Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Woodcraft and Lie-Nielsen

Posts

Woodcraft and Lie-Nielsen

#1

Woodcraft and Lie-Nielsen

Eric Kuehne

>OK, maybe I'm behind the curve but I needed a router bit for work yesterday and wound up at the San Carlos, CA woodcraft who had a sign on their door the said "Lie-Nielsen close out. 15% off all remaining stock". I inquired and the salesman said that Lie-Nielsen was ending the relationship as they don't want to handle the scale of business that Woodcraft represents. They (LN) want more of a "boutique" sales model. His opinion was that you probably wouldn't be able to handle a plane before buying anymore. (For you Bay Area types I assume he wasn't taking Japan Woodworker in to account.)

I did a search here and came up dry. And I just way behind the times? Anyone have any tidbits, corrections or clarity to add?

Thanks,

Eric in Los Gatos

Re: Woodcraft and Lie-Nielsen

#2

Re: Woodcraft and Lie-Nielsen

mike from american sycamore

>Oh What tangled webs we weave....What I heard was that Wood Craft shipped Lie-Nielsen hand planes from their stock to China and had them copied. Wood Craft is now selling Knock-Offs made in China and probably at a much higher margin than what they made on Lie-Nielsen.

Shame on Wood Craft!

Re: Woodcraft and Lie-Nielsen

#3

Re: Woodcraft and Lie-Nielsen

Fred Davis

>OT

can you tell me if the Circle Star Theater is going in San Carlos?

Great place for entertainment and the food wasn't bad either.

FredD

Re: Woodcraft and Lie-Nielsen

#4

Circle Star is long gone

Neal in San Jose

>I don't remember when, exactly, but it has to be at least 20 years. I saw Peter, Paul and Mary there back in their prime, and many others, but CS is no more.

But to the question of Lie Nielson and Woodcraft. I teach handplanes at the Dublin CA Woodcraft, and according to the owner (as of Sunday, anyway), LN and Woodcraft have reached a new agreement with less discount to Woodcraft. I'm not sure what the new line of Wood River planes has to do with this, but the "boutique" part sounds about right for LN. The story I got was that LN wanted a larger slice of the (retail) pie. Since LN shamelessly copied Stanley's Bedrock design, then who did Woodcraft really copy?

Has anyone else tried the new Wood River planes that Woodcraft is selling? I bought the #4 and have had my hands on a (fairly poorly tuned) #5, and I have to say I'm impressed. I'm really happy about this, since Stanley clearly dropped the ball with their re-entry to the quality plane market. A modestly priced plane that actually works; what's next?

Neal

Re: Woodcraft and Lie-Nielsen

#5

Don't you mean shame on Nie Nielson?

Neal in San Jose

>Did you happen to notice that LN copied Stanley's Bedrock design? And Ohio Tool? And Record? Anybody else? Who is Woodcraft actually copying, then?

Neal, happy owner of 5 LN and 1 Wood River as well as many Stanleys and Ohio Tools and Records......

Re: Woodcraft and Lie-Nielsen

#6

I don't think there's anything legal involved, but

Simon St.Laurent - Dryden, NY

>Somehow it seems to me that Woodcraft would have been smarter to copy Bedrock planes directly, as L-N did, than to copy L-N planes, and aggravate a supplier whose reputation helps their stores.

If that's what actually happened, anyway.

Re: Woodcraft and Lie-Nielsen

#7

Re: Woodcraft and Lie-Nielsen

Dean Lapinel

>I'm sure it's a fine plane but I would rather support a North American or European country over China at this time.

Re: Woodcraft and Lie-Nielsen

#8

Re: Woodcraft and Lie-Nielsen

Eric Kuehne

>Just remembered that the guy also said something about Pinnacle wanting to get in the game. They seem to make nice enough stuff and I might be interested if they knocked about 50% off the price. Apparently they want to get into the plane market too. Hmmm.

Eric in Los Gatos

Re: Woodcraft and Lie-Nielsen

#9

Who is Pinnacle?

