Water Heater pop-offs OT

Posts

Water Heater pop-offs OT

#1

Water Heater pop-offs OT

Randy Johnson Connersville IN

>I encountered a problem today that is going to cost one of my company�s customers a lot of money, and since it�s possible some of you here might have a similar setup I want to pass it along.

My main job responsibility is reading gas meters. Part of the job is finding out why usages on individual meters are significantly higher or lower than normal for any given month. Today, one meter showed a usage that was a little over four times what it should have been. The homeowner invited me to check things out and I found a pop-off valve on the water heater stuck in the open position. He was not aware of it because a hose was attached to the tube coming out of the valve. In turn, the hose was stuck inside a 1 � drain pipe. The water heater had been draining unnoticed for who knows how long, all the while running the burner almost if not constantly. This particular customer�s problem was compounded by having an almost unheard of 100 gallon water heater. (More gas being used while the burner is on.) Just the cost of his gas this month before all the little add-ons like service charges and taxes is going to be a little over $330. His water bill will also be higher.

If any of you have a setup like I have described, or have the relief tube stuck through the floor into a crawl space, CHANGE IT! The end of the relief tube should be easily visible so you will know if the pop-off has stuck open.

We find this problem more often than you might think.

Re: Water Heater pop-offs OT

#2

You are killing me Randy......

Barry Irby

>As a Home Inspector I find this stuff all the time. If you are going to have people fix it for themselves and save money on water and gas, what am I to do? I could starve to death. ;>)

There are several issues here. The hose worries me. The relief tube should be full size and unrestricted. If the hose is under sized or has a kink in it. the relief valve may not be able to discharge. If the discharge fails the water heater could explode. (Google Exploding Water Heaters or some such thing, it really does happen.)

If the unit discharges inside the house and goes unnoticed, it can do enormous damage. IF the unit discharges while you are standing there you can get a horrific steam burn.

If you go look at your water heater and it does not have a discharge tube and the valve is looking back at you, you should have it corrected. I see them by the dozens.

If the relief tube extends through an outside wall and it leaks slowly and freezes, it can be blocked and cause the above mentioned explosion.

The best setup might be to have a pan under the water heater that has a drain to the outside and the relief tube extend into the pan, but not touching the bottom of the pan. That way, the water would hopefully run out side safely, you would see it soon enough and if the exterior drain failed, was blocked, or froze, the pan would over flow, but the unit could still vent.

I have seen several houses with exploding water heaters and at least a dozen that were damaged by leaking relief valves. A friend had a rental house where the valve was discharging into the crawl space. The tenant was griping about high water bills and high electric bills. By the time the guy sent me to check it out, the crawl space was full of water and the floor system had been steamed to pieces.

Re: Water Heater pop-offs OT

#3

Re: You are killing me Randy......

Randy Johnson Connersville IN

>In the case I cited, the WH was in a location where venting on the floor would have been messy, but since the floor was concrete no real damage could have been done. Had it been a wood floor your suggestion of a pan is the way to go.

A month or two ago a customer called to complain about a high gas bill in a vacant rental. The entry to the basement was outside. The guy unlocked the door, and by the time I was on the second step I knew what cataracts are like because my glasses were fogged over. There was about two inches of warm water on the floor.

Years ago when I worked for a nursing home, I would often do little quick jobs for coworkers to save them from having to pay a contractor some outrageous amount for a simple job. I was cheap, as in free. One I will NEVER forget. The girl had had way more than her share of life�s troubles. She had not seen her 40th birthday yet and she was already a veteran of a couple of heart surgeries and had recently lost her husband to cancer. She was afraid that there might be something wrong with the way her water heater was wired and she wanted me to look at it. The wiring was okay but��There was NO relief valve on the water heater. She asked me if that was a problem. I answered by killing the power and opening all her hot water faucets. I removed the anode that was screwed in where the relief valve should have been and installed a relief valve in its place. It�s a good thing she wasn�t one to have the thermostat as high as it would go.

Re: Water Heater pop-offs OT

#4

Re: You are killing me Randy......

Barry Irby

>Many years ago a friend of mine wanted to be a Fireman. His dream job. Finally got on with the local Department. This was before 911. A day or two after he got the job a woman calls in, screaming about the water heater just flew out through the roof. They sent the Rookie. Sure Enough, the water heater had flown out through the roof. Her husband had installed and new water heater. In those days you had to buy the TPR valve separately. He did not have one and did not know what that extra hole was for, so he took the old drain valve out of the old heater and screwed it into the hole. Turned it on and left for work. Turns out the element must have been stuck in the ON position. The tank super heated, the bottom blew out of it and the tank went out through the roof. They found it about a block away.

They claim the go to about 300 degrees and the steel fails. The water flashes to steam and expands 1800 to 1. I saw a house where one went off int he basement and it picked the house up, rotated it about twenty degrees and draped it across the basement.

Re: Water Heater pop-offs OT

#5

Re: You are killing me Randy......

Gary Evans--Tallassee TN

>Mythbusters did this on purpose. They built a little shed to local building codes and put the water heater in it. Not only did it totally destroy the shed, it launched the water heater to around 500 ft. in the air, if I remember correctly.

Gary

Re: Water Heater pop-offs OT

#6

I have no doubt......

Barry Irby

>it would kill you if you were close by. At best, you would be badly scalded. I've seen several houses where they blew up and it was clear it was truly an explosion and a very powerful one. I've also seen several houses where there was a gas leak and an explosion. Very similar. One lifted the house off the foundation and blew the brick veneer off it and the other demolished the house.

Re: Water Heater pop-offs OT

#7

Stupid question

Randy Johnson Connersville IN

>I have never seen even the result of an exploded water heater let alone actually see it happen. (i.e. mythbusters)It seems like whenever I've heard it discussed, "going through the roof" is part of the description. Why wouldn't it just explode more or less evenly like a firecracker instead of blowing the pressure out of one end?

Re: Water Heater pop-offs OT

#8

Tank's probably weaker at the bottom...

John in NM

>That's where they tend to rust out. Blows out the bottom, sends the WH up like a big one of those little water rocket toys.

Re: Water Heater pop-offs OT

#9

Re: Tank's probably weaker at the bottom...

Barry Irby

>John's guess is as good as mine. The one that I know went through the roof was new. The bottom is welded in. Perhaps the weld is weaker than the rest of the tank. OTOH, the tank is made by rolling a flat piece of steel into a cylinder, welding a side seam and welding in a top and bottom. Don't know why one would fail more than the others.

The water heater industry posted a video of one blowing up. They had dug a pit for it and it launched itself out of the pit. In that case, it may have blown out of the pit almost regardless of where the failure occurred on the tank.