Tony - Memphis

>I've noticed their stuff in Woodcraft. I wondered if it was house brand. Their stuff looks to be of a higher level quality. haven't purchased any yet.

I'm not interested in arguing the point of Wodcraft vs. LN vs China, etc. But....I do like that I with one email or one phone call, I can get anythign I need fixed, answered, tips on using, etc. from LN. Could probably get Tom on the phone (he has sent me emails before when I had an issue). Woodcraft offers great customer service, but no quite to that level. It is hard though to ignore the price delta between the planes. I don't own many LN', but I feel like I'm using a piece of art when I use them - very nice. I guess its good that there are options to meet everybody's needs and desires.

Tony

Re: Woodcraft and Lie-Nielsen

#10

Why?

wilbur

>This is probably wandering too far over the politics line, but if it's a domestic economy thing you're concerned with, why favor European countries over Asian ones? Whether you buy a product made in Asia or Europe or Canada (I'm making the assumption that you are in the USA), a purchase from a non-domestic country impacts our trade deficit the same way.

Re: Woodcraft and Lie-Nielsen

#11

Steven Antonucci

Human rights, IP law, innovation, take your pick!

steve antonucci

>I have a real issue these days with "cheap labor" being the unique selling point of anything. As the third world commoditizes manufacturing and other industries, the first world (the US in particular) gets lower prices at but at the long term detriment to the US economy.

I firmly believe that China should lift up it's own people through innovation, not by commoditzing American ingenuity. If "we can make it cheaper because we pay our people nothing" is the message, I don't care to hear it. I'll pay more to know it was made here and by people that care, not just someone who wanted our money.

You asked, that's my answer.

steve

Re: Woodcraft and Lie-Nielsen

#12

Re: Why?

Fred Davis

>Exactly Wilbur,

I have preached and beat this issue to death and I still maintain if you use a plane for it's functionality , rather then a Avant Garde idea of one, then I believe many of the older planes Stanley made, along with Miller Falls and Sargent when tuned up as all planes should be , will exceed the capability of the user to get any better or finer surface with a far more costly knockoff.

One thing Lee G. said not to long ago "Trophy Tools" rings a bell with this subject for me.

Though he wasn't talking about planes at the time.

FredD

Re: Woodcraft and Lie-Nielsen

#13

Pinnacle is Woodcraft *LINK*

Craig Daymon

>The Pinnacle router plates and most of the Pinnacle measuring and marking products are relabelled Woodpecker products, made by Woodpecker for Woodcraft. Woodpecker makes a reasonable range of products, though I don't know that they are making any planes. All seem to be very good quality. I have their router plate.

I suspect Woodcraft is just using the Pinnacle name to bring in different vendors under one name. That way if a relationship goes bad they can switch to a different vendor and keep the name. Same thing Home Depot does with Rigid tools.


Woodpecker, Inc.

Re: Woodcraft and Lie-Nielsen

#14

Re: Why?

ThomD

>Of course trade deficit is just one aspect. Even there I am not sure... What if the country you buy from has a trade deficit to your favour? I think the trade deficit Canada US is probably to our/Can favour, and if so it probably has more to do with US oil purchases up here. Which is a good deal for you (greenhouse aside). But beyond that Canadians need your dollars to buy your products, virtually anything I have craved in 50 years has been from the US. I don't know if the chinese or even euros, feel the same way.

Re: Woodcraft and Lie-Nielsen

#15

Re: Why?

Steve in East Tennessee

>I bought a Miller Falls No. 5 from a yard sale for $5. Flattened, polished, repainted, and added a decent Hock Iron plane blade, and as the good Dr. Tindall would say, I produce "gossamer shavings" to my heart's content. Total investment: about $45 and a weekend spent on restoration with the satisfaction that I brought a pretty good tool back to life. Or I could just go to the internet and have a similar quality tool show up at my door in a couple of days for $250.

Disclaimer: I have never used a Lie Nielson bench plane, but it would have to run itself to work better than my reconditioned Miller Falls. The Miller Falls line might be pretty ubiquitous abd generic, but it is one of my "trophy tools."